Fluctuating Ensemble Averages and the BTZ Threshold

R. Sammani, E.H Saidi, R. Ahl Laamara, L.B Drissi · 2025

Read Fluctuating Ensemble Averages and the BTZ Threshold by R. Sammani, E.H Saidi, R. Ahl Laamara, L.B Drissi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-08257.txt.

Introduction

R Sammani, E Saidi, R Ahl Laamara, and L Drissi explore, in a 2025 paper, what the wobble around an average can teach about black holes and quantum gravity. Ensemble averaging has lately linked two-dimensional field theories to gravity, but the averaging implies symmetries that quantum gravity is thought to forbid. The cure may live in the fluctuations: small departures from the average formula. The authors ask which physical states those departures represent.

Working with an ensemble of Narain theories and its three-dimensional gravity dual, they study a charged black hole and test its stability. Using the weak gravity conjecture as a sieve, they show the fluctuation states sit below the black hole threshold: a sublattice of extra-charged states the hole can emit. They then bound the allowed charge vectors and reshape the state-counting formula to match.

Catalog record

CREATORR. Sammani, E.H Saidi, R. Ahl Laamara, L.B Drissi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE227 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-08257

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Fluctuating Ensemble Averages and the BTZ Threshold R. Sammani, E.H Saidi, R. Ahl Laamara, L.B Drissi Abstract Recent work shows fascinating links between ensemble averaging and the Swampland program. In order to break the emerging global symmetries of the ensemble averaging as dictated by the no global symmetries conjecture, one may consider fluctuations away from the average given by deviations in the Siegel-Weil formula. In this work, we investigate the physical interpretation of these fluctuations in the bulk physics and pinpoint the states giving rise to them. For this purpose, we explore an ensemble of generalised Narain CFTs and build the AdS 3 gravitational dual in the Chern-Simons (CS) framework. We study the associated charged BTZ black hole solution and assess its stability. Using the Swampland weak gravity conjecture, we show that the fluctuations of the ensemble average are below the BTZ threshold and correspond to a sublattice of superextremal states emitted by the black hole. We exploit the logarithmic density of states to derive bounds on the charged vectors of the abelian CS symmetry and introduce a novel formulation of the density function to ensure consistency with the sublattice WGC. We establish bounds that allows to distinguish heavy states contributing to the average from light states generating fluctuations around it. 1 Introduction The Swampland program SP1 - SP4 defines constraints on various aspects of the effective field theories that can be completed into UV quantum gravitational theories (Landscape models) such as the bound on the rank of possible gauge groups Finit1 - Finit4 , the condition on the mass of charged states WGC ; Rajae3 and the structure of the moduli space DC . While the Swampland constraints are often backtested in string theory which helps in motivating and formulating them, the Swampland program is independent of a particular UV completion including string theory. Recent studies Land1 - Rajae2 have identified an intriguing region within the Landscape, populated by 3D topological gravitational theories, which has provided new insights into the Swampland program that had not been apparent previously. This lead to establishing new connections between the Swampland program and holography in quantum gravity research based on quantum gravitational theories with exceptional boundaries given by averaged ensembles AJ ; MW . The usual AdS 3 /CFT 2 correspondence associates a quantum gravity theory in AdS 3 with a 2D CFT on its asymptote. However, recent gravitational theories are shown to be dual not to a single boundary theory but rather to an average over an ensemble of theories. This multi-theory boundary was first observed and studied in JT gravity for AdS 2 /CFT 1 JT , where the ensemble average is computed over a random matrix theory JT1 . In 3D, the average is performed over an ensemble of Narain CFTs; these models are well-known from toroidal compactifications, there are theories of c free bosons with U(1)_{L}^{c}\times U(1)_{R}^{c} current algebra where the positive integer c defines the central charge ( c_{L}=c_{R} ). The average is generated by a bulk described by an exotic theory of quantum gravity, where the sum over possible geometries