Addressing Intersectionality, Explainability, and Ethics in AI-Driven Diagnostics: A Rebuttal and Call for Transdiciplinary Action

Myles Joshua Toledo Tan, Panayiotis V. Benos · 2025

Read Addressing Intersectionality, Explainability, and Ethics in AI-Driven Diagnostics: A Rebuttal and Call for Transdiciplinary Action by Myles Joshua Toledo Tan, Panayiotis V. Benos (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-08497.txt.

Introduction

Myles Joshua Toledo Tan and Panayiotis Benos answer a call to put accuracy first in AI diagnosis by urging a wider lens, in a paper from two thousand twenty-five. Accuracy matters, they grant, but fairness, privacy, and layered identity can be flattened into mere scores. Their rebuttal asks for work across social science, ethics, and public health.

Clear explanations must sit at the core of design so users can trust and check the tools. Layered traits, like race plus sex plus income, can stack harms that single marks miss. The authors propose a frame that holds accuracy beside fairness, privacy, and inclusion. Readers get a plea for diagnosis tools that serve mixed publics well.

Catalog record

CREATORMyles Joshua Toledo Tan, Panayiotis V. Benos
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE16 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-08497

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Addressing Intersectionality, Explainability, and Ethics in AI-Driven Diagnostics: A Rebuttal and Call for Transdiciplinary Action Myles Joshua Toledo Tan, Panayiotis V. Benos Abstract The increasing integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into medical diagnostics necessitates a critical examination of its ethical and practical implications. While the prioritization of diagnostic accuracy, as advocated by Sabuncu et al. 2025 , is essential, this approach risks oversimplifying complex socio-ethical issues, including fairness, privacy, and intersectionality. This rebuttal emphasizes the dangers of reducing multifaceted health disparities to quantifiable metrics and advocates for a more transdisciplinary approach. By incorporating insights from social sciences, ethics, and public health, AI systems can address the compounded effects of intersecting identities and safeguard sensitive data. Additionally, explainability and interpretability must be central to AI design, fostering trust and accountability. This paper calls for a framework that balances accuracy with fairness, privacy, and inclusivity to ensure AI-driven diagnostics serve diverse populations equitably and ethically. keywords artificial intelligence, ethical AI, explainability, fairness, intersectionality, medical diagnostics, privacy \copyrightstatement 1 Introduction Sabuncu et al. 2025 propose prioritizing diagnostic accuracy over fairness in AI-driven medical diagnostics, asserting that optimizing performance for individual sub-populations should take precedence over achieving equity across groups. While their intent to enhance diagnostic outcomes is commendable, this perspective neglects critical ethical dimensions. Specifically, their approach overlooks the importance of intersectionality, privacy, and the role of transdisciplinary collaboration in shaping equitable and inclusive AI systems. As engineers and quantitative scientists ourselves, we acknowledge the grave danger in speaking on matters of ethics without incorporating insights from social scientists, ethicists, and practitioners in the fields we aim to transform. It is easy to reduce complex and nuanced issues into quantifiable metrics, stripping them of their human and societal dimensions. In this rebuttal, we call for the authors, and ourselves, to take several steps back, critically reflect on the implications of their propositions, and consider their potential ripple effects across the biomedical engineering community, healthcare systems, and the populations we aim to serve. Moreover, as Tan et al. 2025 highlight, broader determinants of health, such as lifestyle and environmental factors, profoundly shape patient outcomes and healthcare disparities. These elements, alongside demographic and clinical data, must be incorporated into AI diagnostics to create systems that are both precise and reflective of real-world complexities. This reflection is not merely an intellectual exercise but a moral imperative to ensure our contributions do not inadvertently exacerbate existing inequities. 