Countable dense homogeneity and topological groups

Claudio Agostini, Andrea Medini, Lyubomyr Zdomskyy · 2025

Read Countable dense homogeneity and topological groups by Claudio Agostini, Andrea Medini, Lyubomyr Zdomskyy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-09455.txt.

Introduction

Claudio Agostini, Andrea Medini, and Lyubomyr Zdomskyy prove a result in set-based math in this 2025 paper. Their topic is spaces where any two dense sets of a small kind can be swapped by a shape-preserving map. Past work tied such spaces to well-known polished types, which raised the question of whether odd cases must exist.

The team builds a group with the swapping trait that is not of the polished type. Their group sits inside a large product space and has a rare thin-set trait. They also pose a bold guess about such groups and prove it in one narrow case. The work sharpens what pure set rules alone can force in this corner of math.

Catalog record

CREATORClaudio Agostini, Andrea Medini, Lyubomyr Zdomskyy
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE17 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-09455

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Countable dense homogeneity and topological groups Thanks: This research was funded in whole by the Austrian Science Fund (FWF) DOI 10.55776/P35655 (Agostini), 10.55776/P35588 (Medini) and 10.55776/I5930 (Zdomskyy). For open access purposes, the authors have applied a CC BY public copyright license to any authors-accepted manuscript version arising from this submission. Claudio Agostini, Andrea Medini, Lyubomyr Zdomskyy Abstract . Building on results of Medvedev, we construct a 𝖹𝖥𝖢 \mathsf{ZFC} example of a non-Polish topological group that is countable dense homogeneous. Our example is a dense subgroup of ℤ ω \mathbb{Z}^{\omega} of size 𝔟 \mathfrak{b} that is a λ \lambda -set. We also conjecture that every countable dense homogenous Baire topological group with no isolated points contains a copy of the Cantor set, and give a proof in a very special case. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 54H11, 54G20. 1. Introduction As is common in the literature about countable dense homogeneity, all spaces (including groups) are assumed to be separable and metrizable. By group we mean topological group. By countable we mean at most countable. Our reference for general topology is [ En ] . Our reference for groups is [ AT ] . Our reference for descriptive set theory is [ Ke ] . For all other set-theoretic notions, we refer to [ Ku ] . A space X is countable dense homogeneous ( \mathsf{CDH} ) if for every pair (D,E) of countable dense subsets of X there exists a homeomorphism h:X\longrightarrow X such that h[D]=E . The fundamental positive result in the theory of \mathsf{CDH} spaces is due to Anderson, Curtis and van Mill [ ACvM , Theorem 5.2] , and it states that every strongly locally homogeneous Polish space is \mathsf{CDH} . 1 1 1 Recall that a space X is strongly locally homogeneous if there exists a base \mathcal{B} for X such that for every U\in\mathcal{B} and (x,y)\in U\times U there exists a homeomorphism h:X\longrightarrow X such that h(x)=y and h(z)=z for every z\in X\setminus U . In particular, familiar spaces like the Cantor set 2^{\omega} , the Baire space \omega^{\omega} , the Euclidean spaces \mathbb{R}^{n} , the spheres \mathsf{S}^{n} and the Hilbert cube [0,1]^{\omega} are all examples of \mathsf{CDH} spaces. See [ AvM , Sections 14-16] for much more on this topic. Fitzpatrick and Zhou [ FZ1 , Problem 6] asked for non-Polish examples of \mathsf{CDH} spaces (this is Problem 389 from the book “Open problems in topology”), and the present article belongs to this line of research. Consistent examples were constructed in [ FZ1 , Theorem 4.6] and [ BB , Theorem 3.5] . The first \mathsf{ZFC} example was given in [ FHMR ] , using metamathematical methods. Another breakthrough was obtained in [ HGHvM ] , where the authors gave a more direct, “down-to-earth” \mathsf{ZFC} construction. This approach was further developed in [ Me1 ] , [ Mv2 ] and [ Mv3 ] . In particular, one of these results of Medvedev (namely, Theorem 3.2 ) will be a fundamental ingredient in obtaining our main result. A more recent source of inspiration was the following interesting open question [ DKM , Question 1.2] . We remark that Hernández-Gutiérrez [ HG , Corollary 3.8] showed that, consistently, there exists a non-Polish \mathsf{C}_{p} -space that is \mathsf{CDH} . Question 1.1 (Dobrowolski, Krupski, Marciszewski) . Is there a \mathsf{ZFC} example of a non-Polish \mathsf{CDH} topological vector space? 