Simulation and modelling of convective mixing of carbon dioxide in geological formations
Marco De Paoli, Francesco Zonta, Lea Enzenberger, Eliza Coliban, Sergio Pirozzoli · 2025
Read Simulation and modelling of convective mixing of carbon dioxide in geological formations by Marco De Paoli, Francesco Zonta, Lea Enzenberger, Eliza Coliban, Sergio Pirozzoli (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-06090.txt.
Introduction
Marco De Paoli and four colleagues simulate how carbon dioxide mixes convectively in underground porous rock, a process central to geological carbon storage. They run large three-dimensional simulations at Rayleigh-Darcy numbers up to eighty thousand. The setup holds concentration fixed at the top of a semi-infinite domain with no flux at the bottom.
Mixing starts with a diffusion-dominated phase, then solute fingers grow, and finally the process shuts down as fingers reach the bottom. At higher flow strengths a constant-flux regime appears, with dissolution about thirteen percent above two-dimensional estimates. The team also gives a simple physical model for total solute uptake across the whole process.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Marco De Paoli, Francesco Zonta, Lea Enzenberger, Eliza Coliban, Sergio Pirozzoli |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-06090
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Simulation and modelling of convective mixing of carbon dioxide in geological formations Marco De Paoli, Francesco Zonta, Lea Enzenberger, Eliza Coliban, Sergio Pirozzoli Abstract We perform large-scale numerical simulations of convection in 3D porous media at Rayleigh-Darcy numbers up to 𝑅𝑎 = 8 × 10 4 \ra=8\times 10^{4} . To investigate the convective mixing of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) in geological formations, we consider a semi-infinite domain, where the CO 2 concentration is constant at the top and no flux is prescribed at bottom. Convection begins with a diffusion-dominated phase, transitions to convection-driven solute finger growth, and ends with a shutdown stage as fingers reach the bottom boundary and the concentration in the system increases. For 𝑅𝑎 ≥ 5 × 10 3 \ra\geq 5\times 10^{3} , we observe a constant-flux regime with dissolution flux stabilizing at 0.019, approximately 13% higher than in 2D estimates. Finally, we provide a simple and yet accurate physical model describing the mass of solute entering the system throughout the whole mixing process. These findings extend solutal convection insights to 3D and high- 𝑅𝑎 \ra , improving the reliability of tools predicting the long-term CO 2 dynamics in the subsurface. † † journal: Geophysical Research Letters † † corresponding: Marco De Paoli, [email protected] , [email protected] keypoints Convective mixing of carbon dioxide in geological formations follows different regimes During a regime in which the flux is constant, mixing in 3D simulations is 13% larger than in 2D simulations, well below previous estimates A simple model can be employed to accurately reproduce the flow evolution for all the regimes and all the Rayleigh-Darcy numbers \justifying Plain Language Summary The geological sequestration of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) consists of injecting large amounts of CO 2 into underground formations with the aim of permanent storage. This process is key in reducing greenhouse gas emissions in the atmosphere and in supporting energy transition. After injection, CO 2 combines with the resident fluid (brine) and remains stably trapped in the formation, preventing leakage to the atmosphere. The mixing process of CO 2 and brine can take place over hundreds or thousands of years and originates flows driven by density that, in turn, influence mixing. Predicting the evolution of this process is crucial in the design of injection strategies. Field and laboratory measurements are challenging due to the inaccessibility of underground sites and the time scale of the flow processes. Here we employ massive numerical simulations to predict the underground CO 2 dynamics, which depends on the fluid properties, on the rock properties and on the morphology of the formation. We systematically investigate the flow dynamics in three-dimensional systems, and provide a robust quantification of the differences occurring with respect to ideal two-dimensional systems. Finally, we derive a simple, reliable and accurate physical model to predict, design and control the post-injection dynamics of CO 2 . 