GRAPPA - A Hybrid Graph Neural Network for Predicting Pure Component Vapor Pressures

Marco Hoffmann, Hans Hasse, Fabian Jirasek · 2025

Read GRAPPA - A Hybrid Graph Neural Network for Predicting Pure Component Vapor Pressures by Marco Hoffmann, Hans Hasse, Fabian Jirasek (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-08729.txt.

Introduction

Marco Hoffmann, Hans Hasse, and Fabian Jirasek present GRAPPA for predicting vapor pressures in this 2025 paper. Vapor pressure is a key trait when designing chemical plants. No open method was both broad in reach and accurate enough for most molecules.

GRAPPA is a hybrid graph neural network that needs only a molecule's structure as input. Attention passes messages across the molecular graph, and a pooling step catches long-range effects. A final head outputs Antoine equation values, so pressure follows at any temperature. Training used data on nearly twenty-five thousand compounds. On unseen compounds it beat group methods and other learning tools.

Catalog record

CREATORMarco Hoffmann, Hans Hasse, Fabian Jirasek
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-08729

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

GRAPPA - A Hybrid Graph Neural Network for Predicting Pure Component Vapor Pressures Marco Hoffmann, Hans Hasse, Fabian Jirasek Abstract Although the pure component vapor pressure is one of the most important properties for designing chemical processes, no broadly applicable, sufficiently accurate, and open-source prediction method has been available. To overcome this, we have developed GRAPPA - a hybrid graph neural network for predicting vapor pressures of pure components. GRAPPA enables the prediction of the vapor pressure curve of basically any organic molecule, requiring only the molecular structure as input. The new model consists of three parts: A graph attention network for the message passing step, a pooling function that captures long-range interactions, and a prediction head that yields the component-specific parameters of the Antoine equation, from which the vapor pressure can readily and consistently be calculated for any temperature. We have trained and evaluated GRAPPA on experimental vapor pressure data of almost 25,000 pure components. We found excellent prediction accuracy for unseen components, outperforming state-of-the-art group contribution methods and other machine learning approaches in applicability and accuracy. The trained model and its code are fully disclosed, and GRAPPA is directly applicable via the interactive website ml-prop.mv.rptu.de . † † email: [email protected] † † affiliation: Laboratory of Engineering Thermodynamics, RPTU Kaiserslautern, Erwin-Schrödinger-Str. 44, 67663 Kaiserslautern, Germany † † suppinfo: W 1 Introduction The vapor pressure p^{\mathrm{s}} of pure components is a key property in designing and optimizing many chemical processes. However, since experimental data for the vapor pressure are, by far, not available for all relevant components and at all relevant temperatures, prediction methods for this property are paramount. We can thereby distinguish between two types of prediction problems: 1. The interpolation or extrapolation of the vapor pressure to unstudied temperatures for components for which some experimental data (at other temperatures) are available. 2. The prediction of the vapor pressure of components for which no data (at any temperature) are available. The first, much easier, type of prediction problem is usually solved by employing semi-empirical correlations of the vapor pressure as a function of the temperature, of which the Antoine equation is a simple example: \ln\left(p^{\mathrm{s}}/\mathrm{kPa}\right)=A-\frac{B}{C+T/\mathrm{K}} (1) The Antoine equation is a good compromise between simplicity and accuracy and therefore widely used - and there are databases containing the Antoine parameters for several thousand pure components in the literature DDB (2024) ; Yaws (2015) . However, for the largest share of the pure components from the chemical space, no experimental data for the vapor pressure are available, so fitting semi-empirical correlations like Eq. ( 1 ) is infeasible. In these cases, prediction methods that can generalize over components are needed. In the following, we give a brief overview of such methods from the literature. First, we discuss established categories, which we divide into corresponding states, group contribution, quantitative structure-property relations (QSPR), and equation of state (EoS) based methods. Then, we will discuss