RoboReflect: A Robotic Reflective Reasoning Framework for Grasping Ambiguous-Condition Objects
Zhen Luo, Yixuan Yang, Yanfu Zhang, Feng Zheng · 2025
Read RoboReflect: A Robotic Reflective Reasoning Framework for Grasping Ambiguous-Condition Objects by Zhen Luo, Yixuan Yang, Yanfu Zhang, Feng Zheng (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-09307.txt.
Introduction
Zhen Luo, Yixuan Yang, Yanfu Zhang, and Feng Zheng give a grasping robot the ability to notice its own mistakes and try again. Objects in odd states, slippery, tangled, or half hidden, defeat fixed grasping plans, and earlier systems leaned on humans to recover. Their 2025 framework, RoboReflect, pairs the robot with a large vision-language model that reviews each failed attempt.
After a miss, the model reflects on what went wrong and rewrites the strategy; the robot retries until the grasp succeeds. Winning strategies are stored in memory for similar tasks later. On eight tricky objects across three categories, RoboReflect beat a leading grasp pose estimator and a GPT-4V planning method. The authors argue that self-reflection, more than a better first guess, is what field robots need when the world refuses to be tidy.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zhen Luo, Yixuan Yang, Yanfu Zhang, Feng Zheng |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-09307
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
RoboReflect: A Robotic Reflective Reasoning Framework for Grasping Ambiguous-Condition Objects Zhen Luo, Yixuan Yang, Yanfu Zhang, Feng Zheng Abstract As robotic technology rapidly develops, robots are being employed in an increasing number of fields. However, due to the complexity of deployment environments or the prevalence of ambiguous-condition objects, the practical application of robotics still faces many challenges, leading to frequent errors. Traditional methods and some LLM-based approaches, although improved, still require substantial human intervention and struggle with autonomous error correction in complex scenarios. In this work, we propose RoboReflect, a novel framework leveraging large vision-language models (LVLMs) to enable self-reflection and autonomous error correction in robotic grasping tasks. RoboReflect allows robots to automatically adjust their strategies based on unsuccessful attempts until successful execution is achieved. The corrected strategies are saved in the memory for future task reference. We evaluate RoboReflect through extensive testing on eight common objects prone to ambiguous conditions of three categories. Our results demonstrate that RoboReflect not only outperforms existing grasp pose estimation methods like AnyGrasp and high-level action planning techniques ReKep with GPT-4V but also significantly enhances the robot’s capability to adapt and correct errors independently. These findings underscore the critical importance of autonomous self-reflection in robotic systems while effectively addressing the challenges posed by ambiguous-condition environments. I INTRODUCTION With the rapid development of artificial intelligence, embodied AI and robotics technology have made significant strides across various fields. A notable instance is robotic arm grasping tasks, which have become a vital application in industrial automation and service robotics [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . The recent rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) has further broadened the potential of these technologies. Compared to traditional methods, LLM-based robotic arms can understand tasks from natural language instructions and autonomously generate grasping policies. This capability makes robotic arms more flexible when facing diverse and dynamically changing tasks. Furthermore, this also lays the foundation for robotic arms to deal with complex, long-horizon manipulation tasks. Therefore, researchers are now exploring ways to integrate LLMs into robotic systems, envisioning them as the “brain” of embodied intelligence, capable of facilitating actions in the real world. In real-world scenarios, the properties of daily necessities often differ from those in experimental training data (e.g., Empty tissue bags, deformed bottles, and fragile toys). Some objects whose properties change with use undergo corresponding changes at different conditions, consequently resulting in errors in the grasping ( e.g. , fulfilled tissue bags and empty tissue bags). Additionally, achieving reliable grasping performance necessitates deeper understanding of objects due to factors such as material composition or edibility (e.g., ice cream on a stick). We refer to such objects as ambiguous-condition objects , where both robotic arm systems and LLMs struggle to determine the object’s current condition to calculate the affordance point or grasp pose at the first time, often leading to grasping failures or unreasonable actions. Therefore, whether applying