Comparative Analysis of Perturbed f ⁡ ( R ) f(R) Gravity and Perturbed Rastall Gravity Models in Describing Cosmic Evolution from Early to Late Universe Relative to the Λ \Lambda CDM Model

Muhammad Yarahmadi 1 . Amin Salehi 1 . Hadis Mousavi 1 · 2025

Read Comparative Analysis of Perturbed f ⁡ ( R ) f(R) Gravity and Perturbed Rastall Gravity Models in Describing Cosmic Evolution from Early to Late Universe Relative to the Λ \Lambda CDM Model by Muhammad Yarahmadi 1 . Amin Salehi 1 . Hadis Mousavi 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-06614.txt.

Introduction

Muhammad Yarahmadi, Amin Salehi, and Hadis Mousavi race two modified gravity theories against the standard cosmic model. Their paper appeared in two thousand twenty-five. The rivals are perturbed f(R) gravity and perturbed Rastall gravity. The benchmark is the Lambda CDM model. The contest runs from the early universe to today's acceleration. Each theory must form structure early and speed up late.

Early on, both rivals match the standard model's structure formation. Jeans wavenumbers support that verdict. Late times split the field. Using Markov Chain Monte Carlo fits, the team rebuilds the deceleration history. The f(R) results align closely with earlier studies and shine late. The comparison maps where each theory earns its keep.

Catalog record

CREATORMuhammad Yarahmadi 1 . Amin Salehi 1 . Hadis Mousavi 1
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE79 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-06614

