Background subtraction method is not only much simpler, but also as applicable as covariant counterterm method
Wei Guo 1,2, Xiyao Guo 1,2, Xin Lan 1,2, Hongbao Zhang 1,2, Wei Zhang 1,2 · 2025
Read Background subtraction method is not only much simpler, but also as applicable as covariant counterterm method by Wei Guo 1,2, Xiyao Guo 1,2, Xin Lan 1,2, Hongbao Zhang 1,2, Wei Zhang 1,2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-08214.txt.
Introduction
Wei Guo and co-authors wrote a physics paper in 2025 on black hole heat theory. Two methods compete to compute a black hole's free energy. One subtracts a plain background space; the other adds fix-up terms at the edge. The second is broader but much harder to use.
The team shows the plain method rests on two tests that can both be checked far from the hole. With that shortcut, they prove the plain method works as widely as the harder one. The proof covers plain gravity and gravity with extra correction terms, in both flat and curved-edge spaces. They also give the first general formula for free energy beyond plain gravity. The authors say the simpler method should become the standard choice.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Wei Guo 1,2, Xiyao Guo 1,2, Xin Lan 1,2, Hongbao Zhang 1,2, Wei Zhang 1,2 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-08214
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Background subtraction method is not only much simpler, but also as applicable as covariant counterterm method Wei Guo 1,2, Xiyao Guo 1,2, Xin Lan 1,2, Hongbao Zhang 1,2, Wei Zhang 1,2 Abstract As the criterion for the applicability of the background subtraction method, not only the finiteness condition of the resulting Hamiltonian but also the condition for the validity of the first law of black hole thermodynamics can be reduced to the form amenable to much simpler analysis at infinity by using the covariant phase space formalism. With this, we further establish that the background subtraction method is as applicable as the covariant counterterm method not only to Einstein’s gravity, but also to its higher derivative corrections for black hole thermodynamics in both asymptotically flat and AdS spacetimes. In addition, our framework also provides us with the first derivation of the universal expression of the Gibbs free energy in terms of the Euclidean on-shell action beyond Einstein’s gravity. Among others, our findings have a far reaching impact on the shift in methodology for the Euclidean approach to black hole thermodynamics, where the well justified background subtraction method by our wieldy criterion is supposed to be the favored choice compared to the covariant counterterm method. I Introduction Since its advent, not only has the Euclidean approach to quantum gravity demonstrated its remarkable power in disclosing the thermal nature of stationary black holes, but also displayed its great success in calculating the corresponding Gibbs free energy and related thermodynamic quantities by either the background subtraction method [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 ] or the covariant counterterm method [ 6 , 7 , 8 ] . In particular, via the Euclidean quantum gravity, or its variant AdS/CFT correspondence for asympotically AdS spacetimes, significant progress has recently been made in our understanding of the higher derivative corrections to black hole thermodynamics [ 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 ] , which not only supplies some universal information about the unknown UV theory within the framework of effective field theory, but also sheds insight into the dynamics of the boundary quantum systems beyond the strong coupling and infinite N limits in the context of AdS/CFT correspondence. Despite this, the only two available methods mentioned above are both suspected to have their disadvantages, respectively. The covariant counterterm method turns out to be unwieldy compared to the background subtraction method, because the former generically needs additional terms added on the boundary on top of the generalized Gibbons-Hawking term for a general diffeomorphism covariant theory of gravity. It is noteworthy that these additional boundary terms are not only highly complicated, but also dependent delicately on the spacetime dimension. While the background subtraction method is believed to have a rather restrictive applicability in the sense that the induced metric of the stationary black holes on the boundary cannot always be embedded isometrically into the reference spacetime [ 7 , 8 , 18 , 20 , 21 ] . But nevertheless, as evidenced miraculously by the final correct result it gives rise to, the background subtraction method seems also applicable to some specific circumstances where such an embedding is impossible. This