Anonymous Attention and Abuse
Florian Ederer, Paul Goldsmith-Pinkham and Kyle Jensen · 2025
Read Anonymous Attention and Abuse by Florian Ederer, Paul Goldsmith-Pinkham and Kyle Jensen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-07410.txt.
Introduction
Florian Ederer and co-authors dissect an anonymous forum where economists trade job market talk, and not always kindly. Economics Job Market Rumors is famous inside the field for sharp, nameless posts. The study tracks how the forum leans on outside sources and what that says about the profession online.
Links outward shape much of the forum's diet, and the team maps which domains feed it. Talk driven by Twitter posts has surged since the late twenty tens. The authors sort whose posts get chewed over most, by the poster's traits and fame. The forum plainly moves information through the field. It also stirs hard questions about welcome and ethics, since nameless attention can shade into abuse. Departments may need norms for a space they do not run but cannot ignore.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Florian Ederer, Paul Goldsmith-Pinkham and Kyle Jensen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 20 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-07410
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Anonymous Attention and Abuse Florian Ederer, Paul Goldsmith-Pinkham and Kyle Jensen Abstract \draftSpacing 1.5 \shortTitle Anonymous Attention and Abuse \pubYear 2025 \pubMonth May \pubVolume 115 \pubIssue 1 Economics Job Market Rumors (henceforth EJMR) occupies a controversial position within the economics profession. While it began as an anonymous forum primarily focused on the annual job market for economics PhDs, its scope has expanded significantly over the years. Today, EJMR serves as both a clearinghouse for job market information and a breeding ground for discussions that range from professional commentary to abusive rhetoric. The forum is infamous for hosting content that is defamatory, misogynistic, and otherwise toxic ( Wu, 2018 ; Wu, 2020 ; Ederer, Goldsmith-Pinkham and Jensen, 2024 ) . Its anonymity fosters candid discussions, but it also enables behaviors that contribute to its notoriety. This duality of EJMR—as both a valuable resource and a harmful platform—raises important questions about its role in the economics community. The influence of the platform is considerable. In early 2023, SimilarWeb estimated that EJMR received 2.5 million monthly visits, surpassing even prominent academic resources such as the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) and the American Economic Association (AEA) websites in terms of page views per visit. Such metrics underscore its popularity, but they also highlight its unique position as a digital forum that blends professional and informal exchanges. Despite its popularity, EJMR has been criticized as a “cesspool of misogyny” (David Romer quoted in Wolfers (2017) ), “4chan for economists” ( Lowrey, 2022 ) , and evidence of a toxic culture that marginalizes women and underrepresented groups within the profession ( Wolfers, 2017 ) . Figure 1: Share of discussion topics with links in the first post over time. {figurenotes} This figure plots the share of EJMR topics that begin with a link for the top 10 most popular domains linked on the site over our sample. Figure 2: Number of discussion topics beginning with links over time. {figurenotes} This figure plots the number of EJMR topics that begin with a link for the top 10 most popular domains linked on the site over our sample. A significant focus of EJMR is its function as an aggregator of external information. In this article we analyze EJMR content from January 2012 to May 2023 1 1 1 The end of our sample coincides with the public announcement of the results of Ederer, Goldsmith-Pinkham and Jensen (2024) which significantly changed the content and discourse on EJMR. and show that a sizable proportion of EJMR discussion topics begin with links to other websites, ranging from academic papers and news articles to social media posts and blog entries. Over time, the platform’s reliance on external domains has evolved, reflecting broader changes in how economists interact with information. We show that starting in 2018, EJMR saw an explosion in discussions initiated by references to Twitter posts. This shift mirrors Twitter’s growing importance as a real-time source of information and debate in academic and public policy circles. The analysis of these linked domains offers insight into how the economics profession engages with a diverse array of online platforms and information sources. EJMR’s transformation also underscores the changing landscape of digital discourse in economics. Initially dominated by academic content, the forum has increasingly incorporated references to social media, highlighting its role as a nexus between professional and public discussions. The platform’s toxicity, however, raises ethical questions about its impact on the profession. The prevalence of abusive content, as documented in prior research, contributes to a hostile environment that discourages participation from marginalized groups. This dual nature, as both a valuable resource and a source of harm, necessitates a nuanced examination of its role in shaping economic discourse. Our paper complements previous findings of Ederer, Goldsmith-Pinkham and Jensen (2024) by analyzing EJMR’s evolving interactions with external information sources. We focus on three key aspects: (1) the prevalence and impact of links to external domains; (2) the surge in discussions driven by Twitter posts since 2018; and (3) the categorization of individuals whose tweets and content are discussed on EJMR. Using data on linked domains, we examine how these trends reflect broader changes in the economics profession’s digital footprint. Our analysis not only sheds light on EJMR’s informational role but also raises critical questions about the forum’s implications for inclusivity and professional ethics. 1 Links to External Domains Our examination of EJMR discussions reveals that a significant proportion of discussion topics begin with links to external sites. To measure links to external sites, we use a database of all posts on EJMR from 2012 to May 2023, and identify all links—“anchor” or “ a ” tags with href atributes in the HyperText Markup Language (HTML). We then roll-up these links to their canonical domain name. For example, we combine the two links m.twitter.com and www.twitter.com into the Twitter domain. We focus on the presence of links that are in the first post of a given topic (a thread of posts) in order to avoid double counting and assess the impact of links driving the conversation on EJMR. From January 2012 to May 2023, the proportion of topics containing a link in the first post varies between roughly 10 and 20 percent. These links predominantly direct to academic resources, news outlets, and increasingly over time, to the social media platform Twitter, reflecting the shifting priorities and preferences of EJMR users. Early years exhibit a strong preference for academic and blog-based content, such as NBER papers and Marginal Revolution (a popular economics blog) posts. From 2018 onward, Twitter’s rapid growth reshaped the forum’s linking habits, reflecting broader changes in how economists interact with public and semi-public discussions. This evolution suggests that EJMR has become a microcosm of the economics profession’s digital transformation, with implications for how economic ideas are shared and debated. Figure 1 shows the shares of topics with links in the first post by the domain to which the links point. At the beginning of our sample, approximately 10 percent of the opening posts contain links that direct to YouTube. However, beginning in 2018 the share of topics linking to YouTube disappears almost entirely due to automatic moderation instituted on EJMR. This automatic moderation substantially reduced the ability to post links to YouTube as such posts increasingly contained repetitive spam messages. Z-score of average post classification Number of Twitter Username LLM Description Hate Speech Negativity Misogynistic Toxic Topics realChrisBrunet Right-wing commentator and controversial social media figure -0.127 0.405 0.069 -0.62 325 elonmusk Billionaire entrepreneur and technology influencer -0.332 0.172 -0.146 0.056 302 text35237388338 N/A - Twitter account has been deleted/unavailable -0.37 -7.121 -0.335 -0.851 214 RichardHanania Conservative commentator and president of policy center 0.12 -0.531 -0.029 1.04 189 Claudia_Sahm Economist and expert on fiscal policy and Fed -0.216 0.187 1.974 0.116 172 jenniferdoleac Economist and criminal justice policy expert -0.003 -0.131 2.598 0.657 162 Noahpinion Economics blogger and commentator with a humorous style -0.08 0.065 0.026 0.223 158 JustinWolfers Economics professor and commentator on public policy -0.282 0.273 -0.335 0.048 132 libsoftiktok Conservative social media commentator and agitator -0.264 0.445 0.191 0.232 105 Black Female Economist* N/A - Twitter account has been deleted/unavailable -0.144 0.301 -0.335 -0.205 105 visegrad24 Conservative news aggregator and