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Comparative Analysis of Perturbed f ⁡ ( R ) f(R) Gravity and Perturbed Rastall Gravity Models in Describing Cosmic Evolution from Early to Late Universe Relative to the Λ \Lambda CDM Model Muhammad Yarahmadi 1 . Amin Salehi 1 . Hadis Mousavi 1 Abstract This study conducts a meticulous examination of the cosmological implications inherent in Rastall gravity and f ⁡ ( R ) f(R) gravity models, assessing their efficacy across distinct cosmic epochs, from early universe structure formation to late-time acceleration. In the initial stages, both models exhibit commendable compatibility with observed features of structure formation, aligning with the established Λ \Lambda CDM model. The derived Jeans’ wavenumbers for each model support their viability. However, as the cosmic timeline progresses into the late universe, a discernible disparity surfaces. Utilizing the Markov Chain Monte Carlo method, we reconstruct the deceleration parameter ( q ) (q) and identify Deceleration - Acceleration redshift transition values. For f ⁡ ( R ) f(R) gravity, our results align closely with previous studies, emphasizing its superior ability to elucidate the recent cosmic acceleration. In contrast, Rastall gravity exhibits distinct redshift transition values. Our rigorous analysis underscores the prowess of f ⁡ ( R ) f(R) gravity in capturing the observed cosmic acceleration, positioning it as a compelling alternative to the conventional Λ \Lambda CDM model. The discernible shifts observed in the peaks of the CMB power spectrum and evolution of deceleration parameter (q) for both f ⁡ ( R ) f(R) gravity and Rastall gravity models in the Early and Late universe, in relation to the Λ \Lambda CDM model, provide compelling evidence supporting the proposition that these alternative gravity models can account for the anisotropy of the universe without invoking the need for dark energy. pacs 98.80.-k, 04.50.Kd, 04.25.Nx I Introduction Dark energy, a fundamental yet enigmatic component of the universe, constitutes approximately 68% of the total energy density and is the driving force behind the observed accelerated expansion of the cosmos riess1998observational ; perlmutter1999measurements . Discovered through the analysis of distant Type Ia supernovae in the late 1990s, dark energy presents a profound challenge to our understanding of fundamental physics weinberg1989cosmological . The most widely accepted model for dark energy is the cosmological constant ( \Lambda ), representing a constant energy density inherent to the vacuum of space carroll2001cosmological . However, this model, while successful in explaining current observations, raises significant theoretical concerns, particularly the fine-tuning and coincidence problems weinberg2000cosmology . Alternative models, such as quintessence, suggest a dynamic scalar field that evolves over time, while modified gravity theories propose alterations to general relativity on large scales copeland2006dynamics . Despite extensive observational efforts, the true nature of dark energy remains elusive, with key questions about its origin, properties, and implications for the ultimate fate of the universe still unanswered frieman2008dark . Understanding dark energy is not only crucial for resolving the Hubble tension and other cosmological puzzles but also for gaining deeper insights into the fundamental laws governing the universe. As such, dark energy continues to be a focal point of both theoretical investigations and observational missions, with the potential to revolutionize our comprehension of cosmology and fundamental physics linder2008cosmic . The \Lambda CDM (Lambda-Cold Dark Matter) model represents a conventional framework in Big Bang cosmology, where the predominant driving force is gravitational interaction. \Lambda CDM, which stands for Lambda Cold Dark Matter, is a widely recognized abbreviation in the fields of cosmology and astrophysics. This model postulates the existence of a cosmological constant, \Lambda , along with an additional energy component known as dark energy (DE) Hinshaw . The nature and origin of DE have posed significant challenges within cosmology, remaining one of the most profound enigmas in the field Komatsu . While the \Lambda CDM model has achieved considerable success in explaining a wide range of observational data, it is not without its inherent challenges Tsujikawa . One approach to addressing these challenges involves modifying the underlying gravity theory or altering the energy-momentum framework. Various modified gravity theories have been proposed as alternatives to the \Lambda CDM paradigm Chagoya . These theories provide alternative explanations for the late-time acceleration of the universe, offering different perspectives on cosmological phenomena Oliveros . Modified gravity theories encompass a diverse range of models, including scalar-vector-tensor theories, Einstein-aether, scalar-tensor theories, Rastall gravity, TeVeS, Bimetric theories, general higher-order theories, f(R) gravity, Horava-Lifschitz gravity, Ghost Condensates, Galileons, and models involving extra dimensions such as Kaluza-Klein, Randall-Sundrum, DGP models, and etc Abbas ; Ali ; AroraDN ; AroraDM ; Javed ; Molla ; Mustafa1 ; Mustafa2 ; Mustafa3 ; Mustafa4 ; Rehman ; yasir among others. Among these theories, some alter the geometric structure, while others modify the constituents of matter Oliveros Nojiri Clifton Nojiri2017 . In this article, the principles of Rastall gravity and f(R) gravity are employed. The motivation for studying Rastall and f(R) gravities stems from the need to address several unresolved issues in cosmology and gravitational physics. In particular, both theories are pursued as potential solutions to the dark energy problem and the limitations of General Relativity (GR) in explaining the accelerated expansion of the universe. These modified gravity theories are also motivated by their ability to provide alternative explanations for the Hubble tension and other cosmological anomalies, such as the behavior of large-scale structures and galaxy dynamics. Furthermore, they offer a framework for exploring possible extensions to GR that might arise from quantum gravity effects or other fundamental theories, allowing for higher-order curvature corrections or modified conservation laws. The pursuit of these theories is driven by the broader goal of finding a more complete and accurate description of the universe, one that can address both current observational data and theoretical challenges. Rastall gravity primarily modifies the interaction between matter and geometry by relaxing conservation laws, while f(R) gravity directly alters the geometry of spacetime through modifications to the curvature Chagoya . Compared to the \Lambda CDM model, f(R) gravity possesses an additional scalar degree of freedom, providing more flexibility in describing the background evolution of the universe De Felice . The f(R) gravity theory extends Einstein’s general theory of relativity by replacing the scalar Lagrangian R with a function f(R) of the scalar curvature Ferraro . General Relativity (GR) has successfully described a variety of gravitational phenomena and is widely accepted as a fundamental theory for describing the geometric properties of space-time De Felice . However, f(R) gravity offers a natural extension of the standard Einstein-Hilbert action by incorporating a function of the Ricci scalar, thereby providing a broader framework for understanding cosmic acceleration. Myrzakulov (2011) demonstrated that the acceleration of the universe can be effectively explained by f(R) gravity models Hasmani . The problem of DE can also be addressed within this framework Sharif . Several f(R) models have been proposed to tackle the limitations of GR, including the Hu-Sawicki model, the Starobinsky model, and the Tsujikawa model, also known as exponential gravity Gogoi Linder Cognola Hu Tsujikawa . However, no single f(R) model can fully explain all cosmological and astrophysical phenomena of the present universe. The modifications introduced by different f(R) functions yield unique cosmological and astrophysical properties, particularly in the intermediate curvature regime ( Gogoi ; Yarahmadi3 ). One of the

Read the complete text