Theory for the Rydberg states of helium: Comparison with experiment for the 1 ​ s ​ 24 ​ p 1 ​ P 1 1s24p\;^{1}P_{1} state ( n = 24 n=24 )

Aaron T. Bondy 1, G. W. F. Drake 1,∗, Cody McLeod 1, Evan M. R. Petrimoulx 1, Xiao-Qiu Qi 2,3, Zhen-Xiang Zhong 4,3 · 2025

Read Theory for the Rydberg states of helium: Comparison with experiment for the 1 ​ s ​ 24 ​ p 1 ​ P 1 1s24p\;^{1}P_{1} state ( n = 24 n=24 ) by Aaron T. Bondy 1, G. W. F. Drake 1,∗, Cody McLeod 1, Evan M. R. Petrimoulx 1, Xiao-Qiu Qi 2,3, Zhen-Xiang Zhong 4,3 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-06096.txt.

Introduction

Aaron Bondy and co-authors compute the energy of a high helium state to extreme precision in a 2025 paper. Helium's Rydberg states, with one electron flung far out, test atomic theory hard because standard methods lose accuracy as the orbit grows. New measurements at orbit number twenty-four sharpened the challenge.

Using a triple basis set in special coordinates, the team reached energies good to twenty-three significant figures with a modest basis. Adding relativity and quantum corrections brought the predicted ionization energy within a hair of the measured value. The state can now anchor other measurements. The work also confirms an eleven-sigma clash between theory and experiment elsewhere in helium's spectrum, a standing puzzle.

Catalog record

CREATORAaron T. Bondy 1, G. W. F. Drake 1,∗, Cody McLeod 1, Evan M. R. Petrimoulx 1, Xiao-Qiu Qi 2,3, Zhen-Xiang Zhong 4,3
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-06096

