Control Strategies for Maintaining Transport Symmetries Far From Equilibrium

David Andrieux · 2025

Read Control Strategies for Maintaining Transport Symmetries Far From Equilibrium by David Andrieux (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-05212.txt.

Introduction

David Andrieux presents, in a 2025 paper, two control strategies for tiny devices that carry particles and heat while far from equilibrium. Mesoscopic devices, small enough that fluctuations matter, are hard to steer without breaking the balance of their flows. Transport laws in such systems obey symmetries that link currents to the forces driving them. Pushing a device hard usually breaks those links. Andrieux asks how to adjust the output while keeping the symmetry intact.

Both schemes reshape currents and energy flows while preserving symmetric transport properties. He gives exact descriptions of each and studies their traits in detail. One scheme stands out for changing the original process as little as possible, measured by a standard information distance. The author offers the methods as tools for designing and running small energy and information devices.

Catalog record

CREATORDavid Andrieux
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE60 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-05212

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Control Strategies for Maintaining Transport Symmetries Far From Equilibrium David Andrieux Abstract We present two strategies for controlling the transport dynamics of mesoscopic devices. In both cases, we manipulate the system’s output — such as particle currents and energy flows — while maintaining symmetric transport properties, even under far-from-equilibrium conditions. We provide exact descriptions of each scheme and investigate their characteristics. Notably, one of them minimizes the dissimilarity between the original and modified processes, as quantified by the Kullback-Leibler divergence. These findings can be used to improve the design and control of mesoscopic systems. Context and objectives Imagine you are operating a mesoscopic device designed to produce a specific output, such as a flow of particles or energy currents. The device’s operating mode reflects a balance between achieving the desired transport properties and managing acceptable levels of fluctuations, dissipation, and robustness. Now, consider the problem of adjusting this output in a controlled way. How can you ensure that the device continues to function as intended? In many systems, altering any single kinetic parameter can impact the overall dynamics, including fluctuations, dissipation, and efficiency [ 1 ] . Conversely, some parameters may exhibit ”sloppy” behavior, meaning that altering their values over a wide range may not significantly change the output [ 2 , 3 ] . Navigating this complex parameter space to identify the parameters’ adjustments for achieving the desired output is a challenging task. In addition, different transport processes are interconnected: changes to one current can affect others. Close to equilibrium, the Onsager symmetries describe how the response of a system is related to changes of reciprocal processes [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] . This is particularly useful in materials science, electrochemistry, and biological processes, where the Onsager reciprocity allows predictions about one type of response based on measurements of its reciprocal process. Another benefit of the reciprocity relations is the reduction in the number of independent coefficients needed to describe the system. Extending these symmetries to far-from-equilibrium situations would expand our understanding of energy and matter transfer in various applications. In addition, predictable symmetry principles that relate one response to another even in the nonlinear regime would improve our ability to design and control mesoscopic devices that rely on multiple coupled processes (e.g., thermal, electrical, mechanical). For example, if a large applied temperature gradient not only generates a heat current but also influences mechanical deformation in a predictable way, designers could exploit these relationships to optimize multiple performance metrics simultaneously [ 7 ] . However, extending the Onsager symmetries to the nonlinear regime has remained elusive [ 8 ] . A notable exception is the fluctuation theorem for currents, which imposes linear relations between the response coefficients of the same order [ 9 ] . These constraints reduce the number of independent coefficients [ 10 ] , but do not provide full symmetries. In this paper, we propose two control schemes designed to achieve a system’s desired output together with symmetric transport properties. Our strategy is to decompose the space of parameters in terms of thermodynamics quantities and use geometric