traditional methods or LLM-driven approaches, distinguishing between objects with the same label but differing physical properties remains highly challenging for ensuring proper grasping. How to reduce these misjudgments remains a key problem in more general and practical applications. Some existing studies attempted to teach embodied robots with the capability to correct errors, making them more robust. REFLECT [ 4 ] primarily addresses errors arising from the robot’s planning and execution but struggles with understanding complex and ambiguous real-world scenarios. YAY Robot [ 5 ] , which incorporates language correction via human feedback, demonstrates robustness across diverse environments. However, it heavily relies on human intervention during the error correction process. While these methods broaden the robot’s adaptability, they fail to develop the robot’s ability to autonomously identify and resolve ambiguous-condition objects. Ultimately, these techniques rely on human guidance to enhance adaptability, rather than activating the robot’s autonomous error-solving capabilities when encountering objects in ambiguous conditions. To address the above challenges, we introduce a novel framework named RoboReflect, a first-of-its-kind tailored solution for embodied robot autonomous reflection and error correction using Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) to grasp objects under ambiguous conditions. In this framework, LVLM provides high-level policies for grasping tasks to embodied robots based on instructions and the environment and decomposes them into executable primitive actions to guide the robot in completing the task. After each action, LVLM checks whether it was successfully executed; if it fails, LVLM reflects on the reasons for failure based on the results of the failed attempt and corrects the action strategy until the task is successfully completed. The main contribution of the RoboReflect can be summarized as follows: • We introduce a novel self-reflect and correction robot grasping framework, RoboReflect, which can autonomously correct the failure of the grasping task on ambiguous-condition objects. • RoboReflect utilizes the Reflective Reasoning module with LVLM and a Memory module, enabling the framework to resolve the ambiguous grasping scenario and incorporates a memory mechanism to handle ambiguous-condition issues that have already been encountered. • We categorize ambiguous-condition objects into three types, and test RoboReflect on eight common objects. Ours consistently outperforms ReKep [ 6 ] , AnyGrasp [ 7 ] and GPT-4V [ 8 ] driven grasp method, which highlights the critical role of autonomous reflection-correction in ambiguous grasping scenarios. II RELATED WORK Large Models for Robotics. Recent advancements in LVLMs like GPT-4V [ 8 ] , PaLM [ 9 ] , and LLaMA [ 10 ] have spurred interest in integrating these models into robotics. Some research focuses on generating high-level task plans using human language instructions to guide robots in executing complex tasks [ 11 , 12 ] , while others explore the direct generation of robotic control code [ 13 , 14 ] . Additionally, LVLMs are fine-tuned on robotic datasets to learn and adapt actions in real-time environments [ 15 , 16 , 17 ] . While these efforts enhance robotic comprehension and planning, real-world task execution remains challenging. We propose leveraging LVLMs’ inferential abilities for autonomous reflective reasoning to address these complexities. Robot Action Correction. Recent studies have explored using LLMs for error reasoning and action correction in robots [ 18 , 4 ] , but most focus on simple action failures with limited environmental understanding. Other approaches rely on human feedback to correct robot actions [ 19 , 20 ] , but these often require extensive human intervention to handle diverse errors in complex environments. To tackle this, we propose the RoboReflect framework, which enables robots to address errors autonomously through reflection and recommendation mechanisms, improving their adaptability and robustness in ambiguous scenarios. III METHODOLOGY Fig. 1 : The RoboReflect Framework for Autonomous Error Correction in Robotic Grasping Tasks. The process begins with the Vision Processing Module, which extracts RGB \bm{I} and depth images \bm{I_{D}} , generating 3D spatial positions \bm{S} . \bm{I} pass to the LVLM \mathcal{M} , which, along with text instructions \bm{Ins} , generates actions \bm{I_{act}} through the Action Module. The Judgment Module evaluates the grasp based on the grasp state \bm{G_{S}} and grasp position \bm{G_{P}} , using action images \bm{I_{act}} , \bm{S} , and \bm{Ins} . If the grasp fails (i.e., \bm{G_{S}}\cup\bm{G_{P}}=0 ), the system engages the Reflective Reasoning Module, which analyzes the error and proposes corrective suggestions \bm{R^{\prime}} through reasoning steps. The memory module stores object descriptions and successful