Lake- and Surface-Based Detectors for Forward Neutrino Physics
Nicholas W. Kamp, Carlos A. Argüelles, Albrecht Karle, Jennifer Thomas, Tianlu Yuan · 2025
Read Lake- and Surface-Based Detectors for Forward Neutrino Physics by Nicholas W. Kamp, Carlos A. Argüelles, Albrecht Karle, Jennifer Thomas, Tianlu Yuan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-08278.txt.
Introduction
Nicholas Kamp, Carlos Argüelles, Albrecht Karle, Jennifer Thomas, and Tianlu Yuan propose two neutrino detectors near the Large Hadron Collider, in a 2025 paper. Neutrinos made in collider crashes fly forward in huge numbers and are rarely studied. One design places panels on the surface above a collision point. The other sinks a water detector into Lake Geneva to watch a second collision point.
Simulations predict millions of neutrino events during the collider's high-output era. The surface detector would catch muon neutrinos, while the lake detector sees all flavors. The data could pin down how often neutrinos interact and how charm particles are made in crashes. The authors pitch both as cheap partners to a planned forward physics facility.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nicholas W. Kamp, Carlos A. Argüelles, Albrecht Karle, Jennifer Thomas, Tianlu Yuan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 27 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-08278
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Lake- and Surface-Based Detectors for Forward Neutrino Physics Nicholas W. Kamp, Carlos A. Argüelles, Albrecht Karle, Jennifer Thomas, Tianlu Yuan Abstract We propose two medium-baseline, kiloton-scale neutrino experiments to study neutrinos from LHC proton-proton collisions: SINE, a surface-based scintillator panel detector observing muon neutrinos from the CMS interaction point, and UNDINE, a water Cherenkov detector submerged in lake Geneva observing all-flavor neutrinos from LHCb. Using a Monte Carlo simulation, we estimate millions of neutrino interactions during the high-luminosity LHC era. We show that these datasets can constrain neutrino cross sections, charm production in p p pp collisions, and strangeness enhancement as a solution to the cosmic-ray muon puzzle. SINE and UNDINE thus offer a cost-effective medium-baseline complement to the proposed short-baseline forward physics facility. I Introduction Figure 1: Illustration of experimental layout. Top: shows sky-view vision of the area around the LHC including potential locations for the detectors. Middle and bottom: shows a side view of the UNDINE and SINE detector setups. The geometries shown in this figure are only approximate and for illustration purposes only. Illustration by Jackapan Pairin. It has been realized since 1984 De Rujula and Ruckl 1984 that proton-proton ( pp ) collisions at the large hadron collider (LHC) produce a collimated beam of neutrinos along the collision axis, or the “forward direction” De Rujula and Ruckl 1984 ; De Rújula et al. 1993 ; Fernández 1993 . These neutrinos come from the decay of forward-going hadrons, including pions, kaons, charm mesons, and B mesons De Rujula and Ruckl 1984 ; De Rújula et al. 1993 . They offer a unique opportunity to study the interaction of TeV neutrinos in a controlled laboratory setting, enabling precise measurements of the neutrino cross section at these energies Mammen Abraham et al. 2024a . Forward neutrinos also carry important hadronic information in both their production and their detection Feng et al. 2023 . Furthermore, a relatively large number of tau neutrinos are produced, mostly from D and D_{s} decays De Rújula et al. 1993 . Observations of these tau neutrinos could substantially enlarge the global collection rate, enabling unique physics Mammen Abraham et al. 2022 . Collider-generated neutrinos from the LHC were observed for the first time in 2023 by the ForwArd SEaRch (FASER) experiment Abreu et al. 2023 . Since then, FASER has performed the first measurements of the total \nu_{e} and \nu_{\mu} cross sections in the TeV energy regime Mammen Abraham et al. 2024a . Following the success of FASER, there are plans to construct the Forward Physics Facility (FPF) Anchordoqui et al. 2022a ; Adhikary et al. 2024 by excavating a cavern underground along the ATLAS forward beamline with enough space to house larger detectors. These larger detectors have various physics goals: searches for the decay of new, heavy particles — FASER2 Feng et al. 2023 —, neutrino and light dark matter detection — FASER \nu 2 Batell et al. 2021a ; Feng et al. 2023 , Advanced SND@LHC Abbaneo et al. 2024 , FLArE Batell et al. 2021b ,— and searches for millicharged particles — FORMOSA Foroughi-Abari et al. 2021 . Beyond the objectives listed above, the FPF will also have world-leading sensitivity to many models of hypothetical long-lived particles produced along the forward direction in pp collisions Anchordoqui et al. 2022a . Despite the success and vitality of this program, we would like to point out two important observations relevant to the neutrino physics aspects of the existing program. First, the neutrino beam produced at the pp collision is very collimated compared to traditional neutrino beams Aguilar-Arevalo et al. 2009 ; Adamson et al. 2016 ; Abe et al. 2019 , with a spread of \mathcal{O}(10\,{\rm m}) at distances of \mathcal{O}(10\,{\rm km}) . This implies that a detector placed far away from the interaction point will still capture most of the beam with a relatively small experiment. The key advantage is that such a detector would be unconstrained from near-siting logistics and other beam-induced backgrounds, such as high-energy muons. Second, the intensity of the forward neutrino beam of the high-luminosity LHC (HL-LHC) is such that millions of neutrinos can be observed with kiloton-scale detectors. This implies that these experiments can achieve a high signal-to-background ratio at the surface level despite cosmic-ray backgrounds. We build upon these insights as well as prior work on experiments deployed in natural environments— IceCube Aartsen et al. 2017 , KM3NeT Margiotta 2014 , and CHIPS Alonso Rancurel et al. 2024 —and exploit the local geography around the LHC to bring new opportunities to neutrino physics. In this letter, we introduce two new detector concepts for medium-baseline forward neutrino (MBF \nu ) physics. The main idea is to deploy kiloton-scale detectors leveraging the surrounding geography at distances of \mathcal{O}(10\,{\rm km}) from the LHC interaction points. The first detector leverages the fact that neutrinos from the CMS interaction point travel through 18 km of bedrock before exiting Earth’s surface. We propose to use scintillator panels to observe upward-going muons from Earth’s surface from upstream neutrino interactions in the preceding bedrock. We refer to this concept as the Surface-based Integrated Neutrino Experiment (SINE). The second detector leverages the fact that neutrinos from the LHCb interaction point pass through lake Geneva by submerging kiloton-scale water Cherenkov detectors around 50 m below the lake’s surface. This is the UNDerwater Integrated Neutrino Experiment (UNDINE) 1 1 1 UNDINE derives from the Latin word unda for wave and is also the name for a water nymph in European folklore. . SINE and UNDINE are cost-effective complements to the planned FPF detectors and can collect \mathcal{O}(10{\rm M}) and \mathcal{O}(0.1{\rm M}) neutrino interactions over the course of the HL-LHC run, respectively. These detectors are represented diagrammatically in Fig. 1 . The remainder of the letter is organized as follows. Section II describes the SINE and UNDINE detectors in more detail as well as the forward neutrino beamline model used. Next, Section III presents a simulation-based calculation of the neutrino interaction rates observed by SINE and UNDINE during the HL-LHC. We discuss three physics opportunities enabled by these datasets in Section IV : cross sections, charm production, and constraints on a solution to the cosmic-ray muon puzzle. We conclude in Section V with the next steps toward deploying SINE and UNDINE for the HL-LHC. II The Lake and Surface Detectors The SINE and UNDINE detectors rely on the forward neutrino flux produced at CMS and LHCb, respectively. A birds-eye view of the neutrino beam from these two interaction points is shown in the top panel of Fig. 1 . To model this flux, we use the forward neutrino flux computed in ATLAS presented in Ref. Mäkelä ; Kling et al. 2023 . While there will be differences between the flux profiles at each interaction point, this is a reasonable approximation for this first study. More details about the flux profile assumed here are given in Appendix A . We now turn to the detectors themselves. As depicted in the bottom panel of Fig. 1 , the SINE detector looks for upward-going muons using scintillator panels located at the point through which the forward neutrino beamline from the CMS interaction point exits the Earth’s surface, corresponding to a distance