puzzle has remained elusive since the background subtraction method was proposed long before back in the 1970s. Among others, one main purpose of this paper is to resolve the above longstanding puzzle in a confirmative way. To this end, for the first time we have succeeded in reducing the necessary and sufficient conditions for the applicability of the background subtraction method into the form amenable to much simpler analysis at infinity by using the covariant phase space formalism [ 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 , 31 , 32 ] in an innovative manner. It turns out that the resulting criterion does not require the induced metrics be the same, thus evades the restriction on the applicability of the background subtraction method from the isometric embedding. Based on our newly formulated criterion, we establish in an explicit way that the background subtraction method is actually as applicable as the covariant counterterm method not only to Einstein’s gravity but also to its higher derivative corrections in both asymptotically flat and AdS spacetimes, overturning the prevailing belief that the former is inferior to the latter in this regard. Therefore our finding offers the first universal proof for the applicability of the background subtraction method in the aforementioned more generic circumstances. In passing, we also fill the gap in all the calculations via the background subtraction method for the higher derivative corrections to black hole thermodynamics by providing the first proof of the universal relation between the Gibbs free energy and the on-shell Euclidean action beyond Einstein’s gravity, which has been previously assumed without derivation [ 9 , 10 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 22 , 23 ] . In particular, our work will have a direct impact on the shift in methodology for the Euclidean approach to black hole thermodynamics, where the well justified background subtraction method by our wieldy criterion is supposed to be the favorable choice for the relevant calculations, which otherwise would become much more involved via the covariant counterterm method. We will follow the notation and conventions of [ 33 ] . In particular, we shall use the boldface letters to denote differential forms with the tensor indices suppressed. In addition, we shall work in the units with c=\hbar=k_{B}=G_{N}=1 . II Covariant phase space formalism for F(R_{abcd}) gravity In this section, we shall present the relevant ingredients of covariant phase space formalism for F(R_{abcd}) gravity. For details, please refer to [ 31 ] . As such, we start from the Lagrangian form for F(R_{abcd}) gravity as follows \mathbf{L}=\bm{\epsilon}F(R_{abcd},g_{ab}), (1) where \bm{\epsilon} is the spacetime volume form, and F is an arbitrary function of R_{abcd} and g_{ab} . The variation of the Lagrangian form is given by \delta\mathbf{L}=\bm{\epsilon}E^{ab}\delta g_{ab}+d\mathbf{\Theta}. (2) Here E^{ab}=0 is the equation of motion with \displaystyle E_{g}^{ab}=\frac{1}{2}g^{ab}F+\frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial F}{\partial g_{ab}}+2\nabla_{c}\nabla_{d}\psi^{c(ab)d}, (3) and \mathbf{\Theta}=\theta\cdot\bm{\epsilon} is called the bulk symplectic potential with \theta^{a}=2(\nabla_{d}\psi^{bdca}\delta g_{bc}-\psi^{bdca}\nabla_{d}\delta g_{bc}), (4) where \psi^{abcd} is defined as the derivative of F with respect to the Riemann tensor R_{abcd} by assuming it is independent of the metric, abbreviated as \psi^{abcd}\equiv\frac{\partial F}{\partial R_{abcd}} . The Noether current associated with a vector field \xi is given by \mathbf{J}_{\xi}\equiv X_{\xi}\cdot\mathbf{\Theta}-\xi\cdot\mathbf{L}=d\mathbf{Q}_{\xi}, (5) when evaluated on the on-shell solutions with the corresponding Noether charge \mathbf{Q}_{\xi}=(-\psi^{cadb}\nabla_{[d}\xi_{b]}+2\nabla_{[d}\psi^{cadb}\xi_{b]})\bm{\epsilon}_{ca\cdot\cdot\cdot}. (6) Here X_{\xi}\equiv\int d^{d}x\sqrt{-g}\mathcal{L}_{\xi}g_{ab}(x)\frac{\delta}{\delta g_{ab}(x)} is understood as a vector at the point g_{ab}(x) in the configuration space and \delta is regarded as the exterior derivative in the configuration space. On the other hand, with n_{a} as the outward-pointing normal vector and h_{ab} as the induced metric of a timelike boundary \Gamma , which is assumed to be fixed under variation, the variation of n_{a} is always proportional to n_{a} , namely \delta n_{a}=\delta an_{a} with \delta a the proportional coefficient. Accordingly, one can further have \displaystyle\delta n^{a}=-\delta an^{a}-{\mathchar 22\mkern-10.0mu\delta}{A}^{a},\quad\delta g^{ab}=-2\delta an^{a}n^{b}-{\mathchar 22\mkern-10.0mu\delta}A^{a}n^{b}-n^{a}{\mathchar 22\mkern-10.0mu\delta}A^{b}+\delta h^{ab} (7) with {\mathchar 22\mkern-10.0mu\delta}{A}^{a}n_{a}=0 . Whence the bulk symplectic