Star equilibrium: from BNG to TOV
Roberto Casadio, Octavian Micu · 2025
Read Star equilibrium: from BNG to TOV by Roberto Casadio, Octavian Micu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-04632.txt.
Introduction
Roberto Casadio and Octavian Micu test a modified theory of gravity on the balance that holds a star up. Their 2025 paper works in bootstrapped Newtonian gravity, a halfway scheme between Newton's rules and full relativity. They enrich its balance equation with terms borrowed from the relativistic TOV equation, the standard rule for star structure.
The pair then compare their stars with exact Newtonian and relativistic solutions for balls of uniform density. One classic result does not appear: no matter which extra terms they add, their stars show no Buchdahl limit, the cap on compactness found in relativity. Some added terms do push pressure below zero inside stars that are still too loose to form black holes in the scheme. The study maps where the halfway theory matches its parents and where it strays.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Roberto Casadio, Octavian Micu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 47 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-04632
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Star equilibrium: from BNG to TOV Roberto Casadio, Octavian Micu Abstract We study the role of the equilibrium equation in bootstrapped Newtonian gravity (BNG) by including terms inspired by the post-Newtonian expansion of the Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkov (TOV) equation. We then compare (approximate) BNG solutions for homogenous stars with their Newtonian and General Relativistic exact solutions. Regardless of the additional terms from the conservation equation, BNG stars do not exhibit a Buchdahl limit. However, specific extra terms added to this equation can cause the pressure to become negative inside stars with compactness smaller than the critical values for BNG black hole formation. 1 Introduction We live in a time when more and more experiments are aimed at testing (directly or indirectly) the gravitational interaction in its strong-field regime. Indeed there are many mysteries surrounding the nature of the extremely compact objects that would source these strong fields. A key question is whether space-time singularities exist behind black hole event horizons, as predicted by general relativity (GR) [ 1 ] , or whether an alternative description is needed in this regime that can lead to regular interior solutions (see, e.g. Ref. [ 2 ] ), for example to effectively account for quantum effects in the classical theory. With this in mind, bootstrapped Newtonian gravity (BNG) was introduced in Ref. [ 3 ] and subsequently developed in a series of works [ 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] as a simple theoretical framework to investigate the role that non-linearities added to the Newtonian theory could play in the interior of very compact objects and even possibly black holes. One of its main motivations was exactly to find if there could exist non-singular configurations for the matter trapped behind the event horizon of a black hole in a description of gravity that is not quite the full-fledged GR. BNG is viewed as a bottom-up approach, that starts from the Newtonian theory and incorporates several additional (non-linear) terms similar to those that appear at leading orders in the weak-field expansion of GR. However, all additional terms are treated on equal footing from the outset, and we regard BNG as a distinct alternative description of compact objects. The additional non-linear terms add a considerable amount of complexity. As a result, it becomes usually impossible to find analytic solutions. In BNG, the model for a compact object is governed by a system of two differential equations, namely the Euler-Lagrange equation for the gravitational potential and the conservation equation, which are solved by imposing the corresponding boundary conditions. While the Euler-Lagrange equation obtained from the action that includes the non-linear terms has remained unchanged throughout the development of the BNG, higher levels of complexity were achieved in successive increments by taking into account extra terms in the equation that is responsible for the equilibrium between the gravitational pull and the pressure. Initially the simplest Newtonian conservation equation was employed. However, the pressure was shown to become very large in the compactness regime of interest, and the pressure was then added to the density, in what might have seemed an ad-hoc extension. In order to achieve a more comprehensive understanding of what our model of compact objects can lead to, we will here add all of the first order terms