Self-consistent full MHD coupling of JOREK and STARWALL for advanced plasma free boundary simulation On the electromagnetic interaction of a Full MHD plasma with a 3D wall model
R. Sparago, F.J. Artola, M. Hoelzl · 2025
Read Self-consistent full MHD coupling of JOREK and STARWALL for advanced plasma free boundary simulation On the electromagnetic interaction of a Full MHD plasma with a 3D wall model by R. Sparago, F.J. Artola, M. Hoelzl (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-05956.txt.
Introduction
The authors report a new coupling between two simulation codes used to model plasma in fusion devices. JOREK simulates the plasma itself, and STARWALL models the conducting walls around it. How plasma interacts with those walls shapes its three-dimensional behavior. Getting the interaction right matters for predicting disruptions and the forces they exert on the vessel. Earlier couplings joined the wall codes to a reduced plasma model.
This work couples the wall code to JOREK's full magnetohydrodynamic model instead. The scheme describes the full three-dimensional interaction between plasma, vacuum region, and external conductors. It links the magnetic vector potential to the magnetic field through natural boundary conditions. The authors validate the scheme with benchmarks: sideways displacement events in symmetric setups and multi-harmonic runs of plasma modes. The results support the coupling as a consistent step toward advanced free-boundary simulation.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | R. Sparago, F.J. Artola, M. Hoelzl |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-05956
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Self-consistent full MHD coupling of JOREK and STARWALL for advanced plasma free boundary simulation On the electromagnetic interaction of a Full MHD plasma with a 3D wall model R. Sparago, F.J. Artola, M. Hoelzl Abstract ABSTRACT An adequate modelling of the electromagnetic interaction of the plasma with the surrounding conductors is paramount for the correct reproduction of 3D plasma dynamics. Simulations of the latter provide in turn useful predictions regarding the plasma evolution, the related MHD modes leading to disruptions and the electromagnetic forces acting on the vacuum vessel’s components when said disruptions occur. The latest modelling efforts with the 3D FEM non-linear JOREK code have been directed towards the eddy current coupling of a reduced magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) plasma model with thin and volumetric wall codes (STARWALL and CARIDDI). In this contribution, we present an eddy current coupling between the full MHD model of JOREK and the STARWALL code; this new coupling scheme describes the full three-dimensional interactions of the plasma with the vacuum region and external conductors, modeled by natural boundary conditions linking the magnetic vector potential 𝐀 \mathbf{A} to the magnetic field 𝐁 \mathbf{B} . The consistency of the new coupling scheme is validated via benchmarks for axisymmetric Vertical Displacement Events and multi-harmonics simulations of MHD modes. I An introduction to free boundary plasma scenarios It is widely known that an accurate study of the macroscopic dynamics of a tokamak plasma requires that its interaction with the surrounding electromagnetic (EM) environment be taken into account. This serves the purpose of "informing" the physical model in use about two main phenomena: 1. The plasma is immersed in a vacuum , i.e. a domain with a certain magnetic permeability \mu_{0} and electric permittivity \epsilon_{0} , and a zero electric conductivity \sigma_{0} ; 2. The presence of the tokamak’s conducting structures (vacuum vessel, first wall, in-vessel components) that surround the plasma determines a wide range of mutual three-dimensional EM interactions between currents in the plasma and the conductors. The above-mentioned points enrich the model by introducing a free boundary scenario, where the magnetic field at the plasma edge is not anymore fixed in space and time, but rather, it is shaped by the interaction with the external electromagnetic environment. This more comprehensive modelling setting renders itself fundamental for a more accurate reproduction of the macroscopic plasma dynamics and the forces arising on the tokamak structures during a plasma discharge. Such information is crucial when dealing with disruptions , that is, violent events caused by the excessive growth of plasma instabilities, which in turn lead to a rapid loss of the thermal and magnetic energy stored within the plasma. Disruptions are often associated with motion, variation in the current and temperature profiles and changes in the magnetic