G G -systems and 4E Cognitive Science
Vadim K. Weinstein · 2025
Read G G -systems and 4E Cognitive Science by Vadim K. Weinstein (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-04125.txt.
Introduction
Vadim Weinstein introduced a class of dynamical systems in a solo 2025 paper and used them to ground ideas for 4E cognitive science. The systems, called G-systems, carry a coupling operation that joins systems together. Cognitive science in the 4E vein treats mind as embodied, embedded, enacted, and extended, and it lacks shared math foundations.
With coupling in place, Weinstein defines dependence and causality for dynamical systems, borrowing the first from dependence logic and the second from Pearl's work. The reverse of coupling, decomposition or reducibility, is then characterized through the dependence atom. Readers get a formal scaffold where claims about coupled minds and worlds can be stated sharply, rather than as loose metaphor.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Vadim K. Weinstein |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-04125
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
G G -systems and 4E Cognitive Science Vadim K. Weinstein Abstract We introduce a class dynamical systems called G G -systems equipped with a coupling operation. We use G G -systems to define the notions of dependence (borrowed from dependence logic) and causality (borrowed from Pearl) for dynamical systems. As a converse to coupling we define decomposition or “reducibility”. We give a characterization of reducibility in terms of the dependence “atom”. We do all this with the motivation of developing mathematical foundations for 4E cognitive science, see introductory sections. 1 Philosophical motivation Classical cognitive science views the biological body as the “hardware” and cognitive processes as a “software” which runs on it. This approach overlooks the deep and intricate entanglement between the two and the constraints they impose on each other. Enactivist, embodied, extended, and embedded (4E) approaches to understanding cognition address this gap. These theories argue that cognition is strongly shaped and constrained in non-trivial ways by the nature of the sensorimotor interactions an agent engages in, or can potentially engage in [ 7 , 14 , 10 , 2 ] . 1.1 Example: Tetrapus \includegraphics [width=]Quadropus.png Figure 1: (a) Tetrapus swimming in a container. (b) Palpating the wall. Occationally entering holes with a tentacle. (c) If the tentacle can bend on the other side, it triggers a pulling behaviour. This bending can only happen if the tentacle can go deep enough into the hole. (d) Tetrapus ends up pulling itself through the hole. Since the thickness of the tentacle matches the size of the beak, the hole is of the right diameter and the pull is successful. It is known that due to its softness an octopus can fit through a very narrow opening. As long as the opening is just slightly wider than its beak, it can fit through because the beak is the only hard part of its body. In our illustration (Figure 1 ) we present a tetrapus (because it is easier to draw). Its tentacles’ middle part, when not squeezed, has the same thickness as the beak. The tetrapus tries to get to the other side of the wall. It palpates its surroundings with its tentacles. If a tentacle goes into a hole and penetrates it so deeply that it can bend on the other side this can be sensed by the tetrapus and triggers the behaviour of pulling the entire body through that hole. The bending is possible precisely when the tentacle is just so deep in the hole that the thick part is through the hole. The specific tentacle thickness in conjuction with the appropriate policies of the tetrapus enable it to be “fit” to the environment and the tasks that are important possibly for its survaval. Such fitness is described as attunement by the 4E approahces. One may be tempted to describe this by saying that when the tentacle can bend, the octopus “knows” that it can fit through the hole. But “knowledge” is not defined in our model. All that is defined are processes that are triggered by other processes modulated by sensory feedback. To ascribe “knowledge” of “being able to fit through the hole” to the tetrapus neglects the fact that there is very little going on in its internal system. “Being able to fit through the hole” is a complex statement about the geometry of the vast state space which consists of all possible configurations of the mushy body of the tetrapus in the given minimal enviroment. Instead, this can be seen as “outsourced” by the agent into the geometry of its own tentacles. One may also conceive of more complex scenarios where the tentacle is less thick than the beak, so apart from fitting in through the hole, the tetrapus would need to wiggle the tentacle in it before the pulling behaviour is triggered. Moreover, in another scenario the pulling behaviour may not be triggered even when the hole has already been found. The tetrapus would keep its tentacle in the hole while feeding on the floating delicacies in the left chamber. The smell of a predator would then trigger the pulling behaviour. Note how the positioning of the tentacle in the hole replaces “memory” for the agent. These embodied processes are regulared by internal dynamics, but they work only when these dynamics are coupled with the appropriate type of environment. Enactivists often use the term attunement to describe the “fit” between the agent’s brain-body system with its environment. 1.2 A brief introduction to 4E Since the publication of The Embodied Mind [ 24 ] where the term enactivism was coined, 4E cognition has been developing into a new paradigm within cognitive science and philosophy of mind. It has given rise to many new concepts to characterize cognition, and new, non-representationalist, ways of explaining it in terms of body-environment coupled dynamics, sensorimotor contingencies, and autonomous attunement to environmental affordances [ 23 , 15 , 14 , 5 , 6 , 2 ] . Today 4E cognition stands for enactive , embedded , emergent , extended , embodied , and ecological . Similar ideas have been (partially independently) discovered also in psychology, robotics and neuroscience [ 7 , 3 , 17 , 12 , 11 ] . The basic contrast to classical cognitive science is that enactivism rejects representations as axiomatic in explaining cognition and proposes instead that the fundamental building blocks are the processes of regulating sensitivity, motor responce adaptation, and sensorimotor policy updates. Colloquially we refer to basic concepts in 4E cognition by 4E concepts (see Box 1). All these approaches have in common that cognition is viewed as the result of sensorimotor coupling between the agent and the environment. Box 1. Some of the key concepts of 4E cognition, or 4E concepts are: autonomy (the agent sets up its own goals), attunement (sensitivity to relevant features), affordances (possibilities to engage in behaviours), emergence (high-level properties of the agent-environment system irreducible to low-level properties), situatedness (dependency of cognitive function on the characteristics of immediate environment), robustness (the ability to maintain a grip / control over the situation) relevance (the ability to pay attention to a few select features and ignoring others), and openness (the ability to be selectively alert and react to unexpected stimuli such as accidentally meeting a friend on the street, or the ringing of the phone) Philosophers and cognitive scientists have been proposing already for decades to develop a DST-based formalism for E-cognition. Such a formalism is expected to ground, unify, and clarify concepts of enactive and embodied cognitive science as well as create bridges from it to robotics, AI, and more [ 8 , 23 , 1 , 4 , 5 , 9 , 13 ] . So far, the concepts of DST have only been applied heuristically to talk about and explain 4E concepts while a rigorous mathematical theory is lacking. Using DST concepts as metaphors to describe 4E concepts is useful but it does not do the heavy lifting nor grant the true benefits of an actual formalization.. 1.3 Technical motivation {tikzpicture} [ node style/.style=draw, circle, minimum size=1cm, font=, edge style/.style=draw, -stealth, thick ] \node [node style] (Y) at (0, 1) Y ; \node [node style] (I) at (1.6, 0)