1 Introduction Natural convection occurs when a flow is driven by density differences that exist within a fluid domain subject to gravity. Convective flows occurring within a porous medium and characterized by density variations induced by heat or solute, are particularly relevant to geophysical processes. The formation of sea ice, for instance, is controlled by a convective flow Worster ((2019)) , driven by salt- and temperature-induced density variations, and it occurs within a newly formed and porous icy matrix, defined mushy layer Feltham ((2006)) ; Worster ((2019)) ; Wells et al. ((2019)) . In dry salt lakes, subsurface convective processes are responsible for the vertical transport of salt, a fundamental mechanism in arid regions, leaving superficial polygonally-shaped crusts as signature Lasser et al. ((2021)) ; Lasser et al. ((2023)) . Recently, the problem of convection in porous media has become pivotal to address the challenge of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) sequestration Huppert & Neufeld ((2014)) , a key process required to contribute to the energy transition. With the aim of permanent storage, supercritical CO 2 is injected in underground geological formations (e.g., saline aquifers), which may be idealized as porous regions filled with brine and confined by two low-permeability layers, acting as hydrodynamics barriers to the flow Neufeld et al. ((2010)) ; De Paoli ((2021)) . In these conditions, supercritical CO 2 is lighter than the resident fluid and after injection accumulates underneath the upper confining layer Emami-Meybodi et al. ((2015)) . This situation is potentially critical, as a fracture of this natural barrier may allow CO 2 to escape to the upper geological layers and eventually to the atmosphere. However, CO 2 is partially miscible with brine, and the resulting mixture (CO 2 +brine) is heavier than both starting fluids. The process of accumulation of this heavy mixture at the boundary between the fluid layers is key, as it promotes the formation of flow instabilities (called plumes or fingers) that, due to convection, increase the mixing rate of CO 2 in brine Ennis-King et al. ((2005)) ; Xu et al. ((2006)) and reduce the risk of leakage. Therefore, predicting the mixing rate as a function of fluid properties, rock properties and formation morphology is the key to accurately address the process of geological carbon sequestration H. Ulloa & Letelier ((2022)) ; Letelier et al. ((2023)) . The dynamics of the CO 2 -brine mixing process is characterized by three main phases Slim et al. ((2013)) ; Slim ((2014)) : i) initially, solute transport is limited to the fluid-fluid interface, and it is controlled by diffusion; ii) then, when the dense, CO 2 -rich fluid layer becomes sufficiently thick, it becomes unstable and promotes the formation of small fingers; iii) these fingers grow vertically and eventually merge with neighboring plumes generating larger and persistent structures in a statistically-steady fashion; iv) finally, when the domain is saturated with the CO 2 -rich fluid carried downward by the megaplumes, the mixing of CO 2 slows progressively down Hewitt et al. ((2013)) . The single dimensionless governing parameter is the Rayleigh-Darcy number \ra , which expresses the ratio of the strength of driving (buoyancy) to dissipative (viscosity and molecular diffusion) mechanisms. It contains the fluids, medium and formation properties, and it may span over few decades, namely from O(10) Emami-Meybodi ((2017)) to O(10^{5}) Hu et al. ((2023)) . Despite the highly non-linear and transient character described, this system has been accurately characterized numerically in two dimensions Emami-Meybodi et al. ((2015)) ; Hewitt ((2020)) ; De Paoli ((2023)) . The three-dimensional problem, in contrast, is still partially unexplored, due to the huge computational cost required to accurately resolve the flow at large \ra . With the exception of few works at moderate \ra Liyanage et al. ((2024)) ; Imuetinyan et al. ((2024)) ; Sin et al. ((2024)) ; Imuetinyan et al. ((2024)) , the opacity of the media represents an intrinsic limitation for the laboratory experiments, preventing from obtaining simultaneous measurements of flow and solute. In this work, we aim precisely at this gap. We perform high-resolution, large-scale simulations of solute convection in two- and three-dimensional porous media at unprecedented Rayleigh-Darcy numbers, namely up to \ra=8\times 10^{4} . Using this unique database, which we make available De Paoli, Zonta et al. ((2025)) , we provide a detailed characterization of the flow dynamics. We analyze the flow in terms