topology of the plasma; said occurrences determine the induction of eddy currents in the surrounding conductive structures and the exchange of current between the plasma and the wall structures; these currents generate a reaction magnetic field that ends up affecting the plasma evolution itself. Aside from this feedback effect, the wall current density field \mathbf{J_{w}} associated with a plasma perturbation will interact with the magnetic field \mathbf{B} , thus generating an electromechanical force distribution \mathbf{F_{w}} on the machine’s structures. Forces that are brought about by certain magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) modes can be detrimental for future reactors’ components; furthermore, because of the frequency of some of these modes, the resulting forces can be rotating and therefore constitute a threat for the integrity of conducting structures due to resonant excitation [ 1 ]. Code suit Plasma model Conductive structures model CarMa0NL [ 2 ] 2D evolutionary equilibrium 3D volumetric NIMROD [ 3 ] 3D full MHD 2D* thin M3D [ 4 ] 3D full MHD 2D* thin M3D-C 1 [ 5 ] 3D full MHD 2D* volumetric JOREK-STARWALL [ 6 ] [ 7 ] [ 8 ] 3D reduced / full MHD 2D* thin JOREK-CARIDDI [ 9 ] 3D reduced / full MHD 3D volumetric Table 1 : Overview of presently available simulation tools for the reproduction of free boundary MHD modes. *The 2D notation stands for axisymmetry of the conducting structures, but non-axisymmetric wall currents are allowed by the 3D plasma codes nonetheless. Furthermore, simple 3D wall representations are also possible in STARWALL. Because of the above, tokamak loads ensuing disruptions represent a major concern for the machine’s mechanical structure, which needs to be designed appropriately leveraging the predictive capability of simulation codes. To this end, a variety of coupled MHD plasma \leftrightarrow EM wall codes has been developed in the past 30 years, each characterized by different degrees of simplifying assumptions concerning both the plasma and the conducting structures’ representation. An overview of these codes can be found in Table 1 . The CarMa0NL [ 2 ] code is an example of simplified plasma model coupled with 3D volumetric conductors: here, the plasma is assumed to be massless, thus resulting in instantaneous reactions to external magnetic perturbations; in addition, the MHD equations are solved in the non-linear axisymmetric perturbed equilibrium limit. With different coupling schemes, the 3D full MHD codes NIMROD [ 3 ] and M3D [ 4 ] were instead coupled to an axisymmetric thin model of passive conductors, thus providing a more limited representation of the complex current distributions that can arise in these conductors. This limit was relaxed in M3D-C 1 [ 5 ] with the adoption of an axisymmetric volumetric representation for the conductors, which were included in the standard computational domain; however at the cost of a limited resolution for their representation. The JOREK-STARWALL [ 6 ] and JOREK-CARIDDI [ 9 ] code suits are the only frameworks that are currently featuring a non-linear extended MHD plasma model with a self-consistent representation of 3D conducting structures. As will be shown, the coupling strategy is based on the virtual casing principle, also adopted in CarMa0NL. The only difference between STARWALL and CARIDDI stems from the numerical representation of the electromagnetic degrees of freedom in the conducting structures; in STARWALL, the conductors are limited to be thin, whereas CARIDDI is able to solve the electromagnetic problem under investigation for the most general case, that is, thick and non-axysimmetric conductive structures. This makes JOREK-CARIDDI the only code with a self-consistent coupling of a 3D MHD plasma with 3D volumetric conductors. The latter representation becomes fundamental when the skin depth of the magnetic perturbation is comparable to the wall width, which can occur for certain MHD modes, and when the modelling of the path of shared ( halo ) currents between the plasma and the wall structures is required. At present, coupling schemes with the JOREK [ 7 ] code have been implemented only for eddy currents; a halo current coupling is currently in preparation. Furthermore, for both STARWALL and CARIDDI, the eddy current coupling has been only carried out for the reduced MHD model of JOREK. The present contribution aims to improve the fidelity of the last-mentioned code suits even further by performing the coupling of the full MHD model of JOREK, which opens up the possibility to reproduce plasma free boundary dynamics and wall forces with a greater accuracy than before. In particular, the full MHD coupling of JOREK and STARWALL is presented,