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Theory for the Rydberg states of helium: Comparison with experiment for the 1 ​ s ​ 24 ​ p 1 ​ P 1 1s24p\;^{1}P_{1} state ( n = 24 n=24 ) Aaron T. Bondy 1, G. W. F. Drake 1,∗, Cody McLeod 1, Evan M. R. Petrimoulx 1, Xiao-Qiu Qi 2,3, Zhen-Xiang Zhong 4,3 Abstract Recent measurements of the ionization energies of the Rydberg P 1 {}^{1}P states of helium for principal quantum number n = 24 n=24 and higher present a new challenge to theoretical atomic physics. A long-standing obstacle to high precision atomic theory for three-body systems is a rapid loss of accuracy for variational calculations with increasing principal quantum number n n . We show that this problem can be overcome with the use of a “triple” basis set in Hylleraas coordinates. Nonrelativistic energies accurate to 23 significant figures are obtained with basis sets of relatively modest size (6744 terms). Relativistic and quantum electrodynamic effects are calculated, including an estimate of terms of order m ​ α 6 m\alpha^{6} from a 1 / n 3 1/n^{3} extrapolation, resulting in an estimated accuracy of ± \pm 1 kHz. The calculated ionization energy of 5704 980.348(1) MHz is in excellent agreement with the experimental value 5704 980.312(95) MHz. These results establish the ionization energy of the 1 ​ s ​ 24 ​ p 1 ​ P 1 1s24p\;^{1}P_{1} state as an absolute point of reference for transitions to lower-lying states, and they confirm an 11 ​ σ 11\sigma disagreement between theory and experiment in the triplet spectrum of helium. Results are also given for the 1 ​ s ​ 24 ​ p 3 ​ P J 1s24p\;^{3}P_{J} states in agreement with a recent experiment on the triplet Rydberg series, thereby confirming a discrepancy of 0.468 ± 0.055 0.468\pm 0.055 MHz for the ionization energy of the 1 ​ s ​ 2 ​ s 3 ​ S 1 1s2s\;^{3}S_{1} state. pacs 31.15.ap, 31.15.ac, 32.10.Dk Recent measurements for the ionization energies of the Rydberg {}^{1}P states of helium for principal quantum number n=24 to 100 Clausen present a new challenge to high-precision atomic theory. Results for the nonrelativistic wave functions and energies are readily obtained for the low-lying sates of helium and other three-body systems by means of variational calculations in Hylleraas coordinates. Relativistic and quantum electrodynamic corrections can then be included by perturbation theory Yan1995 ; Pachucki2012 ; Pachucki2010 ; Zheng2017 ; Kato2018 . A long-standing obstacle to further theoretical progress is that the accuracy typically declines quickly with increasing n . The problem has now become urgent with the publication of the Clausen et al. results Clausen . Their measurements provide absolute point of reference for transitions to lower-lying states where there is an 11\sigma disagreement between theory and experiment Clausen ; Patkos2021 , but there is no corresponding theory for comparison. The rapid decline in accuracy is already evident in the original ground-breaking calculations of Accad, Pekeris and Schiff Accad71 . Their result for the 1s5p\;^{1}P barely exceeds the accuracy of a simple screened hydrogenic approximation -2.02000 E h . Drake et al. Drake87 ; Drake88 ; DrakeMakowski88 ; DrakeYan92 showed that much improved accuracy could be obtained by “doubling” the basis set so that it explicitly contains two variationally determined distance scales for the inner and outer electron. Double basis sets proved adequate to obtain results of useful accuracy (parts in 10^{16} ) for all states of helium up to n=10 and angular momentum L=7 , including relativistic and QED corrections. The only calculations to beyond n=10 are the ICI calculations of Nakashima et al. Nakashima2008 up to n=24 for the nonelativistic energies of S -states. In addition, very high precision calculations have been performed by Aznabaev et al. Aznabaev2018 for the nonrelativistic energies for all states up to n=4 , using stochastic all-exponential basis functions with up to 22000 terms of the form \exp(-\alpha_{i}r_{1}-\beta_{i}r_{2}-\gamma_{i}r_{12}) . If doubling the basis set is good, then perhaps tripling it is even better. Preliminary experiments for the ground states of Ps - , H - and He Nistor2002 showed that one does indeed obtain results of improved accuracy for basis sets of the same total size, but with improved numerical stability. The most accurate results to date for H - have been obtained by Aznabaev et al. Aznabaev2018 . To be specific, the heliumlike Hamiltonian is diagonalized in a basis set constructed from basis functions of the form (for P -states) \displaystyle\phi_{i,j,k}(\alpha,\beta;{\bf r}_{1},{\bf r}_{2}) \displaystyle= \displaystyle r_{1}^{i}\,r_{2}^{j+1}\,r_{12}^{k}\exp(-\alpha r_{1}-\beta r_{2})\cos\theta_{2} (1) \displaystyle\mbox{}\pm\mbox{ exchange} where {\bf r}_{1} and {\bf r}_{2} are the position vectors of electron 1 and electron 2 relative to the nucleus of charge Z , \cos\theta_{2} gives the angular dependence on {\bf r}_{2} appropriate to a p -electron, and r_{12}=|{\bf r}_{1}-{\bf r}_{2}| is the inter-electron separation. The “exchange” term denotes an interchange of the labels 1 and 2, with the (+) sign for triplets and the ( - ) sign for singlets. A variational wave function in a double or triple basis set then has the form \psi({\bf r}_{1},{\bf r}_{2})=\sum_{p=1}^{2{\rm\,or\,}3}\,\,\sum_{i,j,k}^{i+j+k\leq\Omega}c_{i,j,k}^{(p)}\phi_{i,j,k}(\alpha_{p},\beta_{p};{\bf r}_{1},{\bf r}_{2}) (2) where the c_{i,j,k}^{(p)} ar linear variational coefficients, and \Omega controls the size of the basis set such that i+j+k\leq\Omega . The upper limit for the sum over p is 2 for a double basis set and 3 for a triple basis set. The four or six nonlinear variational parameters \alpha_{p} , \beta_{p} are determined by minimizing the energy on a four- or six-dimensional energy surface. This is accomplished by calculating analytically the derivatives \partial E/\partial\alpha_{p} , \partial E/\partial\beta_{p} DrakeMakowski88 and finding their zeros by Newton’s method. The optimization produces a natural separation of the nonlinear parameters into short-range, intermediate, and asymptotic long-range sectors Sati2024 . The basis set also includes the screened hydrogenic term \psi_{1s}({\bf r}_{1};Z)\psi_{24p}({\bf r}_{2};Z-1)\pm exchange for effective nuclear charges Z and Z-1 respectively. The rationale for improved accuracy is that a point of diminishing returns (and numerical instability) is reached with increasing \Omega , and so doubling or tripling the basis set allows more terms to be added without \Omega becoming excessively large. The main purpose of the present work is to extend triple basis set calculations to the high-lying P -states, including relativistic and QED corrections, and compare with the high-precision measurements of Clausen et al. Clausen . The principal computational step to obtain nonrelativistic wave functions and energies is to solve the generalized eigenvalue problem {\bf H}\Psi=\lambda{\bf O}\Psi (3) where H is the Hamiltonian matrix with matrix elements \langle\phi_{i^{\prime},j^{\prime},k^{\prime}}|H|\phi_{i,j,k}\rangle , O is the overlap matrix in the nonorthogonal basis set, and \Psi is the column vector of basis function coefficients c_{i,j,k}^{(p)} . The Hamiltonian in center-of-mass (CM) coordinates is given by (in atomic units with 4\pi\epsilon_{0}=1 ) H=\frac{p_{1}^{2}+p_{2}^{2}}{2\mu}+\frac{{\bf p}_{1}\mbox{\boldmath{$\cdot$}}{\bf p}_{2}}{M}-\frac{Ze^{2}}{r_{1}}-\frac{Ze^{2}}{r_{2}}+\frac{e^{2}}{r_{12}} (4) where M is the nuclear mass, \mu=Mm_{e}/(M+m_{e}) is the reduced electron mass, and the {\bf p}_{1}\mbox{\boldmath{$\cdot$}}{\bf p}_{2}/M term is the mass polarization operator resulting from the motion of the nucleus in the CM frame. The correction due to the finite nuclear mass is obtained by comparison with the infinite nuclear mass case M=\infty . The power method is used to find the eigenvalue closest to an initial guess. The strategy is to perform a sequence of calculations with increasing values

Read the complete text