A study of pendular liquid bridge between two equal solid spheres
James Q. Feng · 2025
Read A study of pendular liquid bridge between two equal solid spheres by James Q. Feng (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-08344.txt.
Introduction
James Feng studied in 2025 the thin liquid bridge that forms between two equal solid balls, hanging like a small ring where they nearly touch. Such bridges arise when vapor condenses in the gap, and they pull the balls together. The exact shape follows a classic surface equation, but many simple shortcuts are used in practice.
Feng checks those shortcuts and fitted formulas against the exact solution and finds where each drifts. Gap distance between the balls turns out to play a central role in ring formation and force strength. A ring-shaped shortcut is fairly good, above all at tiny gaps. An oval profile is sharper but too complex for daily use.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | James Q. Feng |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-08344
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A study of pendular liquid bridge between two equal solid spheres James Q. Feng Abstract Pendular liquid bridges with concave meridians between two equal rigid spheres are mathematically studied emphasizing some less analyzed facts in the literature. Discrepancies from the numerical solution of the Young-Laplace equation are examined among typical simplifying approximations and a few curve-fitting formulas. An in-depth analysis is provided about the important role of separation distance between spheres played in pendular ring formation via capillary condensation at a given relative humidity and the strength of subsequent capillary forces. For most practical situations, the toroidal approximation could be reasonably accurate (especially with diminishing separation distance) and provide valuable mathematical insights at least in a qualitative sense with its relatively simple analytical formulas. Using the elliptic meridional profile generally offers more accurate approximations, but with such complicated analytical formulas that it would limit its convenience for practical applications. With a few examples, the present study shows that curve-fitting formulas cannot be perfect and, by their approximative nature, would always leave room for improvements; therefore, care should be taken when applying curve-fitting formulas, to avoid undesirable errors. Keywords: Young-Laplace equation, pendular bridge, capillary condensation, capillary forces, mathematical approximation 1 Introduction Everyday experience indicates that moist sand (as well as soils, powders, and granular materials in general) can be easily shaped for building castles, while dry sand can flow without much cohesivity, yet too much moisture would make the sand soggy. Early studies of soil cohesion property have suggested the significant effects of capillary forces when wet [ 1 , 2 ] . To enable quantified analysis, the “ideal soil” with uniform rigid spheres in regular packing was considered to understand the moisture effects on soil mechanics. With an idealized model, it is shown that the presence of a small amount of liquid between two solid spheres would form a so-called pendular ring meniscus which can exert substantial capillary forces on the spheres. Even when these spheres are not in solid-solid contact, they could still be connected by a liquid bridge with the pendular ring. The capillary forces associated with such an axisymmetric meniscus of the pendular liquid bridge have been the subject of serious investigation by numerous authors over a century [ 3 ] – [ 11 ] , due to their relevance to many natural phenomena and practical processes. Quantitative calculations of the capillary forces due to a pendular ring meniscus can be important for understanding not only the adhesion-cohesion of powder particles, but also the behavior of insects, frogs, and geckos [ 12 , 13 ] , as well as sintering of ceramic and metallic particles [ 14 , 15 ] , even relevant to stiction of slider in magnetic memory hard discs [ 16 ] . The physical mechanism for forming a liquid bridge may be described by the Kelvin equation which indicates that capillary condensation could occur on a liquid surface with negative mean curvature even in a subsaturated vapor environment. Moreover, the excess pressure due to the mean curvature of the liquid bridge surface is a significant contributor to the capillary adhesion force between particles. Therefore, efforts have been made to determine the geometric shape and the associated value of mean curvature of a liquid bridge surface, as the solution of the well-established Young-Laplace equation which can only be computed numerically [ 7 , 8 ] . Studies with the toroidal approximation [ 3 , 