2p-2h Cross-Section Systematics in DUNE
Lars Bathe-Peters · 2025
Read 2p-2h Cross-Section Systematics in DUNE by Lars Bathe-Peters (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-08725.txt.
Introduction
Lars Bathe-Peters, writing alone, studies a hard-to-pin-down neutrino reaction for the DUNE experiment in this 2025 report. In this reaction, called 2p-2h, a neutrino strikes a bound pair of nucleons in a nucleus. Poor knowledge of such nuclear effects is a top source of error for neutrino work.
Bathe-Peters compares three leading models of the charged-current form of this reaction. He also sets out a set of uncertainty terms built to cover the gaps between models. These terms feed into the DUNE oscillation analysis. The aim is a model whose stated error bars honestly match what the data can support.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lars Bathe-Peters |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 11 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-08725
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
2p-2h Cross-Section Systematics in DUNE Lars Bathe-Peters Abstract For the operation of precision neutrino experiments, the understanding of neutrino interactions with matter is a preconditioned requirement for all detections and measurements of neutrinos. The largest uncertainties in estimating neutrino-nucleus interaction cross sections arise from the incomplete understanding of nuclear effects. In the study of neutrino oscillations and nuclear scattering processes, obtaining an interaction model with associated uncertainties is of sub- stantial interest for the neutrino physics community. This report presents studies of simulated CC 2p-2h interactions, in which a neutrino interacts with a bound pair of nucleons. This interaction mode is very poorly constrained by current data. A comparison of three leading CC 2p-2h models is presented, along with a number of uncertainty parameters that have been implemented to account for model-to-model discrepancies in the DUNE oscillation analysis. 1 Introduction Figure 1 : Left: Illustrations of neutrino-nucleus interactions. Figures taken or adapted from [ 1 ] Right: Unoscillated DUNE, No \nu a and T2K flux predictions overlaid with neutrino-argon cross sections as a function of the neutrino energy. Plot from L. Pickering. Figure 2 : Nuclear Effects that complicate the description of neutrino-nucleus scattering. These can be categorised into initial state effects (left) such as Fermi motion, nucleon-binding processes (middle) for example via virtual pion exchange and final-state interactions (right) such as pion production or charge exchange within the nuclear medium. Figures taken or adapted from [ 1 , 2 ] . Figure 3 : Charged-current 2p-2h model differences in the Martini, Valencia and the SuSAv2 models. Table adapted from [ 3 ] . The DUNE experiment is a 1300 km long-baseline neutrino oscillation experiment with the goal of measuring neutrino oscillation parameters, searching for CP violation, proton decay and supernova neutrinos. Moreover, there is a physics program for beyond the standard model physics, atmospheric neutrinos, dark matter searches as well as a rich neutrino interaction program. One of the roles of the DUNE near detector is the tuning of the neutrino-nucleus interaction model. A determination of neutrino oscillation parameters requires an accurate reconstructed neutrino energy, since the relevant cross section applies to the true neutrino energy. The right plot in fig. 1 shows the unoscillated DUNE near detector flux predictions alongside the oscillated one overlaid with the partial neutrino cross section predictions for various neutrino interaction channels shown on the left. This picture becomes more complicated when considering nuclear effects (see fig. 2 ). Table 1 : Model elements of tunes used in the simulation of muon neutrino interactions on argon. Model element Set name G18_10a_00_000 G18_10s_00_000 G18_10e_00_000 Nuclear (Ground-State) Model Local Fermi Gas Local Fermi Gas Local Fermi Gas Quasi-Elastic (QE) processes Nieves Nieves Nieves 2p-2h (MEC)-processes Nieves (Valencia) SuSAv2 Empirical Resonance (RES) production Berger-Sehgal Berger-Sehgal Berger-Sehgal Deep Inelastic Scattering (DIS) Bodek-Yang Bodek-Yang Bodek-Yang Coherent (COH) production Berger-Sehgal Berger-Sehgal Berger-Sehgal Final-State Interactions (FSI) INTRANUKE hA 2018 INTRANUKE hA 2018 INTRANUKE hA 2018 2 Charged-Current 2p-2h Neutrino-Nucleus Interactions 2p-2h Charged-Current (CC) neutrino-nucleus scattering events are interactions in which the neutrino scatters off a bound state of two nucleons giving rise to a lepton and two particles in the final state. As two particles get ejected from the nuclear medium, they leave two holes behind, hence the name 2-particle-2-hole interactions. The differences in theoretical computations of the 2p-2h process according to the 2p-2h Martini, Valencia and SuSAv2 models are highlighted in fig. 3 . The main differences between these models lie in the contributing Feynman diagrams that enter the calculation and the interferences of respective resonances. 