Order-by-order uncertainties of nucleon-nucleon Wolfenstein amplitudes in chiral effective field theory
B. McClung, Ch. Elster, D.R. Phillips · 2025
Read Order-by-order uncertainties of nucleon-nucleon Wolfenstein amplitudes in chiral effective field theory by B. McClung, Ch. Elster, D.R. Phillips (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-09231.txt.
Introduction
McClung, Elster, and Phillips weigh error bars in a 2025 paper on how two nucleons scatter. Rules of quantum theory fix the shape of that interplay to five free parts, each with its own strength curve. A modern force model built step by step should give those curves with shrinking doubt at each added step.
The team tracked all five curves across lab energies for both mixed and like pairs of nucleons. They used a smooth curve-fitting method from a known group to chart doubt at each step. Readers see how steady the model's calls are, and where more work is still needed.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | B. McClung, Ch. Elster, D.R. Phillips |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-09231
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Order-by-order uncertainties of nucleon-nucleon Wolfenstein amplitudes in chiral effective field theory B. McClung, Ch. Elster, D.R. Phillips Abstract Quantum mechanical invariance principles dictate the most general operator structure that can be present in the nucleon-nucleon (NN) interaction. Five independent operators appear in the on-shell NN amplitude together with five corresponding coefficient functions. The usual choice for these coefficient functions is known as the NN Wolfenstein amplitudes. We analyze the order-by-order convergence of each of the five NN Wolfenstein amplitudes predicted by a semi-local coordinate space potential implementation of chiral effective field theory ( χ \chi EFT). We do this at laboratory kinetic energies between 25 and 200 MeV for both neutron-proton and proton-proton scattering. Our analysis uses the Gaussian-Process methods developed by the BUQEYE collaboration to describe the contributions of each χ \chi EFT order, and so yields truncation uncertainties for each Wolfenstein amplitude that are correlated across scattering angles. We combine information on the size of different orders in the EFT to infer the χ \chi EFT breakdown scale for each amplitude, finding, on average, Λ b \Lambda_{b} between 750 and 800 MeV. With this choice of Λ b \Lambda_{b} , the EFT truncation uncertainties cover both higher-order results and empirical Wolfenstein amplitudes well for all orders other than the leading order. I Introduction and Motivation Nucleon-nucleon (NN) interactions derived in the chiral effective field theory ( \chi EFT) expansion are widely applied in low-energy nuclear physics. (For reviews see Refs. Epelbaum et al. 2009 ; Hammer et al. 2020 ; Machleidt and Sammarruca 2024 .) They are crucial inputs to ab initio calculations of finite nuclei, nuclear reactions, and nuclear matter. Such treatments of the NN force are systematic because of the effective field theory (EFT) power counting, which organizes the infinite set of operators that could appear in the NN potential into a sequence of terms of decreasing importance. Such a treatment implies that NN scattering observables will have a well-defined uncertainty corresponding to the size of the omitted terms beyond the order computed in the \chi EFT expansion. However, while in principle this statement provides a way to estimate the theory uncertainty of a \chi EFT calculation, quantifying those uncertainties requires a statistical model for the higher-order terms. A careful check of the uncertainty quantification of NN amplitudes derived in \chi EFT is also important because the expansion of the NN potential does not translate into an expansion of the NN amplitude. Hence, testing whether the \chi EFT expansion has a regular convergence pattern is an important a posteriori check on attempts to implement a \chi EFT expansion for observables via a NN potential. The study of truncation uncertainties of two-nucleon scattering observables obtained with \chi EFT NN interactions has already been successfully carried out (see e.g. Furnstahl et al. 2015 ; Melendez et al. 2017 ; Melendez et al. 2019 ), extended to the nucleon-deuteron (Nd) system Epelbaum et al. 2020 , as well as to structure observables for light nuclei Binder et al. 2018 ; Maris et al. 2021 ; Maris et al. 2022 , to nucleon-nucleus scattering Baker et al. 2022 , and to neutron and nuclear matter Drischler et al. 2020a ; Drischler et al. 2020b . In a recent work Millican et al. Millican et al. 2024 assessed correlated truncation errors of a given \chi EFT NN potential in terms of NN observables, i.e., cross sections and spin observables, as functions of the laboratory kinetic energy. Since the observables for the NN system are plentiful, it is not always easy to relate them to specific properties of the underlying NN potentials. In this work, we follow the same statistical methodology as Millican et al. and several of the other works listed in the previous paragraph: the “BUQEYE” (Bayesian Uncertainty Quantification: Errors for Your EFT) approach to truncation errors. But here, we emphasize the invariant operator structure of the NN potential Okubo and Marshak 1958 and the resulting scattering amplitudes. Representing NN potentials in terms of their invariant operator structure has already been successfully applied in calculations of NN scattering in which conventional partial wave decompositions were not used Veerasamy et al. 2012 ; Golak et al. 2010 ; Fachruddin et al. 2000 . Since we are considering NN scattering, we will focus on the convergence pattern of the NN scattering amplitude as expressed through its Wolfenstein representation Wolfenstein and Ashkin 1952 ; Wolfenstein 1956 . This means we consider five (complex) functions, which are the coefficients in an expression that defines the NN t-matrix in terms of the most general operator structure consistent with rotational invariance, parity, and time reversal. Quantum mechanics mandates that observables are bilinear in the Wolfenstein amplitudes, so the pattern of convergence of the chiral EFT expansion is more straightforward when analyzed in the amplitudes rather than in terms of observables. The BUQEYE approach to EFT truncation errors involves expressing the quantities of interest in terms of dimensionless coefficients associated with each order in the EFT expansion. The EFT will then have regular convergence and predictable truncation uncertainties if all coefficients are of similar size. In addition, the formalism of Melendez et al. Melendez et al. 2019 allows the analysis of functions–like the Wolfenstein amplitudes–predicted by the EFT, since it assumes that each coefficient function is a different draw from the same underlying Gaussian process (GP) Rasmussen and Williams 2006 ; Bastos and O’Hagan 2009 . Here, we carry out such an analysis of the neutron-proton and proton-proton Wolfenstein amplitudes predicted in a semi-local co-ordinate space (SCS) implementation of the chiral EFT NN interaction of Epelbaum, Krebs, and Meißner Epelbaum et al. 2015a ; Epelbaum et al. 2015b . This potential exists at five different EFT orders ranging from leading order LO [ O(Q^{0}) ], to next-to-next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order N 4 LO [ O(Q^{5}) ], and so we have a sizable set of coefficients to train our GP on for each of the five Wolfenstein amplitudes we consider. The BUQEYE formalism also allows the extraction of a posterior probability density for the breakdown scale of the EFT, i.e., the momentum scale at which all terms in the EFT have the same size. Thus, we can extract breakdown scales associated with each Wolfenstein amplitude. However, we will also see that the pattern of EFT convergence is irregular for some of the amplitudes. The paper is structured as follows. In Sec. II , we first briefly introduce Wolfenstein amplitudes, then review basic concepts of GPs to analyze the convergence of EFT predictions and give specific choices implemented in this work. In Sec. III , we analyze the neutron-proton Wolfenstein amplitudes as predicted by one SCS \chi EFT interaction, and in Sec. IV , we analyze the corresponding proton-proton amplitudes. We conclude in Sec. V . In an appendix, we show additional results for amplitudes that may interest some readers but might distract from the main points of our study if presented in the body of the paper. II Formal Considerations II.1 Wolfenstein amplitudes Efforts to constrain the NN scattering matrix \overline{M} from invariance principles have a long tradition Hoshizaki 1968 ; Bystricky et al. 1978 . In addition to Galilean invariance, time reversal, and parity conservation are considered, and a