is captured by the abelian Chern-Simons (CS) theory U(1)_{L}^{c}\times U(1)_{R}^{c} AJ ; MW . A generalization of Narain’s CFTs can be envisioned along the lines of M1 , where one can consider instead of the even self dual lattices, general lattices with indefinite quadratic forms. This defines an abelian CS theory with symmetry U(1)_{L}^{p}\times U(1)_{R}^{q} and \Delta c=p-q central charge. Recently, it has been demonstrated that these generalised Narain theories exhibit global symmetries which is strictly prohibited by the Swampland program. Specifically, the no global symmetries conjecture postulates that all global symmetries of quantum gravitational theories must be either broken or gauged NG . Accordingly, to circumvent them, one must consider fluctuations around the ensemble average, which correspond mathematically to deviations in the Siegel-Weil formula SW1 - SW3 or equivalently to the Roeckle-Selberg spectral decomposition RS1 ; RS2 . However, it remains necessary to address how these fluctuations might be interpreted in the bulk and how they arise from the bulk to the boundary. In this paper, we investigate the bulk equivalent of these fluctuations and explore how additional Swampland criteria may impose constraints on the averaged theory to ensure the consistency of the gravitational bulk. We focus on the Weak Gravity Conjecture (WGC) wgc3 ; chark ; MI and non-supersymmetric AdS conjecture Insta to further probe the relationship between ensemble average and the Swampland program. We consider an ensemble of generalised Narain CFTs and build the corresponding AdS 3 gravitational dual in the Chern-Simons formulation by coupling the basic SL\left(2,\mathbb{R}\right)_{L}\times SL\left(2,\mathbb{R}\right)_{R} to abelian U(1)^{p+q-2} gauge fields. We study the charged BTZ black hole and examine its stability. To derive a constraint relation that regulates the discharge of the black hole, we exploit the modular invariance to compute the sublattice WGC. We show that light superextremal states below the black hole threshold lead to fluctuations around the ensemble averaging. As a consistency check, we employ the logarithmic density of states to derive constraints on the charge vectors of the abelian CS symmetry. To ensure physical consistency with the sublattice WGC, we propose an alternative formulation of the density function by treating the bounds on the charged states as permeable barriers. This provided a novel approach to derive the WGC condition and allowed to categorize states into two phases: heavy (averaged states) and light (fluctuation states). The organisation of this paper is as follows: In section 2 , we begin by describing the differences and similarities between the standard and generalised Narain CFTs and establish the mathematical framework for ensemble averaging. Then, we study the emergence of global symmetries and address their removal by considering fluctuations around the ensemble average. In section 3 , we construct the AdS 3 gravitational bulk of the ensemble average of generalised Narain CFTs. We consider Einstein AdS 3 gravity in the Chern-Simons formulation coupled to U(1) p+q-2 gauge fields. We show that under diagonal boundary conditions, the asymptotic symmetries yield two copies of the asymptotic U(1)_{L}^{p}\times U(1)_{R}^{q} affine algebra and the inaugural Brown-Henneaux boundary conformal symmetry emerges as a composite invariance through a twisted Sugawara construction. In section 4 , we investigate the physical interpretation of these fluctuations from the lens of the bulk physics and identify the states giving rise to them. We start by imposing the modular invariance of the partition function to determine the states populating the sublattice verifying WGC. Then, we demonstrate that light superextremal states generate the fluctuations using the torus density of states. section 5 is reserved for final comments and conclusions. 2 Swampland program of averaged ensembles In this section, we revisit the 3D Landscape of consistent quantum gravitational theories given by holographic models with averaged ensembles as boundary dual. We study generalised Narain CFTs to formulate their average over the generalised Narain moduli space. We examine the emerging global symmetries G global and investigate the restoration of the consistency of the gravitational theories in accordance with the Swampland program forbidding G global by considering fluctuations away from the average of the partition function of the boundary defined by the generalised CFTs. 2.1 Averaged CFTs and the bulk dual With the aim of formulating the

Read the complete text