Off-Policy Evaluation and Counterfactual Methods in Dynamic Auction Environments

Ritam Guha 1 and Nilavra Pathak 2 · 2025

Read Off-Policy Evaluation and Counterfactual Methods in Dynamic Auction Environments by Ritam Guha 1 and Nilavra Pathak 2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-05278.txt.

Introduction

Testing a new bidding or allocation policy online is slow and costly, so Ritam Guha and Nilavra Pathak study how to judge policies from data that an older policy already logged. This approach, called off-policy evaluation, uses estimators that reconstruct what would have happened under a different set of choices. The pair focus on dynamic auction settings, where rivals react fast and slow testing can mean losing ground.

The authors examine whether these estimators can predict the outcome of resource allocation strategies well enough to guide which policies deserve a live test. Using them as a screening step could cut the time and cost of experiments and raise confidence in the policies finally chosen. On the strength of their early findings, they sketch an analytics system that would assess new strategies continuously as fresh logged data arrives.

Catalog record

CREATORRitam Guha 1 and Nilavra Pathak 2
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-05278

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Off-Policy Evaluation and Counterfactual Methods in Dynamic Auction Environments Ritam Guha 1 and Nilavra Pathak 2 Abstract Counterfactual estimators are critical for learning and refining policies using logged data, a process known as Off-Policy Evaluation (OPE). OPE allows researchers to assess new policies without costly experiments, speeding up the evaluation process. Online experimental methods, such as A/B tests, are effective but often slow, thus delaying the policy selection and optimization process. In this work, we explore the application of OPE methods in the context of resource allocation in dynamic auction environments. Given the competitive nature of environments where rapid decision-making is crucial for gaining a competitive edge, the ability to quickly and accurately assess algorithmic performance is essential. By utilizing counterfactual estimators as a preliminary step before conducting A/B tests, we aim to streamline the evaluation process, reduce the time and resources required for experimentation, and enhance confidence in the chosen policies. Our investigation focuses on the feasibility and effectiveness of using these estimators to predict the outcomes of potential resource allocation strategies, evaluate their performance, and facilitate more informed decision-making in policy selection. Motivated by the outcomes of our initial study, we envision an advanced analytics system designed to seamlessly and dynamically assess new resource allocation strategies and policies. I Introduction Modern-day marketplaces are increasingly designed as two-sided platforms. In such marketplaces, the goal is to maximize the utility on both the buyers and the sellers. This in turn enhances the overall revenue generated within the marketplace, and is critical in ensuring the long-term viability and competitiveness of the platform. Marketplaces typically implement complex auction mechanisms to achieve these goals. Unlike traditional auctions, that focus solely on price-based allocation, modern auctions consider a variety of factors. It includes the strategic behaviors of both buyers and sellers, the dynamic nature of their payment policies, and the overall impact on marketplace revenue [ 1 , 2 ] . Key industrial applications of these advanced auction mechanisms include Energy Markets, Telecommunications, Digital Marketing and many others. Given the complexity of these auctions, payment policies have also become increasingly dynamic [ 2 ] . Validating a new payment policy in the real-world settings presents significant challenges. A/B testing is commonly used for online evaluation of the new policies, which is both expensive and time-consuming. Moreover, in user-facing commercial applications, A/B tests can risk exposing users to poor-performing policies, which can directly harm the application’s revenue. As an alternative, simulation-based learning has been proposed as a new direction for evaluation [ 3 ] . However, these systems are still in their infancy, often relying on a deep understanding of the auction environment or on assumptions that may not hold true in real-world scenarios. While offline validation has its drawbacks, particularly the necessity of logged data, it has demonstrated significant advantages in applications such as recommendation and ranking. This method, known as Off-Policy Evaluation (OPE) [ 4 ] , is employed in reinforcement learning and decision-making contexts to estimate the performance of a new policy using historical data collected under a different policy. Essentially, OPE predicts how well a new or hypothetical strategy would perform based on data generated by an existing strategy. In industrial settings, particularly in recommendation and ranking systems, OPE provides a practical and efficient alternative to traditional online evaluation methods. In this paper, we explore the limitations and potential of using OPE in a dynamic auction environment. Our goal is to develop a measurement system capable of evaluating the payment policies using existing data alone, thereby enabling us to assess the feasibility of improving performance by testing new policies. To evaluate the viability of this approach, our study addresses the following key research questions: • Conduct a comprehensive analysis of discrete versus continuous policy evaluation methods for dynamic competitive auctions. • Assess the feasibility of identifying the best-performing policy among three options based on the outcomes of two prior tests. • Learning optimal policies through optimization of policy estimators and evaluating their effectiveness via simulation. II Overview of the Approach II-A Problem Description In this dynamic auction environment, resources are considered to be theoretically infinite, and an indeterminate number of agents compete to acquire them. Each agent assigns a personal value to the resources and aims to maximize their utility through participation. Agents operate according to a payment policy ( \pi ), which influences their willingness to pay to acquire the resources for which they are competing. The determination of the winning agent involves considering both the payment amount and the potential revenue generated from the allocation [ 2 ] . Winning the auction incurs costs for the agent, related to the resources expended. The effectiveness of the allocation is evaluated through metrics such as reach , resources , and returns . Reach measures the impact or extent of the allocation, this is analogous to views in marketing. Resources denote the quantity of units allocated after conversion, such as purchases, download, etc. Returns reflect the overall utility of winning the allocation. Agents have the flexibility to design their payment policies to optimize their performance based on these metrics. This allows them to balance the costs incurred with the expected benefits derived from the allocated resources. II-B Evaluation Pipeline We adopt our pipeline based on the Open-Bandit Modules [ 4 ] but adapt it for our use-cases. The only controllable units in this case are the payment policies. An overview of the pipeline is provided in the Figure 1 . Figure 1 : Off-Policy Evaluator Hyperparameter Learning and Application. The pipeline consists of the following components: • Action Space: In our problem, the action space consists of payment policies, which are continuous variables. For non-continuous evaluators, we discretize them by grouping them into bins. • Policy Modeling: Instead of directly using the original payment policy, we identified proxies by training Random Forest Classifiers (for discrete action space) / Regressors (for continuous action space) on the collected data. This approach is both generalizable and data-driven, making it applicable to any test scenario, regardless of the underlying model. • Reward Modeling: A reward model is required for some of the metrics outlined in Section II-C . In these cases, we employed a Random Forest Regressor to model the reward. • Policy Evaluation: Finally, we compare the rewards predicted by the OPE methods with the actual rewards observed during the A/B tests to assess the accuracy of the estimators. Our experiments involve comparing a wide range of discrete and continuous evaluators. The evaluators used in these comparisons are listed in Section II-C . The OPEs consist of some tunable hyperparameters which are learned to correct the distribution mismatch between the pre-tested policy and the new candidate policy. The data collected during the past A/B tests is used for this task. • Off-Policy Learning: Off-policy learning is the approach where an agent learns about an optimal policy based on the off-policy evaluator. Due to the dynamic nature of the policies and the complex underlying probability associated with them, we learn proxy payment models for simulation. We elaborate more about the process in Section II-D . II-C Off-Policy Evaluation The main idea behind using OPE in dynamic environments is to hypothetically test the performance of different payment

Read the complete text