Uncertainty in Elastic Turbulence
J. R. C. King 1, R. J. Poole 2, C. P. Fonte 3, S. J. Lind 4 · 2025
Read Uncertainty in Elastic Turbulence by J. R. C. King 1, R. J. Poole 2, C. P. Fonte 3, S. J. Lind 4 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-09421.txt.
Introduction
Jack King, Robert Poole, Cláudio Fonte, and Steven Lind study, in a 2025 preprint, how uncertainty grows inside elastic turbulence. Elastic turbulence is the chaotic flow of stretchy fluids, like polymer solutions, even at slow speeds. It can boost mixing and heat transfer, so engineers want to steer it. Forecasting such flow means knowing how fast small errors swell. The authors borrow an approach lately used on ordinary turbulence. They derive equations for how measures of uncertainty evolve.
Computer experiments revealed four regimes of error growth. Errors first rush to large scales, then get eaten by dissipation, then grow at all scales at once, and at last level off. Stretchy effects feed the growth while viscosity and relaxation drain it. Slowing the flow raised early uncertainty but mattered less later. Stronger elasticity and larger domains sped late growth.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | J. R. C. King 1, R. J. Poole 2, C. P. Fonte 3, S. J. Lind 4 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 119 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-09421
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Uncertainty in Elastic Turbulence J. R. C. King 1, R. J. Poole 2, C. P. Fonte 3, S. J. Lind 4 Abstract Elastic turbulence can lead to increased flow resistance, mixing and heat transfer. Its control – either suppression or promotion – has significant potential, and there is a concerted ongoing effort by the community to improve our understanding. Here we explore the dynamics of uncertainty in elastic turbulence, inspired by an approach recently applied to inertial turbulence in Ge et al. (2023) J. Fluid Mech. 977:A17. We derive equations for the evolution of uncertainty measures, yielding insight on uncertainty growth mechanisms. Through numerical experiments, we identify four regimes of uncertainty evolution, characterised by I) rapid transfer to large scales, with large scale growth rates of τ 6 \tau^{6} (where τ \tau represents time), II) a dissipative reduction of uncertainty, III) exponential growth at all scales, and IV) saturation. These regimes are governed by the interplay between advective and polymeric contributions (which tend to increase uncertainty), viscous, relaxation and dissipation effects (which reduce uncertainty), and inertial contributions. In elastic turbulence, reducing Reynolds number increases uncertainty at short times, but does not significantly influence the growth of uncertainty at later times. At late times, the growth of uncertainty increases with Weissenberg number, with decreasing polymeric diffusivity, and with the logarithm of the maximum length scale, as large flow features adjust the balance of advective and relaxation effects. These findings provide insight into the dynamics of elastic turbulence, offering a new approach for the analysis of viscoelastic flow instabilities. † † affiliation: 1 Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, The University of Manchester, Manchester, UK 2 School of Engineering, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK 3 Department of Chemical Engineering, The University of Manchester, Manchester, UK 4 School of Engineering, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK 1 Introduction Elastic turbulence ( Groisman & Steinberg, 2000 ) , a chaotic flow state observed in polymer solutions even in the limit of vanishing inertia, has implications across a range of application areas. It has been shown that elastic turbulence can enable emulsification ( Poole et al., 2012 ) ; that it can promote heat transfer ( Traore et al., 2015 ) ; that it is involved in melt fracture ( Morozov & van Saarloos, 2007 ) ; and that in mass-transfer limited regimes it can increase apparent reaction rates in porous reactors ( Browne & Datta, 2024 ) to provide just a few examples. Since the first documentation of elastic turbulence in 2000 by Groisman & Steinberg (2000) , there has been a concerted effort amongst the community to understand the phenomenon, and we refer the reader to Steinberg (2021) , Datta et al. (2022) and Sasmal (2025) for recent and comprehensive reviews. We note the related phenomena of elasto-inertial turbulence, first described by Samanta et al. (2013) ; a chaotic state seen across a large range of Reynolds numbers, driven by the polymer dynamics, where both elastic and inertial effects are important. In this