FOGGIE X: Characterizing the Small-Scale Structure of the CGM and its Imprint on Observables
Ramona Augustin, Jason Tumlinson, Molly S. Peeples, Brian W. O’Shea, Britton D. Smith, Cassandra Lochhaas, Anna C. Wright, Ayan Acharyya, Jessica K. Werk, Nicolas Lehner, Lauren Corlies, Raymond C. Simons, J. Christopher Howk, John M. O’Meara · 2025
Read FOGGIE X: Characterizing the Small-Scale Structure of the CGM and its Imprint on Observables by Ramona Augustin, Jason Tumlinson, Molly S. Peeples, Brian W. O’Shea, Britton D. Smith, Cassandra Lochhaas, Anna C. Wright, Ayan Acharyya, Jessica K. Werk, Nicolas Lehner, Lauren Corlies, Raymond C. Simons, J. Christopher Howk, John M. O’Meara (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-06551.txt.
Introduction
Ramona Augustin and co-authors (2025) used the FOGGIE simulations to study the clumpy structure of gas around a galaxy. This halo gas, the circumgalactic medium, feeds galaxies and receives their outflows, yet its small-scale texture is poorly known. The team picked out dense clumps in a galaxy simulated at redshift one. They measured each clump's temperature, metal content, and motion. The runs resolve clumps as small as a quarter of a kiloparsec.
Most clumps held about a hundred thousand solar masses of cool gas near ten thousand degrees. The gas leaned slightly toward inflow. Many clumps varied inside, so key ions used by observers would appear at mixed levels. Clump gas held fewer metals than the smoother gas nearby, which can bias metal estimates from observations. Wider clumps tended to survive. The authors compare them with the fast clouds seen around the Milky Way.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ramona Augustin, Jason Tumlinson, Molly S. Peeples, Brian W. O’Shea, Britton D. Smith, Cassandra Lochhaas, Anna C. Wright, Ayan Acharyya, Jessica K. Werk, Nicolas Lehner, Lauren Corlies, Raymond C. Simons, J. Christopher Howk, John M. O’Meara |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 92 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-06551
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
FOGGIE X: Characterizing the Small-Scale Structure of the CGM and its Imprint on Observables Ramona Augustin, Jason Tumlinson, Molly S. Peeples, Brian W. O’Shea, Britton D. Smith, Cassandra Lochhaas, Anna C. Wright, Ayan Acharyya, Jessica K. Werk, Nicolas Lehner, Lauren Corlies, Raymond C. Simons, J. Christopher Howk, John M. O’Meara Abstract One of the main unknowns in galaxy evolution is how gas flows into and out of galaxies in the circumgalactic medium (CGM). Studies observing the CGM in absorption using multiple or extended background objects suggest a high degree of variation on relatively small ( ≲ 1 \lesssim 1 kpc) spatial scales. Similarly, high-resolution simulations generally exhibit small-scale substructure in the gas around galaxies. We examine the small-scale structure of the z = 1 z=1 CGM using simulations from the FOGGIE (Figuring Out Gas & Galaxies in Enzo) project. We select gaseous substructures (“clumps”) by their local overdensity and investigate their physical properties, including temperature, metallicity, and kinematics with respect to the galaxy and the nearby surroundings. FOGGIE resolves clumps down to sphericalized radii R ∼ 0.25 R\sim 0.25 kpc at z = 1 z=1 . The distribution of clumps peaks at ∼ 10 5 \sim 10^{5} M ⊙ {\rm M}_{\odot} and 10 4 10^{4} K, consistent with relatively condensed, cool gas with a slight preference for inflow-like velocities. Many clumps show internal temperature and density variations, and thus internally varying ionization levels for key diagnostic ions such as H I, Mg II, and O VI. The average metallicity in clumps is about a factor 1.5–2 × \times lower in metallicity than nearby gas, suggesting that the metals are not well-mixed between structured and diffuse CGM, which may have implications for observational metallicity estimations of dense CGM clouds. We estimate the survivability of CGM clumps and find that structures larger than 0.5 kpc are generally long-lived. Finally, we qualitatively compare the simulated cloud properties to Milky Way high-velocity clouds. Journal: ApJ I Introduction The gas surrounding galaxies (the circumgalactic medium, or CGM) acts as a mediator of galactic star formation, feedback, and recycling [ 97 ] . The emergent “baryon cycle” helps to set galactic masses and star formation rates and may play a role in galaxy quenching. The available observational information about the CGM rests primarily on absorption-line studies from the classical quasar absorber technique or, more recently, on resolved absorption or emission from integral-field spectrographs (IFS). Both techniques are biased. Absorption