Feldman-Cousins’ ML Cousin: Sterile Neutrino Global Fits using Simulation-Based Inference
Joshua Villarreal, John Hardin, Janet M. Conrad · 2025
Read Feldman-Cousins’ ML Cousin: Sterile Neutrino Global Fits using Simulation-Based Inference by Joshua Villarreal, John Hardin, Janet M. Conrad (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-08988.txt.
Introduction
Joshua Villarreal, John Hardin, and Janet Conrad speed up global fits hunting for a hypothetical extra neutrino, in a paper from twenty twenty-five. Tiny-signal analyses often break a classic statistical shortcut, forcing a costly exact procedure. Combining many experiments makes that procedure impossibly slow.
Their machine learning method imitates a full Bayesian analysis at a fraction of the cost, running about two hundred times faster than the classic exact route. They demo it on a joint fit of electron neutrino disappearance data under one sterile neutrino scheme. The authors expect the approach to serve global fits of many kinds, wherever the exact method is out of reach.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Joshua Villarreal, John Hardin, Janet M. Conrad |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-08988
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Feldman-Cousins’ ML Cousin: Sterile Neutrino Global Fits using Simulation-Based Inference Joshua Villarreal, John Hardin, Janet M. Conrad Abstract For many small-signal particle physics analyses, Wilks’ theorem, a simplifying assumption that presumes log-likelihood asymptotic normality, does not hold. The most common alternative approach applied in particle physics is a highly computationally expensive procedure put forward by Feldman and Cousins. When many experiments are combined for a global fit to data, deviations from Wilks’ theorem are exacerbated, and Feldman-Cousins becomes computationally intractable. We present a novel, machine learning-based procedure that can approximate a full-fledged Bayesian analysis 200 times faster than the Feldman-Cousins method. We demonstrate the utility of this novel method by performing a joint analysis of electron neutrino/antineutrino disappearance data within a single sterile neutrino oscillation framework. Although we present a prototypical simulation-based inference method for a sterile neutrino global fit, we anticipate that similar procedures will be useful for global fits of all kinds, especially those in which Feldman-Cousins is too computationally expensive to use. Name Ref. L [m] E [MeV] Significance Short Description Reactor Experiments ( \bar{\nu}_{e} ) STEREO Almazan2023 9-11 1.625-7.125 NR ILL research reactor, extended detector PROSPECT prospectResults 7-10 0.8-7.2 NR ORNL research reactor, extended detector DANSS Skrobova2023 10-12 1-7 2.3\sigma Kalinin power reactor, moving baseline system NEOS/RENO PhysRevD.105.L111101 24/294 1-10 NR Hanbit power reactor, two detectors, with RENO near detector used as SM flux baseline Source Experiments ( \nu_{e} ) SAGE & GALLEX Gavrin2013 ; KOSTENSALO2019542 ; Giunti:2010zu , 0-0.7 & 0-1.9 0.426, 0.747, 0752, 0.811, 0.813 2.3\sigma 51 Cr and 37 Ar sources; single segment 71 Ga target BEST PhysRevLett.128.232501 ; PhysRevD.105.L051703 0-1.7 0.426, 0.747, 0752 >5\sigma 51 Cr source; two-segment 71 Ga target Table 1 : Relevant parameters of experiments used in this study. Characteristic L and E values are approximate, see reference (column 2) for more details. Column 5 provides the reported significance of a 3+1 signal in numbers of standard deviations (or NR if the best fit point is not reported). I Introduction Searching for rare particles or physics processes often involves synthesizing data from multiple experiments and signatures. For example, the first estimates of the top quark mass combined data from numerous electroweak experiments ALEPH:1995ac ; the Higgs boson search drew on a wide range of experimental data sets PDG2012Higgs ; and the establishment of the three-neutrino oscillation model relied on diverse neutrino sources and detectors Gonzalez-Garcia:2012hef . These exercises in global fitting were instrumental in achieving the 1999, 2013, and 2015 Nobel Prizes. In addition to validating and excluding theoretical predictions, global fits have also been valuable for highlighting unexplored model parameter spaces for future studies, honing the direction of particle physics experiments. In a traditional frequentist global fit, a test statistic is computed over a model’s parameter space and profiled to assess the stability and significance of a fit by building a confidence level (CL). The simplest approach involves calculating the model’s likelihood across the parameter space, profiling the log-likelihood difference relative to a null (no-signal) hypothesis, and describing the test statistic