Valid post-selection inference for penalized G-estimation

Ajmery Jaman, Ashkan Ertefaie, Michèle Bally, Renée Lévesque, Robert W. Platt, Mireille E. Schnitzer · 2025

Read Valid post-selection inference for penalized G-estimation by Ajmery Jaman, Ashkan Ertefaie, Michèle Bally, Renée Lévesque, Robert W. Platt, Mireille E. Schnitzer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-09196.txt.

Introduction

Ajmery Jaman and co-authors fix a hard problem in statistics in a 2025 paper. The problem is judging who gains from a treatment. Knowing how treatment effects vary across people guides choices in medical and clinical work and in marketing alike. When many candidate effect modifiers exist, selection driven by the data is essential. But that step breaks standard calculations of uncertainty that assume a fixed model.

The method under study is penalized G-estimation. It selects key modifiers while it estimates their effects. The authors develop inference that stays valid after that selection step has used the data. Honest error bars after model selection matter greatly. Clinicians act on the claimed differences between patient groups, so those bars must be sound.

Catalog record

CREATORAjmery Jaman, Ashkan Ertefaie, Michèle Bally, Renée Lévesque, Robert W. Platt, Mireille E. Schnitzer
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE104 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-09196

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Valid post-selection inference for penalized G-estimation Ajmery Jaman, Ashkan Ertefaie, Michèle Bally, Renée Lévesque, Robert W. Platt, Mireille E. Schnitzer Abstract Understanding treatment effect heterogeneity is important for decision-making in medical and clinical practices, or handling various engineering and marketing challenges. When dealing with high-dimensional covariates or when the effect modifiers are not predefined and need to be discovered, data-adaptive selection approaches become essential. However, with data-driven model selection, the quantification of statistical uncertainty is complicated by post-selection inference due to difficulties in approximating the sampling distribution of the target estimator. Data-driven model selection tends to favor models with strong effect modifiers with an associated cost of inflated type I errors. Although several frameworks and methods for valid statistical inference have been proposed for ordinary least squares regression following data-driven model selection, fewer options exist for valid inference for effect modifier discovery in causal modeling contexts. In this article, we extend two different methods to develop valid inference for penalized G-estimation that investigates effect modification of proximal treatment effects within the structural nested mean model framework. We show the asymptotic validity of the proposed inferential methods. In our simulation study, the proposed methods effectively controlled the false coverage rates for the target parameters, while the naive inference based on the sandwich variance estimator resulted in false coverage rates higher than the nominal level. Our work is motivated by the study of hemodiafiltration for treating patients with end-stage renal disease at the Centre Hospitalier de l’Université de Montréal. We apply these methods to draw inference about the effect heterogeneity of dialysis facility on the repeated session-specific hemodiafiltration outcomes. Keywords : causal inference, decorrelated score, G-estimation, longitudinal data, one-step improved estimator, post-selection inference 1 Introduction Understanding treatment effect heterogeneity is important for decision-making in medical and clinical practices, or addressing various engineering and marketing challenges. When dealing with high-dimensional covariates or when effect modifiers are not predefined and need to be discovered, data-adaptive selection approaches become essential. However, with data-driven model selection, the quantification of statistical uncertainty is complicated by post-selection inference. Classical inference is built on a framework where all modeling decisions are made independently of the data from which inference is drawn. The asymptotic distribution of the parameter estimator is challenging to derive due to the non-negligible estimation bias and sparsity effects associated with the high dimensional parameters ( Ning and Liu,, 2017 ) . If we perform data-driven effect modifier selection, we tend to favor models with strong effect modifiers with an associated cost of inflated type I errors ( Zhao et al.,, 2022 ) . Data-driven selection procedures produce a model that is itself stochastic, and this model selection uncertainty is not accounted for by the classical inference theory. In the last fifteen years, there have been several proposed frameworks and methods for valid statistical inference following data-driven model selection. Tibshirani