recent machine learning (ML) developments. We acknowledge some ambiguities and that some methods might fit into multiple categories. Corresponding states methods. Lee and Kesler (1975) ; Ambrose and Walton (1989) ; Riedel (1954) These methods follow the idea that the thermophysical properties of many components are similar if the properties are reduced using the components’ critical properties. Consequently, corresponding states methods are based on the availability of critical data for the components of interest, specifically the critical pressure p_{\mathrm{c}} and the critical temperature T_{\mathrm{c}} . Some methods also require the acentric factor \omega (representing one additional data point of the vapor pressure curve). Furthermore, these methods are often limited to components of similar chemical structure. For example, the method of Ambrose and Walton Ambrose and Walton (1989) only applies to alkanes and 1-alcohols. For these reasons, corresponding states methods for predicting vapor pressures usually have a relatively small scope, hampering their practical applicability. Group contribution methods. Macknick and Prausnitz (1979) ; Edwards and Prausnitz (1981) ; Burkhard (1985) ; Tu (1994) ; Sawaya et al. (2004) ; Asher and Pankow (2006) ; Pankow and Asher (2008) ; Nannoolal et al. (2008) ; Moller et al. (2008) ; Ceriani et al. (2013) ; Rezakazemi et al. (2013) ; Wang et al. (2015) The idea behind group contribution methods (GCMs) is to decompose a component into pre-defined structural groups (molecular building blocks) and to model the properties of components as a function of their group composition. Usually, additivity of the contributions of the individual structural groups to the value of the target property of the component is assumed (occasionally, also group interactions are considered), and group-specific parameters are fitted to the training data. The target property can then, in principle, be derived for any component that can be built from the parameterized structural groups. Theoretically, this allows GCMs to predict vapor pressures only from molecular structures. However, in practice, most methods require one additional experimental data point, such as, e.g., the normal boiling temperature Nannoolal et al. (2008) ; Moller et al. (2008) ; Sawaya et al. (2004) or the critical temperature Wang et al. (2015) . Only very few GCMs, e.g., those by Pankow and Asher Pankow and Asher (2008) and Tu Tu (1994) , apply to a wide range of components since they do not require any experimental data. Further limitations arise from the chemical space covered by the structural groups considered in the GCMs. QSPR and early machine learning methods. Beck et al. (2000) ; Gharagheizi et al. (2012) ; Katritzky et al. (2007) The idea of quantitative structure-property relations (QSPR) methods Katritzky et al. (1995) is to identify the molecular descriptors that are most informative for the thermophysical property to be predicted and to find a suitable correlation between these descriptors and the target property. These molecular descriptors are associated with the chemical structure of the molecule. Some simple examples are the dipole moment, the molecular volume and information on the connectivity of the atoms in the molecule Katritzky et al. (2007) . The QSPR approach has been used to develop methods for predicting vapor pressures in different ways, e.g., the descriptors have been used as input for a multilinear regression Katritzky et al. (2007) or the training of neural networks (NNs) Gharagheizi et al. (2012) ; Beck et al. (2000) . Equation of state based methods. Hsieh and Lin (2008) ; Wang et al. (2015) ; Liang et al. (2019) ; Habicht et al. (2023) ; Felton et al. (2024) ; Winter et al. (2023) These methods derive the parameters of an EoS from the molecular structure (or certain descriptors of which) and use this EoS to calculate thermophysical properties, enabling the EoS to generalize over components. For example, Hsieh et al. Hsieh and Lin (2008) introduced a Peng-Robinson (PR) EoS parameterized using descriptors obtained from COSMO Klamt and Eckert (2000) ; Bell et al. (2020) calculations. With the resulting PR+COSMOSAC EoS Hsieh and Lin (2008) ; Wang et al. (2015) ; Liang et al. (2019) , pure component vapor pressures can be predicted. There are also some recent works Habicht et al. (2023) ; Felton et al. (2024) ; Winter et al. (2023) that leverage EoS for pure component vapor pressure prediction, which are, however, discussed in the next section, as the focus of

Read the complete text