studies generally convey no spatial information about the absorbing gas structures, which are seen in projection and only along a narrow “pencil beam” sightline, while emission-line techniques preferentially see the denser gas (emissivity scales as density-squared). Both the single-sightline absorption observations (due to limited sampling of the halo) and the emission observations (due to typically poor spatial resolution and bias on the highest density regions) provide little to no information on the spatial variation of physical properties such as density, temperature and metallicity on small scales ( \lesssim 10 kpc). Therefore, physical inferences about the mass, metal content, or dynamics of the CGM make assumptions about cloud sizes and density of the gas to determine average CGM properties (e.g., 107 , 112 , 77 ). We are motivated to investigate the small-scale structure of the CGM from four different lines of observational evidence, both direct and indirect. The first line of evidence is that absorption lines vary in strength from halo to halo. Even though single absorption sightlines do not individually probe the small scale structure of the CGM, surveys using one sightline per galaxy for a sample of galaxies find strong indirect evidence for an inhomogeneous CGM with a wide range of density, temperature, and ionization state. Absorption lines from H I [ 99 ] , Mg II [ 70 , 113 ] , and C IV [ 14 ] vary across orders of magnitude in samples of \sim 10 or more galaxies, indicating that the typical CGM has a similar degree of internal variation. The high ion O VI varies less from halo to halo [ 98 ] , which has been interpreted as evidence that the higher ionization gas occupies a more volume-filling medium with fewer clumps [ 108 ] . From these patterns we can infer that the CGM is structured in density and temperature on \lesssim 10 kpc scales, probably with smaller structures in cooler, lower-ionization gas. Another line of complementary evidence for small-scale structure from single-sightlines is large metallicity variations (from a factors of a few to >100\times difference) observed in absorbers that are separated by \delta v<500 km s -1 [ 58 , 60 ] . Figure 1: Gas density projection maps of the six FOGGIE halos at z=1 . These density projections clearly show clumpy structures throughout the gas halos, concentrated within the inner 40 kpc of the CGM. A second factor motivating small-scale investigations of the CGM comes from spatially-resolved absorption and emission studies. Observations of absorbers toward lensed quasars have long been used to directly constrain the sizes of absorbers [ 82 ] , as multiply-lensed QSOs can provide sightlines within 1 kpc of each other. Additionally, studies using lensed and unlensed quasars have detected significant amounts of cool gas around massive elliptical quenched galaxies [ 96 , 113 , 24 ] that appears more patchy than around star-forming galaxies, suggesting differences in the small scale structure of the CGM. Integral field units (IFUs) have enabled 2-D maps of absorbers seen against extended [ 73 , e.g.,] or lensed galaxies [ 64 , 15 , e.g.] . Size constraints also come from hit rates and absorption variation in the separate sight-lines [ 57 , 84 , 10 , e.g.,] . These studies indicate that there is significant variation in the absorption strength over the angular extent of the background source, which can span kpc to tens of kpc scales. This variation within single systems indicates that there is an underlying variation in spatial structure of the gas in terms of density, ionization, and/or metallicity that is not subject to the ambiguity of aggregating multiple sightlines. Mapping emission from circumgalactic gas has only recently become feasible, again through the use of IFUs [ 110 , 5 , 41 ] . However, such observations remain challenging and are mostly achievable only for the brightest emission line, Ly \alpha , and in some cases for bright metal lines [ 22 , 27 , 56 , 71 ] . Because these observations are typically close to instrumental limits in surface brightness they typically do not provide constraints on the morphology of the gas clouds in the CGM, particularly in the resonant lines like Ly \alpha , and generally not at spatial scales down to \sim 1 kpc. For a few bright or large extended sources, full 2-D maps are possible and show clear substructure at the \lesssim 10 kpc scales [ 85 ] . A third major indication of a highly structured CGM comes from the few cases of nearby galaxies for which we have multiple sightlines through the CGM [ 50 , 17 , e.g.,] . The halo of the Milky Way’s near neighbor, M31, subtends a larger angle on the sky than any other galaxy of similar mass, providing