2 2 2 Although the authors are not explicit about it, the remark that precedes [ DKM , Corollary 3.4] suggests that they are only considering topological vector spaces over \mathbb{R} . In fact, in his FWF research project P 35655, the second-listed author pointed out that the following (easier) question is also open. Question 1.2 (Medini) . Is there a \mathsf{ZFC} example of a non-Polish \mathsf{CDH} group? The main result of this article shows that Question 1.2 has an affirmative answer (see Corollary 3.4 ). We remark that, for a consistent example of a non-Polish \mathsf{CDH} group, it is not necessary to resort to \mathsf{C}_{p} -spaces. The earliest example seems to be [ MM , Theorem 21] . In fact, every non-meager \mathsf{P} -filter, viewed as a subspace of 2^{\omega} , gives such a group by [ HGH , Theorem 1.6] (see also [ KMZ , Theorem 10] ). However, the existence of a non-meager \mathsf{P} -filter in \mathsf{ZFC} is a long-standing open problem [ JMPS , Question 0.1] . 2. More preliminaries and terminology Given a space Z , we will say that a subspace X of Z is a copy of a space Y if X is homeomorphic to Y . A space is crowded if it is non-empty and it has no isolated points. A subset S of a space X is meager in X if there exist closed nowhere dense subsets C_{n} of X for n\in\omega such that S\subseteq\bigcup_{n\in\omega}C_{n} . A space X is meager if X is a meager subset of X . A space X is Baire if no non-empty open subset of X is meager in X . A space X is homogeneous if for every (x,y)\in X\times X there exists a homeomorphism h:X\longrightarrow X such that h(x)=y . Using translations, one sees that every group is homogeneous. A space X is h-homogeneous if every non-empty clopen subspace of X is homeomorphic to X . A subset S of a group X is precompact if for every neighborhood U of the identity in X there exists a finite F\subseteq X such that S\subseteq FU\cap UF . A group X is locally precompact if there exists a precompact neighborhood of the identity in X . The fact that \mathbb{Z}^{\omega} is not locally precompact (which is a simple exercise) will be crucial in the proof of Corollary 3.4 . Here, we use \mathbb{Z} to denote the integers with the discrete topology and the standard operation of addition. Recall that every group X is a dense subgroup of a Polish group \varrho X , known as the Raĭkov completion of X (see [ AT , Theorem 3.6.10, Proposition 3.6.20 and Proposition 4.3.8] ). Given f,g\in\mathbb{Z}^{\omega} , we will write f\leq^{\ast}g (respectively f<^{\ast}g or f=^{\ast}g ) to mean that f(n)\leq g(n) (respectively f(n)<g(n) or f(n)=g(n) ) for all but finitely many n\in\omega . We will say that S\subseteq\omega^{\omega} is bounded if there exists g\in\omega^{\omega} such that f\leq^{\ast}g for every f\in S . Recall that \mathfrak{b}=\mathsf{min}\{|S|:S\text{ is an unbounded subset of }\omega^{\omega}\}. A space X is a \lambda -set if every countable subset of X is a \mathsf{G_{\delta}} -subset of X . It is easy to realize that every crowded \lambda -set is meager, hence non-Polish. The only other fact concerning \lambda -sets that we will need is the following classical result [ Ro , Théorème 1] . See [ HGHvM , Section 2] and [ Mi , Section 5] for much more on this topic. Lemma 2.1 (Rothberger) . Let X be a space such that |X|<\mathfrak{b} . Then X is a \lambda -set. A subspace X of 2^{\omega} is a Bernstein set if X\cap K\neq\varnothing and (2^{\omega}\setminus X)\cap K\neq\varnothing for every copy K of 2^{\omega} in 2^{\omega} . It is easy to see that Bernstein sets exist in \mathsf{ZFC} , and that they are Baire spaces

Read the complete text