3 CC 2p-2h Uncertainty Parameters There are currently three 2p-2h models implemented in the GENIE neutrino event generator. The model set configurations used for all results shown in this work are listed in table 1 . The following results were obtained by simulating muon-neutrino interactions on argon using the GENIE neutrino event generator for the CC 2p-2h SuSAv2, Valencia and Empirical model. The goal of this study is to choose uncertainties such that the measurement of the oscillation parameters is not biased in case the wrong model is chosen. Hereby, systematic parameters allow us to challenge and depart from the physics assumptions implemented in the central value predictions which in DUNE is the CC 2p-2h SuSAv2 model. This is achieved by the method of event reweighting. 3.1 Normalisation Parameter As the name suggests the normalisation parameter changes the absolute normalization of variable distributions. The effect of varying its related dial can be seen on the left in fig. 4 . Figure 4 : Left: The normalisation parameter. The default CC2p-2h SuSAv2 model prediction is shown in orange. Middle and right: Reweighting by changing the nucleon angular distribution dependency. By changing the normalisation parameter, one can reweight these distributions up and down. 3.2 Nucleon Angular Distribution A slightly more complicated parameter is a nucleon angular distribution parameter that modifies the angular dependency of the struck nucleon pair. In the default model prediction (SuSAv2), the nuclear angular distribution is isotropic, meaning that the cosine of this angle is a flat distribution. This can be seen in in the middle and right in fig. 4 . This assumption is challenged by introducing a weight that leads to an angular distribution that is dependent on the squared-cosine of the decay angle. The effect is an enhancement of events in the forward and backward scattering regions and a suppression of scattering at right angles. This choice of changing the angular dependence in this way is not well physically motivated as the underlying physics of these outgoing nucleon directions is challenging to describe. In order to accommodate this difficulty, another dial was implemented that changes the frequency of the distribution (see fig. 4 ). 3.3 Nucleon Pair Content The nucleon pair content parameter changes the fraction of pn-pairs inside the nuclear medium (see fig. 5 ). Figure 5 : Left: A default fraction of pn-pairs inside the nuclear medium prior to the neutrino interaction determines the frequency of neutrinos scattering off bound states of two nucleons. These give rise to different proton multiplicites (middle). Right: Effect of reweighting the energy dependence parameter. As the number of np-pairs is increased, there are more 2-proton final states. Consequently, there are less 1-proton final states as more np-pairs means less nn-pairs. 3.4 CC 2p-2h Model Shape Differences The cross-section shape parameter interpolates between the CC 2p-2h models. This is usually considered in the three-momentum transfer versus energy-transfer plane as it is shown in fig. 6 . Figure 6 : The cross-section interpolation parameter allows the transition from the Valencia (left) and SuSAv2 (middle) model to the Empirial (right) model via event reweighting. The idea is to reweight from one to the other model. The reweighting using this parameter from the SuSAv2 to the Empirical model is shown in fig. 6 . One characteristic feature of the Valencia model in this plane is the second peak that results from resonances and interference terms. This two-peak structure vanishes when reweighting from the Valencia to the empirical model. There is good agreement with the nominal prediction. In the future it would be interesting to weight features of the models individually rather than interpolate between models. 3.5 Energy Dependence The energy dependence parameter changes the energy dependence