More than a void? The detection and characterization of cavities in a simulated galaxy’s interstellar medium
Abolfazl Taghribi, Marco Canducci, Michele Mastropietro, Sven De Rijcke, Reynier Frans Peletier, Peter Tino, Kerstin Bunte · 2025
Read More than a void? The detection and characterization of cavities in a simulated galaxy’s interstellar medium by Abolfazl Taghribi, Marco Canducci, Michele Mastropietro, Sven De Rijcke, Reynier Frans Peletier, Peter Tino, Kerstin Bunte (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-05581.txt.
Introduction
Abolfazl Taghribi and six co-authors published this paper in 2025. It builds an automatic way to find cavities in the gas between stars. Such holes and bubbles are usually read as scars left by exploding stars, and astronomers spot them by eye, which invites bias.
Their method uses the geometry of the gas particles themselves to outline each hole and grip its edge. Tested on a simulated dwarf galaxy, it found 808 holes across twenty-one snapshots spanning one hundred million years. Fewer than forty percent could be firmly tied to exploding stars. About a third of the holes were shrinking, not growing. The authors warn that not every cavity is a supernova relic. Their tool also measures each hole's shape and temperature for later study.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Abolfazl Taghribi, Marco Canducci, Michele Mastropietro, Sven De Rijcke, Reynier Frans Peletier, Peter Tino, Kerstin Bunte |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 56 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-05581
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
More than a void? The detection and characterization of cavities in a simulated galaxy’s interstellar medium Abolfazl Taghribi, Marco Canducci, Michele Mastropietro, Sven De Rijcke, Reynier Frans Peletier, Peter Tino, Kerstin Bunte Abstract The interstellar medium of galaxies is filled with holes, bubbles, and shells, typically interpreted as remnants of stellar evolution. There is growing interest in the study of their properties to investigate stellar and supernova feedback. So far, the detection of cavities in observational and numerical data is mostly done visually and, hence, is prone to biases. Therefore, we present an automated, objective method for discovering cavities in particle simulations, with demonstrations using hydrodynamical simulations of a dwarf galaxy. The suggested technique extracts holes based on the persistent homology of particle positions and identifies tight boundary points around each. With a synthetic ground-truth analysis, we investigate the relationship between data density and the detection radius, demonstrating that higher data density also allows for the robust detection of smaller cavities. By tracking the boundary points, we can measure the shape and physical properties of the cavity, such as its temperature. In this contribution, we detect 808 holes in 21 simulation snapshots. We classified the holes into supernova-blown bubbles and cavities unrelated to stellar feedback activity based on their temperature profile and expansion behaviour during the 100 million years covered by the simulation snapshots analysed for this work. Surprisingly, less than 40% of the detected cavities can unequivocally be linked to stellar evolution. Moreover, about 36% of the cavities are contracting, while 59% are expanding. The rest do not change for a few million years. Clearly, it is erroneous to interpret observational data based on the premise that all cavities are supernova-related and expanding. This study reveals that supernova-driven bubbles typically exhibit smaller diameters, larger expansion velocities, and lower kinetic ages (with a maximum of 220 million years) compared to other cavities. 2025 More than a void? The detection and characterization of cavities in a simulated galaxy’s interstellar medium – 15 1 Introduction It has been appreciated since the late 1960s that the interstellar medium of external galaxies is filled with holes, bubbles, and shells with a wide range of radii and sizes ( Westerlund & Mathewson, 1966 ; Hindman, 1967 ; Hodge, 1967 ) . Such structures have been observed in both optical and radio data. A decade later, radio surveys of the Milky Way revealed similar structures in our own galaxy ( Heiles, 1976 ) . Since then, observations have progressed beyond detections and now include detailed quantitative studies of these bubbles, characterizing their size distributions, spatial distributions, and kinematics ( Oey & Clarke, 1997 ; Bagetakos et al., 2011 ; Nath et al., 2020 ; Pokhrel et al., 2020 ) . For the dwarf galaxies near the Milky Way, exceptionally high spatial resolution data is now available. For instance, ( Kim et al., 2003 ) merged ACTA and Parkes radio observations of the Large Magellanic Cloud and succeeded in measuring the properties of H i cavities on scales from 15 parsecs upwards. Understanding the properties and origin of these bubbles or cavities is an important astrophysical problem because of the possible link between such bubbles and stellar evolution. The idea that stellar winds from massive stars could be responsible for these bubbles was first introduced by Castor et al. (1975) . If this is the case, then these bubbles are intimately linked to the subgrid physics employed in numerical simulations of (dwarf) galaxy formation and evolution ( Schroyen et al., 2011 ) . Thus, bubble properties offer a testbed for the subgrid recipes for stellar and supernova feedback, which regulate the energy injection into the interstellar medium and are expected to affect the H i structure. As such, comparing the properties of the H i cavities in real and simulated dwarf galaxies is expected to help constrain the physics of galaxy evolution. If such a one-to-one relation between newborn stars or star clusters, on the one hand, and H i cavities on the other exists, then one would expect some observational tracer of recent or ongoing star formation to correlate with the H i structure. However, H \alpha and 24-micron emission, which trace ongoing star formation, appear to correlate poorly with H i cavities ( Book et al., 2008 ) . Moreover, detailed observations of the dwarf galaxy Holmberg ii with the Hubble Space Telescope showed that the stars inside a given H i cavity are far from coeval, and their ages do not reflect the kinematical age of the host cavity ( Weisz et al., 2009 ) . Instead, these authors propose a multi-age model, in which stars born over several tens of megayears contribute to inflating an H i cavity. The observed correlation between UV emission, which traces young but not necessarily newborn stars, and H i structure appears to corroborate this idea. Recent JWST observations of nearby galaxies suggest that their intricate gas structures may actually be unrelated to stellar feedback ( Meidt et al., 2023 ) . The cavities visible in the interstellar medium of these galaxies have dimensions comparable with the local turbulent Jeans length. This was interpreted as evidence for three-dimensional fragmentation of the gas disk as the root cause of the observed network of filaments and voids. This fragmentation is expected to be regulated by the balance between turbulent pressure and self-gravity, leading to a correlation between the structures’ sizes and the Jeans scale. Cavities are often identified via a visual inspection of the observed H i column density distribution ( Kim et al., 2003 ) or CO emission maps ( Watkins et al., 2023 ) , possibly extended with a visual inspection of the velocity channel maps, as in Pokhrel et al. (2020) . Sometimes, as in Watkins et al. (2023) , a correlation between the gas structures and the stellar-population properties is required for cavity detection. Observationally, only projected position and line-of-sight velocity information are available, imposing limitations on data interpretation. For instance, an expanding shell, with its front side approaching the observer and its back side receding, looks identical to an imploding shell, with its back side approaching the observer and its front side receding. Interpreting the data based on the assumption that all shells are expanding may lead to false conclusions. This reliance on human judgment introduces a degree of subjectivity and a potential lack of reproducibility in the bubble identification process, and a more automated procedure is clearly desirable. Systematic studies and comparisons of existing void-finding algorithms to detect two- and three-dimensional cosmic voids in the context of the cosmic web and Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) are provided by Colberg et al. (2008) ; Cautun et al. (2018) ; Feldbrugge et al. (2019) . To the best of our knowledge, the community has not yet converged to a clear definition of the spatial boundary of these generic low-density regions, and hence many different ways were proposed to identify them. Strategies include identification based on spherical underdensity, space tessellation, and variations thereof, which will influence the shape of the resulting voids and potential overlap. They generally only partially overlap in the data they use, and some require modalities generally not available in observations. The aforementioned studies