The White Dwarf Pareto: Tracing Mass Loss in Binary Systems

Sahar Shahaf · 2025

Read The White Dwarf Pareto: Tracing Mass Loss in Binary Systems by Sahar Shahaf (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-09586.txt.

Introduction

Sahar Shahaf shows how the masses of white dwarfs in wide pairs reveal how much mass their parent stars lost. Her 2025 paper studies pairs spaced at about one Earth-Sun distance. Past work focused on lone dwarfs and on very close pairs. This middle ground is where pair effects should show in a softer form. Shahaf models the pair mass-ratio pattern with a truncated power-law curve and reads the dwarf share from its shape.

A test case uses pairs in star clusters where a red giant orbits with a dwarf. The dwarfs there weigh about a fifth less than lone dwarfs. Their parent stars appear to have shed most of their mass. Pair effects add a further slice of loss beyond lone-star winds. The method can scale to the huge pair samples coming from new sky surveys.

Catalog record

CREATORSahar Shahaf
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE46 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-09586

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The White Dwarf Pareto: Tracing Mass Loss in Binary Systems Sahar Shahaf Abstract The white dwarf mass distribution has been studied primarily at two extremes: objects that presumably evolved as single stars and members of close binaries that likely underwent substantial interaction. This work considers the intermediate separation regime of ∼ 1 {\sim}\,1 au and demonstrates how binary interaction affects white dwarf masses. The binary mass ratio distribution is utilized for this purpose. Modeled as a truncated Pareto profile, this distribution provides insights into the populations’ properties and evolutionary history. When applied to homogeneous samples of binaries with giant primaries of similar age, the distribution’s shape constrains the fraction of white dwarf companions, the white dwarf mass distribution, and the properties of their progenitors. As a test case, this method is applied to a small spectroscopic sample of binaries in open clusters with red giant primaries and orbital periods between 0.5 0.5 and 20 20 years. The analysis reveals that white dwarfs in these systems are ∼ 20 % {\sim}\,20\% less massive than their isolated counterparts, with a typical mass of ∼ 0.55 ​ M ⊙ {\sim}\,0.55\,\small\rm M_{\odot} . Their progenitors likely lost 80 − 85 % 80-85\% of their mass, with binary interactions enhancing mass loss by an additional ∼ 0.2 ​ M ⊙ {\sim}\,0.2\,\small\rm M_{\odot} . These findings highlight the utility of this approach for studying binary evolution and improving population models, particularly with future datasets from Gaia and other large-scale surveys. This work used cogsworth and its dependencies [ 74 , 75 , 7 ] ; the Unified Cluster Catalogue [ 55 ] ; emcee [ 24 ] ; numpy [ 53 , 72 ] ; and scipy [ 73 ] . I Introduction Stellar multiplicity is established during the early stages of star formation, with primordial configurations dynamically evolving to produce the observed populations of single, binary, and higher-order multiple systems [ 41 , 57 , 5 , 60 , 52 ] . Binary systems are particularly prevalent, comprising about half of all Sun-like stars, three-quarters of A-type stars, and nearly all B- and O-type stars [ 56 , 19 , 52 , e.g.,] . The high occurrence of binaries significantly influences various astrophysical processes, a fact recognized even before large samples became available, motivating early empirical studies of binary populations over a century ago [ 70 , 54 , 40 , e.g.,] . Whether single or part of a binary system, all stars eventually exhaust their nuclear energy supplies, leaving behind stellar remnants, most commonly white dwarfs [ 2 ] . Despite the high frequency of white dwarfs, with hundreds of thousands already discovered either in binaries or isolation [ 25 , 63 ] , key aspects of their population remain incompletely understood [ 35 , 27 , e.g.,] . In particular, the relationship between a white dwarf’s mass and that of its progenitor star, known as the initial-to-final mass relation, or the IFMR, remains an area of active research [ 69 , 15 , 16 , 22 , 17 , 33 , 1 ] . The extent to which binarity affects the mass of white dwarfs strongly depends on the orbital separation. At sufficiently large separations, the two stars are expected to evolve independently [ 4 , 33 , 30 ] . However, at close separation, binary interaction plays an important role. It becomes evident when considering the population of extremely low-mass [ 9 , 39 , e.g.,] , ultramassive [ 13 , 23 , 38 ] or highly magnetized white dwarfs [ 49 ] . However, a significant portion of the population presumably exists in neither of these extremities. Still, until recently, white dwarfs in binaries separated by {\sim}1 au have eluded detection [ 32 ] . This situation has changed with the recent data release by the Gaia spacecraft [ 20 , 68 ] . The astrometric and spectroscopic orbits from Gaia uncovered a large population of binaries comprised of a white dwarf and main sequence star at this intermediate separation regime [ 63 , 76 , 77 ] . Some of the emerging properties of this population already provided new insights and challenges to stellar and binary evolution models [ 27 , 63 , 76 , 58 ] . This work presents a method to estimate the white dwarf mass distribution and constrain the IFMR using binaries where the primary star is a red giant. A truncated power-law (i.e., a Pareto distribution) approximates the mass ratio distribution, whose properties are sensitive to the IFMR parameters. This approach can be applied to spectroscopic binary samples, allowing exploration across a wide range of orbital separations and offering new insights into binary and stellar evolution in regimes that have been previously underexplored. The structure of the paper is as follows: Section II presents the expected shape of the mass ratio and modified mass function distributions; Section III applies this model, as a test case, to a spectroscopic sample of binaries with red giant primaries from open clusters. The results are discussed in Section IV . Section V summarizes the findings and outlines avenues for future study. II Companions of giant stars II.1 The white dwarf fraction Consider an open star cluster of age \tau . The cluster’s turnoff mass, m_{\tau} , defines the threshold above which stars have evolved off the main sequence. Now, suppose a binary system is identified in this cluster, where the primary star is a red giant of mass m_{\scriptsize\textsc{rg}} , and the secondary is too faint to be directly identified. The mass of the secondary can be constrained indirectly from the orbital motion of the primary. However, determining its exact nature based solely on the orbital elements and primary mass is challenging. For example, without additional information, it is difficult to determine whether a {\sim}\,0.6~\small\rm M_{\odot} companion of a red giant is a white dwarf or a late-type main sequence star [ 66 , e.g.,] . Nevertheless, compared to unequivocal classification, statistical estimates are often more feasible. The occurrence rate of white dwarf companions stems from the properties of the primordial, zero-age main sequence population. To model it, assume that the distribution of primordial primary masses, m_{1} , is similar to the Salpeter [61] initial mass function, where \alpha signifies the exponential index of the distribution. The primordial mass ratio distribution is taken to be flat so that the secondary mass, m_{2} , is uniformly distributed between 0 and m_{1} . These assumptions yield a bivariate density function, \Phi(m_{1},m_{2})\propto m_{1}^{-(\alpha+1)} (1) if 0<m_{2}\leq m_{1} and zero otherwise. The impact of deviations from uniformity on the inferred properties of the sample is discussed below. To assess the probability of the secondary companion being a white dwarf, we consider two possible scenarios: first, that the present-day giant star is also the primordial primary, and second, that it is the primordial secondary. In the first scenario, m_{1} can be identified with m_{\scriptsize\textsc{rg}} , assuming insignificant mass loss. Equation ( 1 ) suggests the fraction of systems in this state, {\rm P}_{\scriptsize\textsc{ms}} , is proportional to m_{\scriptsize\textsc{rg}}^{-\alpha} . In this case, the secondary companion is most likely a main-sequence star. Other, less common, evolutionary scenarios are also possible but presumably occur much less

Read the complete text