with a \chi^{2} distribution, as per Wilks’ theorem. This method is efficient for deriving CLs, but issues like varying degrees of freedom and non-Gaussian systematic uncetainties can misrepresent the CLs, failing frequentist consistency checks in many mock experimental trials Hardin:2022qdh . To address this, the Feldman-Cousins method, which compares data from simulated trials across the entire parameter space to the null, is preferred feldman-cousins . However, this approach is highly computationally expensive, requiring extensive trials in a fine grid across the available parameter space and repeated evaluation of the test statistic. Thus, despite the Feldman-Cousins approach being widely regarded as the best choice for correctly characterizing fit results, many analyses are forced to resort to Feldman-Cousins “spot checks” in a more limited region of parameter space to quantify the deviation from the Wilks’ approach rather than complete a high-fidelity data analysis. An alternative approach that is faster to evaluate is the CL s 1 1 1 Not to be confused with confidence levels, CLs. method Qian:2014nha ; however, this is only applicable for setting limits on model parameters, and not for identifying allowed regions, making it less relevant to the goals of most signal-searching global fits. The frequentest approaches described above have a Bayesian alternative. Using Bayes’ rule, one establishes a prior distribution over fit parameters, uses realized experimental data to build a likelihood , and computes a posterior distribution from which credible regions (CRs) can be computed. Depending on the problem’s complexity, computing likelihoods (using methods like Markov Chain Monte Carlo) may be computationally expensive or even intractable. Neither frequentist nor Bayesian approaches are immune from heavy computational overhead. To this end, enhancement or even replacement of these traditional fitting procedures with likelihood-free or simulation-based inference (SBI) has been a major recent effort in scientific computing. The aim of SBI is to develop statistical or machine learning (ML) techniques that can efficiently learn the likelihood function, posterior distribution, or some other quantity (like the likelihood ratio) used for interpreting the results of a fit. Recent advances in deep density estimation via normalizing flows, the primary tooling for this work, have illuminated the huge potential of SBI for efficient data analysis, particularly in the context of particle physics experiments. For a review of SBI and its applications, see Ref. Cranmer2020 ; for a community-led project compilation of SBI methodological developments and novel domain-specific applications, see Refs. sbidotorg ; neuralsbigh . This paper explores how to extend SBI methods from single-experiment analyses to global fits involving arbitrary combinations of experiments. This approach to global fitting has multiple benefits: • The ML algorithm is trained using trials, capturing information on the stochastic behavior of the data set expected at each parameter point. • The data can be generated with systematic uncertainties that are not Gaussian, a point rarely incorporated into fits to single experiments or global fits. • Analysis of a single experiment is very fast relative to traditional fits, and expanding from a single experiment to a global fit involves little increase in the total run time. I.1 Sterile Neutrino Searches via Electron-Neutrino Disappearance To demonstrate the viability and speed of this new global fitting technique compared to high-fidelity analysis frameworks like Feldman-Cousins, we choose the domain of searches for sterile neutrinos —hypothetical noninteracting partners to the three known neutrino flavors in the Standard Model (SM). These searches rely on the quantum mechanical phenomenon of neutrino oscillations , where one type of neutrino converts into another, a well-established behavior for SM neutrinos. Some short baseline (SBL) experiments have observed effects suggesting additional oscillation frequencies beyond SM predictions, while others have found no such evidence, casting doubt on the sterile neutrino hypothesis Hardin:2022muu . To resolve these conflicting results, we must analyze the SBL data as a whole through global fits within a consistent sterile neutrino model. The simplest such model (called “3+1”) involves oscillations between three SM neutrinos and one sterile neutrino. However, fitting the 3+1 model is challenging: Wilks’ approach is too simplistic Hardin:2022qdh , and Feldman-Cousins is computationally prohibitive. SBI techniques naturally lend themselves useful towards analyzing experiments’ preferences for or against a 3+1 sterile neutrino model. To demonstrate SBI’s utility for informing sterile neutrino global