No-go Theorem for Cosmological Parity Violation
Ayngaran Thavanesan · 2025
Read No-go Theorem for Cosmological Parity Violation by Ayngaran Thavanesan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-06383.txt.
Introduction
Ayngaran Thavanesan proves a no-go theorem about parity violation in cosmology, in a 2025 paper. Parity violation would mean the universe treats left and right differently at the largest scales. Some early-universe models predict such a twist, and sky surveys hunt for its fingerprint in galaxy patterns.
Working in even-dimensional spacetimes with stated symmetries, Thavanesan shows that wave-function coefficients must stay real under broad conditions. The conditions cover any local, unitary theory that is finite at both energy extremes and starts from the standard symmetric state. With real coefficients, parity-odd signals built from massless fields vanish at every order of calculation. The theorem closes a door: such signals, if ever seen, would force deeper new physics.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ayngaran Thavanesan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 87 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-06383
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
No-go Theorem for Cosmological Parity Violation Ayngaran Thavanesan Abstract A no-go theorem for parity-violation in even D D -dimensional spacetimes invariant under I S O ( d ) ISO(d) and dilatations (as well as the implications for odd D D ) is derived. For the case of real massless scalar and gravitons (as well as any massless even integer spin- s s field) at ℐ + \mathcal{I}^{+} , the reality of wavefunction coefficients in Fourier space to all orders in perturbation theory (any order in loops) coming from a scale-invariant, IR- and UV-finite theory, which start from the initial 𝐂𝐑𝐓 \bf{CRT} -invariant Bunch-Davies state in the infinite past, is proven. From this, it is inferred that a parity-odd correlator with any massless scalar fields and even integer spin- s s fields vanishes in the presence of any number of interactions of massless fields. The same is true for correlators with an even number of conformally-coupled and massless odd integer spin- s s external fields, which is used to derive the cosmological analogue of Furry’s theorem. The fundamental implications of 𝐂𝐑𝐓 \bf{CRT} symmetry for theories with chemical potentials, such as Chern-Simons and Axion inflation, are also discussed. Given the recent interest in observational claims of parity-violation detection, these results provide clear constraints on parity-violating models of inflation and establish the measurement of any parity-odd correlator as an exceptionally sensitive probe of new physics beyond vanilla inflation. This work is dedicated to the memory of Lt. Colonel Santosham Master (Umainesan Kanpathippillai) and Kuganesan Kanpathippillai. 1 Introduction In theoretical cosmology, we often look towards distant regions of the universe to investigate high-energy physics, searching for signatures of how the universe behaved in its earliest moments. One key aspect is the potential violation of parity (the symmetry between left-handed and right-handed configurations) in the primordial universe. Given that the late universe’s evolution is governed by general relativity which respects parity symmetry, detecting its violation could provide valuable insights into the universe’s initial conditions which are governed by fundamental physics. This paper seeks to probe parity violation by examining various cosmological correlators — quantities that describe statistical relationships between different points in the universe. Correlators involving fields with spin, like gravitational waves (described by tensor fields), can show evidence of parity violation through simple signals like two-point functions. Specifically, different helicities of gravitons can have varying strengths in their corresponding signals. Higher-order correlators, such as the bispectrum (three-point function) and trispectrum (four-point function), are also sensitive to parity violation. However, in the simpler case of scalar fields, parity-violating signals only begin to emerge in four-point correlations due to symmetry restrictions. This paper delves into the correlation functions of primordial scalar and tensor (general integer spin- s ) fields and develops several no-go theorems — results that show under what conditions such parity-violating signals are forbidden. This matches and generalises previous more restricted no-go theorems in the literature [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] obtained from either explicit computations or by using symmetries and the perturbative unitarity constraints of the Cosmological Optical Theorem [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] . The paper also briefly discusses examples where these conditions are relaxed, allowing parity violation to emerge in the scalar trispectrum and higher-order correlation functions, or the graviton correlation functions. The motivation for this work is not purely theoretical: recent experimental results hint at possible signs of parity violation in polarisation data of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] as well as the large-scale structures like galaxies [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] . Though these findings are tentative [ 14 ] , they highlight the importance of understanding how parity violation could manifest in the scalar and tensor sectors of cosmology [ 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 ] . By using insights from the recently derived Cosmological CPT Theorem [ 26 ] , this research clarifies when parity-odd correlators can and cannot arise and thus motivate concrete examples of physical mechanisms that can produce these signals. The main result of this paper is the following No-go Theorem for Cosmological Parity Violation. In even D=d+1 -spacetime dimensions, parity-odd correlators at the \eta=0^{-} boundary of inflation cannot be generated at tree or loop-level by models with: • only massless scalar fields and even-spin fields (e.g. gravitons) satisfying the Bunch-Davies vacuum (can also have even number of massless odd-spin fields, e.g. photons, or conformally coupled fields in external legs); • locally \bf{CRT} -invariant Lagrangians; • IR-finite and UV-finite boundary wavefunction coefficients \psi_{n} . If the last two criteria are met, then a parity-odd correlator B_{n}^{\rm{PO}} at the \eta=0^{-} boundary of inflation can only be sourced by the factorised contribution from internal massive, spinning fields (see [ 3 , 27 ] for a more detailed discussion). This result also has a striking parallel with Furry’s theorem in quantum electrodynamics, which forbids correlators involving an odd number of photons due to charge conjugation symmetry [ 28 ] . In the cosmological setting, a similar result holds: a similar principle applies: if the external legs contain an odd number of odd-spin fields (such as photons), and the theory respects both charge conjugation and \bf{CRT} symmetry, then the corresponding wavefunction coefficients are purely imaginary, implying the vanishing of the parity-even part of the correlator. This constitutes a cosmological analogue of Furry’s theorem in de Sitter space, introducing new structural constraints on the space of allowed observables. At loop-level , the no-go theorem can be circumvented in the UV-divergent case due to the terms proportional to an i\pi correction coming from logarithmic UV-divergences. In dimensional regularisation (dim-reg), the dimension d is analytically continued to non-integer dimensions, and the logarithmic UV-divergence turns into a 1/\delta divergence (for IR-finite 1 -loop diagrams). If one adopts the regularisation scheme of [ 29 ] , where the mass of the field is not renormalised, the phase of the wavefunction coefficients \psi_{n} are real, and thus B_{n}^{\rm{PO}} still vanishes. However, if one uses a regularisation scheme, where the mass of the field is renormalised 1 1 1 In this approach, the mass of the field is also renormalised to keep the order of the Hankel function \nu fixed, which ensures that the integrals can be computed analytically in the dim-reg parameter \delta . The alternative prescription proposed in [ 29 ] does not renormalise the mass of the field, resulting in the order of the Hankel function for the case of massless fields in d=3+\delta -dimensions becoming \nu=d/2=(3+\delta)/2 . However, this prevents the integrals from being computed analytically. Consequently, the authors carry out an expansion in \delta before computing the integrals which introduces non-trivial corrections at various points in the calculation. This makes the overall answer non-analytic in \delta and makes a direct comparison with the phase formula in ( 4.12 ) and ( 4.13 ) nebulous. , the phase of \psi_{n} becomes complex, which when expanded can cancel the 1/\delta divergence, using the simple fact that any generic complex number A can be expressed as A=|A|e^{i\arg(A)} . For IR-finite 1 -loop diagrams we thus find \lim_{\delta\to 0}\left[|\psi^{(L=1)}|e^{i\arg(\psi^{(L=1)})}\right]\sim\frac{1}{\delta}(1\pm i\pi\delta+O(\delta^{2}))=\frac{1}{\delta}\pm