et al., (2016) and Lee et al., (2016) developed frameworks for inference under forward stepwise regression, least angle regression, and the Least Absolute Shrinkage and Selection Operator (LASSO). These conditional approaches provide valid inference only for a few specific model selection methods, not for generic variable selection, and are dependent on distributional assumptions for the response. The Post-Selection Inference (PoSI) method, proposed by Berk et al., (2013) and later generalized by Bachoc et al., (2020) , provides inferential guarantees for arbitrary model selection approaches, including informal ones. The PoSI method ensures valid inference even when an incorrect model is selected, but this inferential procedure is computationally expensive ( Kuchibhotla et al.,, 2020 ) . By addressing the limitations of the PoSI method and accommodating misspecification of the normal linear model, Kuchibhotla et al., (2020) introduced the Universal Post Selection Inference (UPoSI) approach for OLS regression assuming either fixed or random covariates, which are referred to as fixed-design UPoSI and random-design UPoSI, respectively. The UPoSI approach is computationally efficient–its cost is proportional to the number of covariates–and does not require correct model specification, making it a “model-robust” inferential procedure. Other advancements include the debiased or desparsifying method proposed by Zhang and Zhang, (2014) , known as the low dimensional projection estimator (LDPE), which constructs confidence intervals for linear or generalized linear models with the Lasso penalty. Ning and Liu, (2017) proposed a decorrelated score test for inference in penalized M-estimation. Unlike the work in Zhang and Zhang, (2014) which are tailored for individual models, the decorrelated score method ( Ning and Liu,, 2017 ) provides a general framework for high dimensional inference that can be used to infer the oracle parameter under misspecified models. Based on the idea of projected estimating equations ( Zhang and Zhang,, 2014 ) , Xia and Shojaie, (2022) developed an inference procedure for linear functionals of high-dimensional longitudinal data using generalized estimating equations (GEE). However, there are few contributions on valid inference for effect modifier discovery in causal modeling contexts. In one such work, Zhao et al., (2022) adapted the approach of Lee et al., (2016) and proposed a conditional selective inference procedure for effect modification estimated using the LASSO. In the context of multistage decision problems of dynamic treatment regimes, Jones et al., (2022) extended the UPoSI approach ( Kuchibhotla et al.,, 2020 ) to develop valid inference for robust Q-learning. Gao et al., (2025) adapted the approach of Ning and Liu, (2017) to develop an asymptotic inference method for multistage stationary treatment policies in the presence of high dimensional feature variables. In this paper, we contribute to this growing body of work by developing valid inferential methods for the recently proposed doubly-robust penalized G-estimation ( Jaman et al.,, 2025 ) . This method estimates the proximal effects of exposure with simultaneous data-adaptive selection of effect modifiers within a structural nested mean model (SNMM) framework, particularly for repeated outcomes. We present two different proposals for valid inference on effect modification of proximal treatment effects: one is an extension of the UPoSI approach ( Kuchibhotla et al.,, 2020 ) and another is based on the decorrelated score test introduced by Ning and Liu, (2017) . Our methodological development is motivated by a study of hemodiafiltration (HDF), a dialysis technique for treating patients with end-stage renal disease (ESRD). Hemodiafiltration is the standard treatment for ESRD patients at the University of Montreal Hospital Centre (CHUM) outpatient dialysis clinic and its affiliated ambulatory dialysis center (CED). Hemodiafiltration cleans waste and excess fluids from the blood by combining diffusive clearance and convective removal of solutes ( Ronco and Cruz,, 2007 ) . It involves the ultrafiltration of a large volume of plasma water, which requires substitution fluid to be administered to the patient to preserve fluid balance. Dialysis effectiveness is indicated by the convection volume attained during each session, which is calculated as the sum of the substitution volume and the ultrafiltration volume ( Marcelli et al.,, 2015 ) . Using the data extracted from hospital records, Jaman et al., (2025) explored the effect heterogeneity of the dialysis facility (CHUM vs. CED) on the session-specific mean convection volumes applying penalized G-estimation. In this paper, we apply our proposed methods to provide valid post-selection inference for the effects estimated by Jaman et al., (2025) . The identification of effect modifiers in Jaman et al., (2025) is informed by

Read the complete text