9 , 10 ] considerably simplified the calculations, but have been found inaccurate for some situations [ 4 , 5 , 17 ] . Given the inconvenience with numerical computations, Lian and Seville [ 18 ] started to develop analytical formulas by curve-fitting numerically computed results, for general usage. However, the curve-fitting approach could not satisfy all the needs arising from various applications; hence similar efforts have been continuing to the present day [ 19 , 20 ] . Recently, Kruyt and Millet [ 11 ] have suggested an interesting analytical model with an elliptic approximation of the meniscus meridional profile, significantly improving the accuracy of the toroidal model but involving lengthy algebraic manipulations. The present work would examine discrepancies among typical simplifying approximations and the accuracy of a few curve-fitting formulas, emphasizing mathematical explanations of some less analyzed aspects in the literature with the hope of providing enhanced understanding and confidence in calculated values. Figure 1: Illustrative sketch of a pendular liquid bridge between two equal solid spheres with a half separation distance S , the three-phase contact point at z_{c}=S+R(1-\cos\chi) and r_{c}=R\sin\chi , liquid-solid wetting angle \theta and liquid half filling angle \chi (where \beta denotes the bridge neck radius and \rho the radius of curvature of bridge meridional profile) 2 Problem Formulation Considered here is a pendular liquid bridge with a concave meridian formed between two equal solid spheres of radius R separated by a distance of 2S , with the liquid-solid wetting angle \theta and half-filling angle \chi as depicted in figure 1 (based on the toroidal approximation). Motivated by the interest in water vapor-assisted sintering of metal nanoparticle inks for printed electronics [ 21 ] , the length scales in this study are assumed sufficiently small that the effect of gravity is negligible; hence, the pressure inside liquid has a constant value determined solely by the mean curvature of the axisymmetric meniscus and liquid surface tension \sigma . Therefore, the free surface shape of a liquid bridge becomes the essential basis for subsequent analyses, and has a special place, as the case of (static) mechanical equilibrium, in studying the broader dynamic behavior of liquid bridges [ 22 ] - [ 26 ] . For clarity in presentation with consistent nomenclature, most of the mathematical derivations are displayed in the following subsections. To avoid unnecessary distractions, the attention here is focused on the situation of the concave meridian, i.e., with \chi+\theta\leq\pi/2 and hence \beta\leq r_{c} . 2.1 Governing equations The shape of axisymmetric free surface r(z) is governed by the Young-Laplace equation [ 7 , 8 , 11 ] {2H}={\nabla\cdot{\bf{n}}}=\frac{1}{r\sqrt{1+(dr/dz)^{2}}}-\frac{d^{2}r/dz^{2}}{[1+(dr/dz)^{2}]^{3/2}}=\frac{\Delta p}{\sigma}\quad, (1) where the unit normal vector at liquid bridge surface is defined as {\bf{n}}=\frac{{\bf{e_{r}}}-(dr/dz){\bf{e_{z}}}}{\sqrt{1+(dr/dz)^{2}}}=\frac{(dz/dr){\bf{e_{r}}}-{\bf{e_{z}}}}{\sqrt{1+(dz/dr)^{2}}}\quad, (2) and \Delta p denotes the excess pressure inside liquid bridge, \sigma the surface tension. To complete the problem description, there are boundary conditions to be satisfied \frac{dr}{dz}=0\quad\mathrm{at}\,z=0\,\,(\mathrm{where}\,r=\beta)\quad; (3) \frac{dr}{dz}=\tan\left(\frac{\pi}{2}-\chi-\theta\right)\quad\mathrm{at}\,z_{c}=S+R(1-\cos\chi)\,\,(\mathrm{and}\,r_{c}=R\sin\chi\,)\quad. (4) Thus, the mathematical problem becomes well-defined with the specified values of R , S , \chi , and \theta , leaving \beta as a parameter determined as part of the solution. It can also be solved by specifying R , \beta , \chi , and \theta , but leaving S as a parameter as part of the solution [ 11 ] , among other possibilities. 2.2 Solution to the Young-Laplace equation Now, for a rigorous calculation, the Young-Laplace equation (1) can be rearranged as {2H}={\nabla\cdot{\bf{n}}}=\frac{dz/dr}{r\sqrt{1+(dz/dr)^{2}}}+\frac{d^{2}z/dr^{2}}{[1+(dz/dr)^{2}]^{3/2}}=\frac{\Delta p}{\sigma} (5) where \frac{d^{2}z/dr^{2}}{[1+(dz/dr)^{2}]^{3/2}}=\frac{d}{dr}\left[\frac{dz/dr}{\sqrt{1+(dz/dr)^{2}}}\right]=\frac{du}{dr}\quad, with u=\cos\varpi and \varpi being the angle between the tangent to the meridian curve and z-axis. Thus, the Young-Laplace equation becomes \frac{du}{dr}+\frac{u}{r}=2H=\frac{\Delta p}{\sigma}\quad,\mathrm{namely}\,,\,\,r\frac{du}{dr}+u=2Hr\quad. (6) The first integral of ( 6 ) yields ru=Hr^{2}+C\quad. (7) At z_{c}=S+R(1-\cos\chi) and r_{c}=R\sin\chi , we have dz/dr=\tan(\chi+\theta) and u=\sin(\chi+\theta) (where \varpi=\pi/2-\chi-\theta ), yielding C=R\sin\chi[\sin(\chi+\theta)-HR\sin\chi]\quad. And as z\to 0 , dz/dr\to\infty , u\to 1 and r\to\beta ,