Non-reciprocal Scattering in a Microwave Frequency Comb

Christoph L. Bock, J. C. Rivera Hernández, Fabio Lingua, David B. Haviland · 2025

Read Non-reciprocal Scattering in a Microwave Frequency Comb by Christoph L. Bock, J. C. Rivera Hernández, Fabio Lingua, David B. Haviland (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-09453.txt.

Introduction

Ordinarily, a signal passing between two modes travels just as well backward as forward. Christoph Bock and co-authors show in 2025 how to break that symmetry inside a microwave frequency comb driven by a Josephson parametric oscillator. By tuning the pump tones' frequencies, strengths, and phases, they arrange constructive interference for scattering from one mode to another while the reverse path interferes destructively.

The team demonstrates the idea for two-mode isolation and three-mode circulation, then extends it to many modes. A linearized theory matches the experiments well. The one-way scattering, they argue, widens the control toolkit for microwave devices. One promised use is engineering new kinds of quantum correlations between modes, since one-way flow is a basic ingredient in quantum signal routing and protection.

Catalog record

CREATORChristoph L. Bock, J. C. Rivera Hernández, Fabio Lingua, David B. Haviland
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-09453

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Non-reciprocal Scattering in a Microwave Frequency Comb Preprint: APS/123-QED Christoph L. Bock, J. C. Rivera Hernández, Fabio Lingua, David B. Haviland Abstract We investigate non-reciprocal scattering within the modes of a microwave frequency comb. Adjusting the pump frequencies, amplitudes, and phases of a Josephson parametric oscillator, we control constructive interference for the m ⟶ ℓ m\longrightarrow\ell scattering processes, while concurrently achieving destructive interference for the inverse process ℓ ⟶ m \ell\longrightarrow m . We outline the methodology for realizing non-reciprocity in the context of two-mode isolation and a three-mode circulation, which we extend to multiple modes. We find good agreement between the experiments and a linearized theoretical model. Nonreciprocal scattering expands the toolset for parametric control, with the potential to engineer novel quantum correlations. I Introduction Microwave superconducting circuits have emerged as a leading platform for quantum technology devoret_superconducting_2013 ; gu_microwave_2017 ; arute_quantum_2019 ; gyenis_moving_2021 ; bardin_microwaves_2021 . A measurement of the quantum state of these circuits typically requires amplifiers that introduce excessive back-action and undesired decoherence. Measurement through non-reciprocal devices mitigates the back-action and is therefore considered essential to any microwave quantum technology. Achieving non-reciprocity in a compact and reconfigurable measurement scheme, which does not rely on bulky magnetic-based circulators, is highly desired. Josephson parametric amplifiers (JPAs) can in theory work at the quantum limit of back-action caves_quantum_2012 , but their typical mode of operation is reciprocal yurke_lownoise_1996 ; castellanos-beltran_widely_2007 ; castellanos-beltran_amplification_2008 ; yamamoto_flux-driven_2008 ; bergeal_phase-preserving_2010 ; aumentado_superconducting_2020 . Significant effort has focused on Josephson junction devices for directional quantum-limited amplification abdo_directional_2013 ; metelmann_nonreciprocal_2015 ; macklin_nearquantum-limited_2015 ; renberg_nilsson_high-gain_2023 and non-magnetic circulation kamal_noiseless_2011 ; estep_magnetic-free_2014 ; kerckhoff_-chip_2015 . Non-reciprocal scattering was demonstrated in a passive Josephson junction ring fedorov_nonreciprocity_2024 , as well as non-reciprocal frequency conversion and amplification in a multi-modal Josephson circuit lecocq_nonreciprocal_2017 ; lecocq_microwave_2020 ; lecocq_efficient_2021 . These solutions often require multiple coupled resonators and other components which constrain efficient signal routing, bandwidth, and tunability. Simplifying the circuitry while maintaining non-reciprocal behavior for tunable, selected bandwidths would greatly enhance the scalability and integration of quantum hardware. This work explores the use of a single JPA to non-reciprocally connect input and output tones in a microwave frequency comb. We analyze non-reciprocity in the context of asymmetric scattering between these modes deak_reciprocity_2012 ; ranzani_graph-based_2015 . Multiple low and high-frequency pumps with carefully tuned amplitude and phase enable non-reciprocity. We explore different non-reciprocal scattering regimes, ranging from two-mode isolation and three-mode circulation to a general non-reciprocal scattering between n=41 modes. Our scattering approach represents a first step toward a compact, scalable, and reconfigurable non-reciprocal measurement scheme for microwave quantum technology. II Setup and Experiment The experiments measure the scattering of a weak input signal that intermodulates with a multifrequency pump waveform, producing multiple intermodulation products called idlers. The JPA consists of a lumped-element LC circuit, incorporating a gradiometric superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID) whose inductance is modulated by an external time-dependent signal applied through the pump port (see Fig. 1 ). A DC bias at the pump port tunes the resonant frequency of the JPA to \omega_{0}=2\pi\times$4.2\text{\,}\mathrm{GHz}$ . The signal port is over-coupled, yielding a loaded quality factor Q=37.5 , corresponding to a linewidth \kappa=2\pi\times$112\text{\,}\mathrm{MHz}$ . A circulator separates the input and output signals, directing the output to a cryogenic low-noise amplifier. A digital multifrequency lock-in amplifier tholen_measurement_2022 generates the pump tones and the weak coherent signal while demodulating at up to 192 frequencies. We chose all pump, signal, and demodulation tones from a mode basis \{a_{m}\} whose frequencies are integer multiples of the measurement bandwidth \Delta=1/T=2\pi\times$125\text{\,}\mathrm{kHz}$ , where T is the measurement time window. This choice ensures orthogonality of the modes \{a_{m}\} and establishes a global phase reference for modulation and demodulation. We further eliminate Fourier leakage between demodulated modes by tuning \Delta to be commensurate with the digital sampling frequency. The enumeration scheme for the mode frequencies is \omega_{m}=\omega_{0}\pm m\Delta , m\in\mathbb{N} , with the center frequency \omega_{0} placed within \Delta of the resonant frequency of the JPA. We synthesize the multifrequency pump waveform by superposing tones selected from the same basis \{a_{m}\} , distinguishing between low- and high-frequency pump tones. Low-frequency pumps have \Omega_{k}=k\Delta , while high-frequency pumps have \Omega_{k}=2\omega_{0}\pm k\Delta , where k is a small positive integer. The synchronous low and high-frequency pumps are output through different ports of the multifrequency lock-in amplifier and combined at the mixing chamber using a diplexer, as shown in Fig. 1 . Figure 1: Simplified experimental setup, neglecting multiple filtering stages at intermediate temperatures in the dilution refrigerator. The JPA’s resonant frequency is modulated by an external flux gradient threading a gradiometric SQUID loop. III Non-reciprocal scattering For small perturbations of the magnetic flux gradient, the effective Hamiltonian describes the JPA dynamics \hat{\mathcal{H}}_{\text{JPA}}=\frac{\hat{\Phi}^{2}}{2L_{0}}+\frac{\hat{Q}^{2}}{2C}+\frac{\hat{\Phi}^{2}}{2\variation{L(t)}}, (1) where operators \hat{Q} , and \hat{\Phi} represent the node charge and flux at the JPA’s input port, respectively. We express the Hamiltonian in ( 1 ) in terms of the canonical ladder operators of the unperturbed harmonic oscillator, which we expand in the frequency mode basis, A^{({\dagger})}=\sum_{m}a_{m}^{({\dagger})}e^{-i\omega_{m}t} . Considering the classical limit a^{({\dagger})}_{m}\rightarrow a_{m}^{(*)}\in\mathbb{C} , one recovers a linear system of equations of motion \derivative{a_m}{t}=-i\tilde{\omega}_{0}a_{m}-i\omega_{0}p_{L}(t)(a_{m}+a^{*}_{m})+\sqrt{\gamma}\,a_{\text{in,}m} (2) where \tilde{\omega}_{0}=\omega_{0}-i\frac{\gamma}{2} and \gamma accounts for losses due to coupling to the transmission line. In the frequency domain the system ( 2 ) is usually expressed in matrix form -i\bm{M}\vec{a}=\sqrt{\gamma}\vec{a}_{\text{in}} , where \vec{a}=(a_{1},a_{1}^{*},\dots,a_{m},a_{m}^{*},\dots) is the vector containing the complex mode amplitudes. The solution of Eq. ( 2 ) is then readily available upon inversion of matrix \bm{M} naaman_synthesis_2022 . The scattering matrix follows from the mode matching condition \sqrt{\gamma}\vec{a}=\vec{a}_{\text{in}}+\vec{a}_{\text{out}} between the internal degrees of freedom, and the external incoming and reflected signals \vec{a}_{\text{out}}=\bm{S}\cdot\vec{a}_{\text{in}}=\left(i\gamma\bm{M}^{-1}-\mathbb{1}\right)\vec{a}_{\text{in}}, (3) where \gamma is the coupling to the transmission line, assumed to be constant for all modes (see rivera_hernandez_control_2024 for a detailed derivation). Each element S_{mn}\neq 0 connects the input mode at frequency \omega_{n} to the output mode at \omega_{m} through pump-controlled mixing processes. The pumps enable second, third, and higher-order intermodulation products (wave mixing) which generate idlers in the output signal. The pump waveform is defined as a sum of coherent tones with amplitude p_{k} , frequency \Omega_{k} , and phase \phi_{k} , p_{L}(t)=\sum_{k}p_{k}\cos{(\Omega_kt + \phi_k)}. (4) When multiple pumps are involved different mixing processes interfere at the same frequency, effectively enhancing or canceling scattering to that frequency, dependent on the amplitudes and phases of the pumps. Carefully engineering the pump frequencies, amplitudes, and phases, we exploit the interference properties of overlapping mixing processes to create non-reciprocal scattering. Non-reciprocity emerges as an asymmetry of the scattering matrix \bm{S}\neq\bm{S}^{T} ranzani_graph-based_2015 , i.e. S_{ij}\neq S_{ji} holds for at least a subset of matrix elements. Here we use a stronger definition of non-reciprocity |\bm{S}|\neq|\bm{S}^{T}| thus excluding non-reciprocal phase shifts. We know of no universal recipe for generating a specific non-reciprocity, but it is sufficient that the pumps satisfy \Omega_{p}=\sum_{k\neq p}n_{k}\Omega_{k} , where n_{k}\in\mathbb{N} is the multiplicity of pump k , accounting for higher-order mixing processes lecocq_nonreciprocal_2017 . III.1 Two-mode non-reciprocal scattering: the isolator Figure 2: (a)-(d) Isolator. (e)-(h) Circulator. (a) and (e) Scattering parameters as a function of the phase \phi_{3} and \phi_{2} for fixed pump powers, respectively. (b) and (f) Scattering parameters as a function of the relative amplitude p_{\text{rel}} for fixed phases. Blue dots refer to experimental

Read the complete text