Nuclear Explosions for Large Scale Carbon Sequestration
Andy Haverly · 2025
Read Nuclear Explosions for Large Scale Carbon Sequestration by Andy Haverly (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-06623.txt.
Introduction
Andrew Haverly presents a bold climate proposal in a 2025 paper: use a buried nuclear explosion to speed carbon capture. Crushed basalt rock reacts with carbon dioxide and locks it away, a process called enhanced rock weathering, but natural rates are slow. Haverly argues for detonating a device under a remote basalt seabed to pulverize vast rock volumes at once.
Placement under the seabed aims to confine debris, radiation, and energy while the fresh rock surfaces weather fast. The analysis sets out the parameters needed for efficient capture with minimal side effects, and it claims a yield on the order of gigatons is required for global impact. Safety, ecosystem, political, and cost questions are each examined. The paper invites study, not action.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Andy Haverly |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 11 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-06623
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Nuclear Explosions for Large Scale Carbon Sequestration Andy Haverly Abstract Confronting the escalating threat of climate change requires innovative and large-scale interventions. This paper presents a bold proposal to employ a buried nuclear explosion in a remote basaltic seabed for pulverizing basalt, thereby accelerating carbon sequestration through Enhanced Rock Weathering (ERW). By precisely locating the explosion beneath the seabed, we aim to confine debris, radiation, and energy while ensuring rapid rock weathering at a scale substantial enough to make a meaningful dent in atmospheric carbon levels. Our analysis outlines the parameters essential for efficient carbon capture and minimal collateral effects, emphasizing that a yield on the order of gigatons is critical for global climate impact. Although this approach may appear radical, we illustrate its feasibility by examining safety factors, preservation of local ecosystems, political considerations, and financial viability. This work argues for reimagining nuclear technology not merely as a destructive force but as a potential catalyst for decarbonization, thereby inviting further exploration of pioneering solutions in the fight against climate change. 1 Introduction Climate change remains one of humanity’s most pressing existential threats. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) warns that failing to curb global warming could result in massive economic losses ( \$100\text{-}200 trillion by 2100) and the displacement of hundreds of millions of people ( IPCC 2018 ; Stern 2007 ; Rockström et al. 2009 ) . Negative emissions technologies (NETs) are increasingly recognized as essential to limit warming below 2 ∘ C ( Pacala and Socolow 2004 ) . Among NETs, Enhanced Rock Weathering (ERW) can sequester significant quantities of atmospheric CO 2 by accelerating the natural chemical breakdown of silicate rocks, such as basalt ( Schuiling and Krijgsman 2006 ) . The principal barrier to ERW is the immense energy and logistics required to mine, crush, and transport billions of tonnes of rock. Recent proposals have resurrected the idea of peaceful nuclear explosions to do this “heavy lifting.” Historically studied under programs like Project Plowshare ( plo 1961 ) , nuclear blasts can fracture large volumes of geological material. Nuclear explosions are a well-researched topic, but the largest nuclear explosion ever detonated, the Tsar Bomba, only had a yield of 50 megatons of TNT (Mt) ( Narayanan ) . To enable ERW on the required scale using a nuclear explosion, a yield in the gigaton range would be required. This is untested and would require much testing and verification before detonation. 2 Yield Calculations To calculate an effective yield for the nuclear explosion, we will have to make a few assumptions: 1. Every year, approximately 36 gigatons of carbon dioxide are emitted into the atmosphere. ( ) 2. We want to sequester 30 years worth of carbon dioxide emissions. 3. Through ERW, 1 ton of basalt can sequester 0.28 tons of carbon dioxide ( Beerling et al. 2020 ) . 4. The crushing work index of basalt is 22 ( Ram Chandar et al. 2016 ) . 5. In a seafloor buried nuclear explosion, there will be approximately 90% efficiency in pulverizing the basalt. From these assumptions, we can calculate that 1.08 trillion tons of carbon dioxide should be sequestered, 3.86 trillion tons of basalt are needed, the crushing energy needed is 3.05*10^{20} j, and a nuclear explosion yield of 81 Gt is required. This is orders of magnitude larger than the largest nuclear explosion ever detonated, so this is not to be taken lightly. 3 Logistics Detonating a 81 Gt nuclear device could cause a global catastrophe if done improperly. Simply burying a nuclear device in a basalt deposit would cause this catastrophe. However, deep water is incredibly shock absorbant. By buring the nuclear device kilometers underground under kilometers of water, we can be certain that the explosion will first pulverize the rock then be contained by the water. We propose burying this device beneath the Kerguelen Plateau in the Southern Ocean, 3-5 km into the basalt-rich seafloor and 6-8 km below the water’s surface. Under these parameters, there is approximately 800 atm of pressure to absorb the energy. Additionally, nearby currents like the Antarctic Circumpolar Current can distribute the particles for accelerated carbon sequestration. Additionally, the nuclear device should be designed to minimize its long-term radiation effects. To do this, a standard fission-fusion hydrogen bomb design is sufficient. The basalt should absorb and trap in the majority of the radiation to the local area. 4 Analysis and Evaluation This is a radical idea and requires serious discussion around its deployment. This section makes these assumptions about the nuclear device: 1. This explosion can be detonated without global catastrophe. 2. This explosion can sequester 30 years worth of carbon dioxide emissions. 3. This explosion can be detonated within 10 years. 4. This nuclear device is too large to deploy militarily. Additionally, we are assuming that climate change will progress according to current estimates. The estimates range from 1.5^{\circ}-4.5^{\circ} C. With these assumptions, we can compare this plan to current climate change predictions in regards to safety, ecosystem preservation, political feasibility, and financial viability. 4.1 Safety Nuclear explosions are inherently unsafe. They release vast amounts of uncontrolled energy. However, by detonating this nuclear device in a controlled environment we can minimize the impacts. By detonating this nuclear device in a remote location deep in the ocean, the only expected effect on humans is from nuclear radiation. First, this comes in the form of surface radiation and fallout. Because this explosion is so remote and can be timed favorably with the weather, there is little to no expected loss of life from the immediate radiation effects. The long-term effects of global radiation will impact humans and will cause loss of life, but this increased global radiation is “just a drop in the bucket”. Every year, we emit more radiation from coal power plants and we have already detonated over 2000 nuclear devices. Adding one more bomb should have minimal impact on the world. Climate change is also inherently unsafe. By the year 2100, an estimated 30 million lives will be lost from the effects of climate change ( Pozzer et al. 2024 ) . Comparing these effects in regards to safety, it is clear that the nuclear explosion option is favorable. It is approximately 30 million lives safer. 4.2 Ecosystem Preservation The ecological impact from a nuclear explosion is visible. This nuclear detonation will cause extreme destruction and long term radiation to the detonation site. Choosing a barren seafloor can mitigate the ecosystem destruction, but it will still be uninhabitable for decades. This damage will be contained almost entirely to the dozen square kilometers around the detonation site. Climate change, progressing as currently predicted, is profoundly altering global ecosystems through rising temperatures and shifting precipitation patterns. These changes are causing habitat loss and fragmentation, leading to decreased biodiversity as species struggle to adapt or migrate to more suitable environments. Ocean acidification and warming seas are disrupting marine life, particularly affecting coral reefs and fisheries that millions rely on for food and livelihoods. Increased frequency and intensity of extreme weather events, such as hurricanes and wildfires, are further stressing ecosystems and reducing their resilience. Additionally, altered seasonal cycles are impacting plant pollination and animal breeding patterns, ultimately