Black hole–disc coevolution in the presence of magnetic fields: refining the Thorne limit with emission from within the plunging region
Andrew Mummery · 2025
Read Black hole–disc coevolution in the presence of magnetic fields: refining the Thorne limit with emission from within the plunging region by Andrew Mummery (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-05843.txt.
Introduction
Andrew Mummery wrote this 2025 astrophysics paper on how fast a black hole can spin. As a disc of matter feeds a black hole, it usually spins the hole up, while captured light pushes back and slows it. The balance sets a top spin, long known as the Thorne limit, near 0.998 in the simplest theory.
Mummery asks how that limit shifts when the infalling gas glows brightly just inside the inner edge of the disc. Simulations show magnetic stresses make that plunging region shine, adding to the braking effect. The extra light lowers the top spin to about 0.99 for typical cases. The shift is small, but it matters for reading the spins astronomers measure.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Andrew Mummery |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-05843
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Black hole–disc coevolution in the presence of magnetic fields: refining the Thorne limit with emission from within the plunging region Andrew Mummery Abstract The accretion of material onto a black hole modifies the properties of that hole owing to the capture of both matter and radiation. Adding matter to the hole through an accretion disc generally acts to increase the hole’s spin parameter, while the capture of radiation generally provides a retarding torque. The balance between the torques provided by adding matter and radiation leads to a maximum spin parameter that can be obtained by a black hole which grows by accretion, known as the Thorne limit. In the simplest theory of thin disc accretion this Thorne limit has the value a ∙ , lim ≃ 0.998 a_{\bullet,{\rm lim}}\simeq 0.998 . The purpose of this paper is to highlight that any modification to theories of accretion flows also modify this limiting value, and to compute precisely the modification arising from a particular extension of accretion theory: the inclusion of bright emission from within the plunging region which is sourced from the magnetohydrodynamic stresses ubiquitously observed in simulations. This extra emission further suppresses black hole spin-up and results in new, lower, limits on the final black hole spin. These limits depend on the details of the magnetic stresses acting within the plunging region, but typical values seen in simulations and observations would lower the limit to a ∙ , lim ≃ 0.99 a_{\bullet,{\rm lim}}\simeq 0.99 , a subtle but not negligible deviation. Black hole–disc coevolution in the presence of magnetic fields: refining the Thorne limit with emission from within the plunging region – A 2024 1 Introduction The addition of material onto a black hole via an accretion flow will, provided a sufficiently large reservoir of material is available, profoundly modify the properties of the black hole itself. This is because the accreted matter carries both energy and angular momentum, the addition of which modifies the mass and spin parameters of the hole. It was first argued by Bardeen (1970) that an initially Schwarzschild black hole would be spun up to an extremal Kerr black hole (with dimensionless spin parameter a_{\bullet}=1 ) once the mass parameter of the hole had changed from M_{\bullet}=M_{i} to M_{\bullet}=\sqrt{6}M_{i} . In other words, roughly doubling the mass of the black hole by accretion also spins it up to maximal rotation. The Bardeen (1970) argument only considers the effects of adding matter to the black hole, which is not the only form of stress energy present in an accreting system. Thorne (1974) refined the analysis of Bardeen (1970) by including the energy and angular momentum carried onto the black hole by the photon field emitted by the accretion flow. Photons carry angular momentum and energy, and therefore their capture also modifies the evolution of the black hole. It is, generally speaking, difficult to capture a photon, even for a black hole. Photons which are counter-rotating with respect to the black hole’s spin axis must “work against” the rotation of the hole, and have a larger capture cross section ( Thorne, 1974 ) . Therefore, photons generally provide a net negative angular momentum flux onto the black hole, spinning it down. Thorne (1974) showed that incorporating the effects of photon capture results in a limiting black hole spin at which the torque from the accreting matter is balanced by the retarding torque of the radiation field, at which point the spin evolution of the black hole stops. This limiting spin has a very well known value a_{\bullet,{\rm lim}}\simeq 0.998 , and is known as the “Thorne limit”. What is perhaps less widely appreciated is that, while the spirit of the calculation is model-independent (photon capture will always act to spin-down the hole owing to the basic properties of their capture cross section), the actual numerical value of the limiting spin is a model dependent statement. Any modification to theoretical descriptions of accretion flows will also modify this limiting value, and therefore this limit should be re-examined as our theories of accretion flows develop from their 1970s forms. One modification discussed in the original Thorne (1974) analysis is the potential implications of magnetic fields acting in the innermost regions of the disc. Indeed, Thorne (1974) notes that magnetic fields could modify the vanishing ISCO (innermost stable circular orbit) stress assumption employed in their analysis, which would result in an increased photon flux being emitted on small scales (photons which are therefore most likely to be captured), increasing the net spin-down effect of the radiation field. We now of course know that magnetic stresses are essential for driving the accretion process ( Balbus & Hawley, 1991 ) , and flux-freezing results in large enough magnetic stresses in the plunging region to keep the accretion flow hot in the innermost regions Krolik (1999) ; Gammie (1999) . This basic result (which cannot be captured by the \alpha -viscosity toy model, which is unphysical in this regime) has been confirmed by numerous General Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations over the years ( Noble et al., 2010 ; Schnittman et al., 2016 ; Wielgus et al., 2022 , e.g.,) . Some of the implications for black hole spin evolution in the presence of a magnetic ISCO stress were first discussed in Agol & Krolik (2000) , although their analysis neglected photons emitted from the plasma on the plunge itself. Indeed, we do not believe any calculation including the captured photon flux emitted from plunging gas has been performed in the literature. It is the purpose of this short paper to revisit the Thorne (1974) limit calculation using extended models for thin accretion flows which now include emission from within the ISCO. We shall show that the additional dissipation at and within the ISCO results in an increased retarding radiation torque, and therefore a slower rate of black hole spin-up and lower equilibrium spin limits. This is an important result, as the study of co-evolving black hole–disc systems have implications for the present day properties of the population of supermassive black holes which reside in galactic centers and, ultimately, of the properties of their galaxies themselves ( Silk & Rees, 1998 ) . Unlike accreting stellar mass black hole systems, which generally do not have a large enough mass budget available to accrete and change the hole’s properties, supermassive black holes are expected to change their natal mass by large factors across cosmic history (by accreting circumnuclear material, and/or undergoing mergers), and therefore will have spin parameters set by the particular history of their cosmic evolution (see e.g., Piotrowska et al., 2024 , for a recent discussion) . A reduction in the rate of black hole spin-up caused by accretion, and lower saturating spin values, therefore must be taken into account when inferring evolution histories from present day spin measurements. As the spin of a black hole sets (to leading order) the radiative efficiency of the accretion process and the power of relativistic jets launched from the disc (if powered by the Blandford & Znajek, 1977 , mechanism) , this black hole spin evolution also influences all of the feedback mechanisms accreting black holes have on galaxy evolution ( Fabian, 2012 ) and, therefore,