structures to navigate the space. This approach leads to the development of two distinct control schemes, referred to as e and m , which are grounded in concepts from information geometry. We obtain explicit constructions for both strategies. The e dynamics coincide with the concept of ”dynamical equivalence classes” introduced to study large current fluctuations [ 11 , 12 ] . We also demonstrate that the e dynamics modify the device’s outputs while remaining as close as possible to the original dynamics, as measured by the Kullback-Leibler divergence. In turn, the m dynamics define new equivalence classes not considered previously. We derive expressions for the affinity-current manifold and response coefficients for these classes, and express them in terms of equilibrium quantities. These results enable the control of mesoscopic systems by providing the necessary combinations of parameters to achieve the desired outputs, and we illustrate this approach on two systems of interest. These findings also reveal hidden structures and symmetries within the parameter space with a clear thermodynamic interpretation. Beyond its potential applications, this work integrates and extends recent findings in information geometry, transport fluctuations, response theory, and the generation of Markov chains. Structure of the paper: In Section 1, we introduce the dynamics of Markov chains and their associated transport properties. We explore the relationship between microscopic and macroscopic quantities, as well as the dimensionality of the parameter space. We also present the framework for nonlinear response theory. In Sections 2 and 3, we construct the e and m control strategies and analyze their properties. We demonstrate that both schemes lead to symmetric transport properties, albeit through different physical mechanisms. In Section 4, we apply these concepts to two distinct systems. The first system is a molecular motor toy model with a single current, and which can be solved analytically. The second system involves two coupled currents and a higher-dimensional parameter space. Numerical simulations illustrate the nonequilibrium symmetries present in this more complex system. Finally, in Section 5 we discuss the implications and new perspectives offered by these results. I Transport in mesoscopic systems I.1 Markov chain dynamics The dynamical properties of many biological, chemical and physical mesoscale systems are well-described by a Markov dynamics [ 6 , 1 ] . We thus consider the space \Lambda of primitive Markov chains on a finite state space of size N (an extension of our results to continuous-time is straightforward). Each primitive chain P\in\Lambda then admits a unique stationary state \pi with \sum_{i}\pi_{i}=1 . Steady-state transport is characterized by the stationary currents \displaystyle J_{ij}=\pi_{i}P_{ij}-\pi_{j}P_{ji}\,. (1) The system is at thermodynamic equilibrium when all currents vanish, i.e. when \displaystyle\pi_{i}P_{ij}=\pi_{j}P_{ji}\quad{\rm(detailed\,balance)} (2) for all pairs (i,j) . The currents J_{ij} are not independent as they must satisfy Krichoff’s law at each node \displaystyle\sum_{j}J_{ij}=\sum_{i}J_{ij}=0\,. (3) As a result, there exist a set of independent currents J_{\alpha} such that any current J_{ij} can be expressed as a linear combination of these independent currents. These independent currents are linked to the fundamental cycles c_{\alpha} of the graph associated with P [ 13 ] : \displaystyle J_{ij}=\sum_{\alpha}\gamma_{ij}(c_{\alpha})J_{\alpha}\,. (4) Here the quantities \gamma_{ij}(c) take the value \pm 1 if the transition i\rightarrow j belongs to the cycle c in the positive (+) or negative (-) direction, and 0 otherwise. An introduction to the graph representation of Markov chains and how to identify the independent currents is presented in Appendix A. In tandem with the currents, the thermodynamic affinities driving the system out of equilibrium can be measured by the breaking of detailed balance along cyclic paths c=(i_{1},i_{2},\cdots,i_{n}) as \displaystyle A_{c}=\ln\left(\frac{P_{i_{1}i_{2}}\cdots P_{i_{n}i_{1}}}{P_{i_{1}i_{2}}\cdots P_{i_{n}i_{1}}}\right)\,. (5) The affinities vanish at equilibrium where detailed balance is satisfied. They do not involve the stationary probabilities \pi and can thus be calculated from the transition probabilities directly. Similar to the currents, only a subset A_{\alpha} of these affinities are independent. The affinity of an arbitrary cycle can be expressed as a linear combination of the fundamental affinities (Appendix A). The currents and affinities capture the anti-symmetric component of the dynamics. The symmetric component is described by the activities \displaystyle Y_{ij}=\pi_{i}P_{ij}+\pi_{j}P_{ji}\,. (6) These quantities (also called frenesies in the litterature) are not all independent

Read the complete text