resulting from the expansion of the TOV equation in the Newton constant and pressure. Besides extending the model, this also works as a check which shows that the pressure term added previously is found among these extra first order terms. The BNG is built upon a Lagrangian that incorporates several additional terms beyond those found in the Lagrangian for the Newtonian potential, \displaystyle L_{\rm N}[V]=-4\,\pi\int_{0}^{\infty}r^{2}\,\mbox{${\rm d}$}r\left[\frac{\left(V^{\prime}\right)^{2}}{8\,\pi\,G_{\rm N}}+\rho\,V\right]\ , (1.1) which leads to the well known Poisson equation in spherical coordinates, with primes denoting derivatives with respect to r . More exactly, the BNG Lagrangian from Ref. [ 4 ] is given by \displaystyle L[V] \displaystyle\!\!=\!\! \displaystyle L_{\rm N}[V]-4\,\pi\int_{0}^{\infty}r^{2}\,\mbox{${\rm d}$}r\left[q_{V}\,\mathcal{J}_{V}\,V+q_{p}\,\mathcal{J}_{p}\,V+q_{\rho}\,\mathcal{J}_{\rho}\left(\rho+q_{p}\,\mathcal{J}_{p}\right)\right] (1.2) \displaystyle\!\!=\!\! \displaystyle-4\,\pi\int_{0}^{\infty}r^{2}\,\mbox{${\rm d}$}r\left[\frac{\left(V^{\prime}\right)^{2}}{8\,\pi\,G_{\rm N}}\left(1-4\,q_{V}\,V\right)+\left(\rho+\,q_{p}\,p\right)V\left(1-2\,q_{\rho}\,V\right)\right]\ , with V=V(r) representing the potential for static spherically symmetric objects, and primes denote derivatives with respect to the radial coordinate r . Without the additional terms proportional to q_{V} , q_{p} and q_{\rho} , the potential V is the same as the Newtonian potential V_{\rm N} satisfying the field equations derived from Eq. ( 1.1 ) for an object of matter density \rho=\rho(r) . Note that when comparing with GR expressions, the radius r in the above Lagrangian should be viewed as the “harmonic” radial coordinate (which leads to the Poisson equation for the Newtonian potential from the weak-field expansion of the Einstein equations [ 11 ] ). The term proportional to q_{V} in the integral ( 1.2 ) should be understood as the gravitational self-coupling sourced by the gravitational energy U_{\rm N} per unit volume \displaystyle\mathcal{J}_{V}\simeq\frac{\mbox{${\rm d}$}U_{\rm N}}{\mbox{${\rm d}$}\mathcal{V}}=-\frac{\left[V^{\prime}(r)\right]^{2}}{2\,\pi\,G_{\rm N}}\ . (1.3) The BNG was designed to be applicable to highly compact objects, with the compactness defined as \displaystyle X\equiv\frac{G_{\rm N}\,M}{R}\ , (1.4) where M represents the Arnowitt-Deser-Misner (ADM)-like mass [ 12 ] , which should be understood as the mass calculated by studying orbits around the star [ 8 , 13 ] , and R is the star radius. For X\geq 0.1 , the static pressure p=p(r) was found to be no longer negligible [ 3 ] . A corresponding potential energy term U_{p} was then introduced in Ref. [ 4 ] , such that \displaystyle\mathcal{J}_{p}\simeq-\frac{\mbox{${\rm d}$}U_{p}}{\mbox{${\rm d}$}\mathcal{V}}=p\ . (1.5) The effect of the pressure term is to replace \rho\to\rho+q_{p}\,p in the Lagrangian, with the dimensionless coupling q_{p} introduced to formally interpolate between the relativistic limit q_{p}\to 1 and the non-relativistic limit q_{p}\to 0 . The inclusion of the pressure by effectively shifting the density follows along the lines of the definition of the Tolman mass [ 14 ] . The last term in the Lagrangian in Eq. ( 1.2 ) is a higher-order term, namely \displaystyle\mathcal{J}_{\rho}=-2\,V^{2}\ , (1.6) which couples with the matter source. In fact, all of the coupling constants q_{V} , q_{p} and q_{\rho} were specifically introduced to study the different regimes of the BNG when they vary between zero and one. The Newtonian regime is recovered in the limit q_{V}=q_{p}=q_{\rho}\to 0 , as the only remaining term in Eq. ( 1.2 ) is the Lagrangian for the Newtonian potential. Each of the additional terms in Eq. ( 1.2 ) was discussed in more detail in Ref. [ 4 ] and the effects of the coupling q_{\rho} were further investigated in Ref. [ 7 ] . Varying the action ( 1.2 ) with respect to V yields the Euler-Lagrange equation \displaystyle\triangle V=4\,\pi\,G_{\rm N}\left(\rho+q_{p}\,p\right)\frac{1-4\,q_{\rho}\,V}{1-4\,q_{V}\,V}+\frac{2\,q_{V}\left(V^{\prime}\right)^{2}}{1-4\,q_{V}\,V}\ , (1.7) where \triangle is the Laplacian operator in spherical coordinates. The conservation equation for the energy-momentum tensor of a spherically symmetric fluid in GR is given by the Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkov (TOV) equation [ 15 , 16 ] , which follows from the Einstein equations without extra assumptions [see Appendix A ]. Instead, one must impose an equilibrium equation between the pressure and the gravitational pull in Newtonian gravity. The situation is similar in the BNG, where the equilibrium equation must also be imposed beside the field equation ( 1.7 ) that determines the potential. In the original proposal [