work we only consider two-dimensional low Reynolds number flows in the elastic turbulence regime, although the theory we develop is applicable to viscoelastic flows in general. For a review of elasto-inertial turbulence, we refer the reader to Dubief et al. (2023) . The work we present here was inspired by the recent work of Ge et al. (2023) on uncertainty in inertial (Newtonian) turbulence. In Ge et al. (2023) , a remarkable depth of insight was provided through a relatively simple and intuitive approach: take two realisations of the Navier-Stokes equations, subtract them, and get evolution equations for the difference. The uncertainty was defined as the spatial average of the kinetic energy of the velocity difference \Delta{u}_{i} : \left\langle{E}_{\Delta}\right\rangle=\frac{1}{V}\displaystyle\int\frac{1}{2}\Delta{u}_{i}\Delta{u}_{i}dV, (1) for which an evolution equation was derived. Simply by inspecting the form of the evolution equation for \left\langle{E}_{\Delta}\right\rangle , and performing numerical experiments in which one realisation is perturbed and the evolution of the difference is tracked, they obtained fundamental quantitative insight into the chaotic nature of turbulence: identifying a similarity regime in which the production and dissipation rates of uncertainty grow together and the uncertainty spectrum is self-similar, and finding that in the absence of an external input of uncertainty, uncertainty can only be created via compression events in the Newtonian case. For chaotic flows, \left\langle{E}_{\Delta}\right\rangle is expected to grow exponentially, according to \frac{d\left\langle{E}_{\Delta}\right\rangle}{dt}=\lambda\left\langle{E}_{\Delta}\right\rangle, (2) in which \lambda is twice the maximal Lyapunov exponent of the system. Although Ge et al. (2023) provided our inspiration, the concept of \left\langle{E}_{\Delta}\right\rangle in studies of chaos and predictability in Newtonian turbulence predates this (e.g. Boffetta & Musacchio (2017) ; Berera & Ho (2018) ) dating back to the work of Leith & Kraichnan (1972) . To our knowledge, this concept has not previously been applied to viscoelastic flows . We are interested in chaotic flows of polymer solutions. Here, the system cannot be completely defined by the velocity field; a conformation tensor c_{ij} , which provides a macroscopic measure of the molecular deformation of polymers, is also required, and the picture is more complex. In recent years there has been a concerted effort by the community to understand and explore the fundamental dynamics of elastic (and elasto-inertial) turbulence. Much effort has focused on the onset of instabilities, aiming to address the questions of when, where and how do viscoelastic flows transition to these chaotic states. This has led to many important discoveries, including the existence of purely elastic instabilities in straight channels ( Pan et al., 2013 ) , the first exact travelling wave solutions ( Boffetta et al., 2005 ; Page et al., 2020 ; Morozov, 2022 ) , identification of a continuous pathway between elastic and elasto-inertial turbulence ( Khalid et al., 2021 ) , and the recently discovered polymer diffusive instability ( Beneitez et al. (2023) ; Lewy & Kerswell (2024b) ; Lewy & Kerswell (2024a) ; Couchman et al. (2024) ) present in wall-bounded viscoelastic flows. Early numerical studies of elastic turbulence took two-dimensional Kolmogorov flow (a flow with a uni-directional sinusoidal forcing in a doubly-periodic domain) as the setting ( Berti et al., 2008 ; Berti & Boffetta, 2010 ) , and this setting is still used in more recent studies (e.g. Garg et al. (2021) ). Even in this simple configuration, the main features observed experimentally are present: a transition to a chaotic unsteady flow state above a critical Weissenberg number; a distinct increase in power input required to sustain the flow; and an energy spectra with a power law decay having a slope steeper than k^{-3} , where k is the wavenumber. More recently, a similar numerical setting – doubly periodic with a cellular forcing – has been used by Plan et al. (2017) to estimate the Lyapunov dimension of elastic turbulence, and Gupta & Vincenzi (2019) to study the influence of polymeric diffusivity on the dynamics of elastic turbulence. Uncertainty is inherent in both real flows of polymer solutions, and numerical simulations. The conformation tensor c_{ij} used to describe the macroscopic behaviour of polymers is a statistical average of microscopic polymer deformations. Although if left to rest polymers will revert to an undeformed configuration ( c_{ij}\to\delta_{ij} ), in real flows of polymers, local temperature, concentration and