2 The Centrality of Intersectionality in Fairness and Diagnostics Sabuncu et al. 2025 treat sub-populations as discrete entities, a reductionist stance that fails to account for the intersecting factors that shape health outcomes. Intersectionality, introduced by Crenshaw 1989 , underscores how overlapping identities, such as race, gender, and socioeconomic status, compound experiences of privilege and discrimination. Ignoring these intersections risks producing diagnostic models that reinforce, rather than mitigate, health disparities. While Sabuncu et al. 2025 mention using sub-populations such as those defined by race, they do not specify how these groups would be delineated. This omission is problematic given that race, as a social construct, lacks a consistent genetic basis and varies significantly across contexts. For example, African populations are more genetically diverse than populations from other continents, yet diagnostic models often treat "race" as a homogenous variable ( Tishkoff and Kidd 2004 ) . Such simplifications risk perpetuating biases and inaccuracies, particularly when genetic and environmental factors interact with social determinants of health. Moreover, as Smedley and Smedley 2005 emphasize, race is a social construct with no consistent biological or genetic basis. The traits often associated with racial categories, such as skin color or hair texture, are shaped by a small subset of genes and do not correspond to deeper genetic variation. Using race as a diagnostic proxy perpetuates misconceptions that racial groups represent biologically distinct categories. These misconceptions obscure the structural inequities, such as systemic racism and unequal access to healthcare, that underlie health disparities. Granularity presents another challenge. As Sabuncu et al. 2025 suggest, defining increasingly fine-grained sub-populations might improve diagnostic accuracy for small groups, but it also exacerbates issues like data scarcity and resource constraints. Moreover, arbitrary categorizations, such as broad racial labels like "Asian" or "Black", fail to capture the diversity within these groups and could lead to inequities in diagnosis and treatment ( Yudell et al. 2016 ) . While Tan et al. 2025 do not emphasize intersectionality, their insights into the integration of lifestyle and environmental factors provide a complementary perspective. Health outcomes are deeply intertwined with determinants such as diet, physical activity, and air quality, which are shaped by systemic inequities and access to resources. For instance, marginalized populations often face environmental risks (e.g., exposure to pollution) and barriers to healthy lifestyles (e.g., access to nutritious food and safe spaces for exercise). Incorporating these determinants into AI systems is essential for addressing the multifaceted nature of health disparities. Diagnostic models that fail to consider these real-world variables risk oversimplifying the factors contributing to disease and misrepresenting the true health challenges faced by diverse populations. For instance, diagnostic tools optimized for individual sub-populations may fail to recognize how structural inequities compound across intersecting identities. A low-income Black woman, for example, faces unique vulnerabilities due to the convergence of racial, economic, and gendered inequities. Studies like that of Obermeyer et al. 2019 have shown that failing to account for such complexities can result in biased algorithms that systematically underdiagnose or misdiagnose marginalized groups. Beyond practical performance, the lack of intersectional fairness in AI systems poses ethical and societal risks. Diagnostic tools perceived as inequitable undermine trust in healthcare, especially among historically marginalized communities. This erosion of trust further entrenches healthcare disparities, counteracting the potential benefits of AI-driven advancements. Healthcare systems that ignore these broader determinants risk perpetuating inequities. For example, diagnostic AI optimized without consideration of environmental contexts might overlook disparities in exposure to chronic stressors or pollutants. By situating AI diagnostics within this broader context, as Tan et al. 2025 propose through their Healthcare 5.0 framework, we can move toward a human-centric, sustainable, and equitable model. By incorporating more nuanced measures, such as intersectional fairness metrics and environmental, lifestyle, and structural determinants of health, diagnostic AI can better address the complexity of real-world disparities. This requires moving away from arbitrary group definitions and embracing multidimensional data integration to reflect patients’ lived realities. 3 Privacy and Security: Beyond Technical Compliance Sabuncu et al. 2025 recommend leveraging sensitive attributes like race or gender to optimize diagnostic accuracy. While theoretically promising, this raises profound concerns about privacy, data security, and compliance with legal frameworks like the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). These issues are particularly salient in healthcare, where breaches of sensitive data can have devastating consequences. The use of sensitive attributes increases the risk of re-identification, especially in datasets linked with external sources. For marginalized communities, this risk is amplified by the potential for misuse of their data, leading to discrimination or stigma. Incorporating sensitive attributes without robust safeguards could expose individuals to systemic harms, undermining the very goals of equity and inclusivity. Moreover, technical compliance with privacy laws is insufficient to address the ethical dimensions of data use. Patients often lack meaningful consent, with limited understanding of how their data will be used or

Read the complete text