Constraining constructions with WordNet: pros and cons for the semantic annotation of fillers in the Italian Constructicon

Flavio Pisciotta, Ludovica Pannitto, Lucia Busso, Beatrice Bernasconi, Francesca Masini · 2025

Read Constraining constructions with WordNet: pros and cons for the semantic annotation of fillers in the Italian Constructicon by Flavio Pisciotta, Ludovica Pannitto, Lucia Busso, Beatrice Bernasconi, Francesca Masini (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-05990.txt.

Introduction

Flavio Pisciotta and co-authors discuss using a word network to guide meaning labels inside an Italian grammar construction database, in a paper from 2025. Constructions are stored patterns of form and meaning, and their open slots need semantic limits. The project borrows topic labels from a multilingual word network to state those limits. The authors weigh what the borrowing gains and what it costs for the annotation work.

Catalog record

CREATORFlavio Pisciotta, Ludovica Pannitto, Lucia Busso, Beatrice Bernasconi, Francesca Masini
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE23 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-05990

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Constraining constructions with WordNet: pros and cons for the semantic annotation of fillers in the Italian Constructicon Flavio Pisciotta, Ludovica Pannitto, Lucia Busso, Beatrice Bernasconi, Francesca Masini Abstract The paper discusses the role of WordNet-based semantic classification in the formalization of constructions, and more specifically in the semantic annotation of schematic fillers, in the Italian Constructicon. We outline how the Italian Constructicon project uses Open Multilingual WordNet topics to represent semantic features and constraints of constructions. 1 Introduction ⬇ # cxn - id = 171 # cxn = fare Npsych # function = cause to feel ref : B ID UD . FORM LEMMA UPOS FEATS HEAD DEPREL A _ fare VERB _ 0 root B _ _ NOUN Number = Sing A obj REQUIRED WITHOUT SEM . FEATS ADJACENCY IDENTITY 1 _ _ _ _ 1 CHILDREN : DEPREL = det OntoClass = feeling _ _ Listing 0: Example of CoNLL-C annotation for the light verb cxn fare N feeling ‘make feel N feeling ’ (lit. do N feeling ) Pisciotta and Masini forthcoming . Since this construction only occurs with a psychological noun in the singular form, the features of the noun are specified with "number=sing", and the semantic layer uses the topic of "feeling" to constraint the nouns that can occurr in the second slot of the construction. In Construction Grammar (CxG, Hoffmann and Trousdale 2013 , Hoffmann and Trousdale 2013 ), the basic units of linguistic description are constructions (cxns), which are conventionalized pairings of form and function Goldberg 1995 ; Goldberg 2006 . Crucially, cxns can vary in complexity and schematicity, including not only words, but also more complex and/or abstract units such as predicative structures, idioms, and word formation processes. CxG, as other usage-based approaches, assume that cxns are not stored as a mere list, but as a structured network (the Construct-i-con ) in which cxns are linked by different kinds of relationships ( Diessel 2019 ; Diessel 2023 ) . Despite traditional research in CxG not focusing much on language as a system, recent years have seen a growing interest in Constructicography , a blend of “Practical Lexicography” and CxG ( Boas et al. 2019 ) . That is, the notion of “Constructicon” has acquired an additional meaning. Beside relating to the structured inventory of all constructions in a language, it has come to indicate a linguistic resource that aims at representing and formalising the network of constructions in a given language Lyngfelt et al. 2018b . Constructicography, therefore, is the research field that aims to build Constructicons, that is, to develop repositories of cxns that consistently and coherently describe the grammar (and thus the constructional network) of a specific language. Constructicons already exist for a number of languages (e.g., Janda et al. 2018 ; Lyngfelt et al. 2018a ; Torrent et al. 2018 ), and are often linked to the FrameNet enterprise ( Baker et al. 1998 ) . In fact, Frame Semantics is considered a “sister” framework to CxG - as both theories stem from Fillmore’s work on semantic roles Fillmore 1968 - and is typically used to represent semantic aspects of constructions Borin and Lyngfelt forthcoming . Despite Constructicography being a fast-growing research area in many languages, Italian has so far been at the periphery of it. Not only there is no Constructicon, but there is also no published Italian FrameNet, although there have been several attempts at developing such a resource Tonelli et al. 2009 ; Lenci et al. 2010 ; Basili et al. 2017 . The present contribution introduces the Italian Constructicon (ItCon) project ( Masini et al. 2024 ) . This project aims to bridge this gap by building an open and collaborative resource that is designed to be interoperable with existing resources for Italian (treebanks, lexical databases, corpora). Crucially, we outline how we use WordNet-based semantic classification to represent the semantic layer of Italian constructions. As it stands, the resource is still in its infancy. Therefore, the primary goal so far is to develop a solid theoretical and operational background for the project. In this contribution, we focus specifically on how to constrain the generative power of cxns with respect to the semantic productivity of the open slots of semi-specified cxns ( Suttle and Goldberg 2011 ; Perek 2016 ) , and how this problem can be addressed operationally through the integration of data from WordNet(s) available for Italian ( Roventini et al. 2000 ; Pianta et al. 2002 ) in our annotation format. We will proceed by briefly describing the architecture of ItCon and the annotation format of constructional entries (Section 2 ), and then we discuss how our annotation scheme can benefit from the connection with WordNet, as well as the possible limitations of such proposals (Sections 3 and 4 ). 2 Architecture of the Italian Constructicon ItCon consists of three linked structures: • a database of cxns ; • the graph of cxns , where each node represents a cxn in terms of the set of constraints that it expresses and edges represent horizontal and vertical links holding between cxns; • a body of annotated examples in CoNLL-U format Nivre et al. 2016 , incrementally built by annotating instances of a specific cxn (i.e., constructs) in texts by means of a specific feature in the MISC field. In the database of cxns , each entry describes a cxn through a number of text fields and tags. They serve the purpose of specifying information about the properties and behavior of the constructs, as well as linking the database entry to a node in the graph of cxns and to a subset of the annotated examples . Each node in the graph of cxns consists of a columnar formalization customized for cxns representation, based on CoNLL-X format Buchholz and Marsi 2006 and therefore named CoNLL-C ( Masini et al. 2024 ) , that can be converted into a Grew query ( Guillaume 2021 ) in order to match occurrences of the cxn in CoNLL-U annotated corpora, i.e., Universal Dependencies (UD, Nivre et al. 2016 ) treebanks . The generative power of the cxn gets constrained at this level, as it is necessary to narrow down the possible set of matched occurrences. This is done through a set of fields specifying formal and functional constraints, which we briefly describe. 2.1 The CoNLL-C format The CoNLL-C format is a UD compatible format 1 1 1 For a comprehensive description of the format and the relevant fields, see Pannitto et al. 2024 . . As shown in Listing 1 2 2 2 The columnar format was split in two lines for space reasons. , each formalized cxn is described by a set of metadata (i.e., the lines prefixed by \# ) that specify holistic properties of the cxn (such as its semantic function ), and by a number of fields, containing a token-by-token description of the cxn components . The first 7 fields ( ID , UD.FORM , LEMMA , UPOS , FEATS , HEAD , DEPREL ) can be mapped on the matching fields in CoNLL-U format. Since one of the aims of such formalization is to match the relevant constructs in UD-annotated corpora, some other fields

Read the complete text