Entanglement Breaking Structure of Cartan-Covariant Quantum Channels

Sean Prudhoe · 2025

Read Entanglement Breaking Structure of Cartan-Covariant Quantum Channels by Sean Prudhoe (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-03959.txt.

Introduction

Sean Prudhoe maps a new family of quantum channels whose symmetry makes their entanglement behavior exactly solvable. His 2025 paper defines Cartan-covariant channels, processes that respect symmetry groups forming symmetric pairs with the full unitary group. The family includes older rotation-covariant channels and adds symplectic and mixed unitary cousins.

Using the standard channel-state dictionary, Prudhoe computes the full spectrum of the associated states and their partial transposes for any dimension. That exact grip lets him test a famous conjecture about entanglement breaking: composing two channels that pass the transpose test should destroy all entanglement. Every Cartan-covariant channel obeys it, and the proof is not trivial for the new members. The work gives quantum information theory a fresh set of fully understood test cases, valuable because exact results in this area are rare.

Catalog record

CREATORSean Prudhoe
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-03959

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Entanglement Breaking Structure of Cartan-Covariant Quantum Channels Sean Prudhoe Abstract Cartan-covariant quantum channels are introduced and studied using the Choi-Jamiołkowski isomorphism. The channels are Cartan-covariant as the covariance groups considered form symmetric pairs with the special unitary group SU( n n ), and their associated Cartan involution provides a route to exactly compute the eigenspectrum of their Choi states and the partial transpose for any n ∈ ℕ n\in\mathbb{N} . These channels include previously studied SO ( n ) (n) -covariant channels, and further include Sp ( n 2 ) (\frac{n}{2}) -covariant channels (when n n is even) and S(U( p p ) × \times U( q q ))-covariant channels (where n = p + q n\!=\!p\!+\!q ). We show that all Cartan-covariant channels satisfy the PPT 2 -conjecture and further demonstrate the nontrivial nature of this result for the class of Sp ( n 2 ) (\frac{n}{2}) -covariant and S ⁡ ( U ⁡ ( p ) × U ⁡ ( q ) ) {\rm S}({\rm U}(p)\!\times\!{\rm U}(q)) -covariant channels. 1 Introduction Quantum channels play a central role in quantum information theory, describing both the unitary and non-unitary evolution of physical quantum systems [ 19 , 2 ] . Understanding the structure of quantum channels and whether they are entanglement breaking is essential to design and implement quantum protocols that leverage entanglement as a resource [ 11 ] . However, determining the entanglement breaking structure of generic channels is NP hard because it is equivalent to determining the separability of the Choi state. An active area of research regarding entanglement breaking channels is the {\rm PPT}^{2} -conjecture, proposed by Christandl [ 15 ] . The conjecture states that the composition of any completely co-positive quantum channels results in an entanglement-breaking channel. It implies that PPT-entangled states cannot be used as a resource in quantum repeaters or other similar quantum network structures that leverage any non-zero amount of entanglement [ 4 ] . Although still an open problem in quantum computation, work in the past decade has proven the PPT 2 -conjecture for limited classes of channels. For example, the PPT 2 -conjecture was proven for low Kraus rank channels, approximately depolarizing channels, and Gaussian channels [ 5 ] . The PPT 2 -conjecture is especially amenable to study over the class of covariant quantum channels. Covariant channels are quantum channels where a group action exists which commutes with the action of the channels [ 22 ] . Explicitly, a unitary representation of a group ( \mathcal{G} ) exists such that U_{g}\mathscr{E}(\cdot)U^{{\dagger}}_{g}=\mathscr{E}\left(U_{g}(\cdot)U^{{\dagger}}_{g}\right) (1) for all g\in\mathcal{G} where \mathscr{E} is the \mathcal{G} -covariant channel. Group symmetry and the study of entanglement breaking of quantum channels pair extremely well. For compact covariance Lie groups, the Haar measure exists and allows for the construction of the twirl operation, \displaystyle\Xi_{\rm twirl}(\cdot)=\int d\mu_{\rm Harr}U_{g}\otimes V_{g}(\cdot)U^{{\dagger}}_{g}\otimes V^{{\dagger}}_{g}\, (2) which projects bipartite matrices onto the space of \mathcal{G} -invariant bipartite matrices. The real power in connection to entanglement breaking is that twirl operation preserves separability [ 25 ] . In fact, all entanglement witnesses map to \mathcal{G} -invariant entanglement witnesses under the twirl operation. Recently, it has been shown that quantum channels covariant with respect to the diagonal unitary group satisfy the PPT 2 -conjecture [ 24 ] and further that the conjecture holds for large, random, diagonal orthogonal covariant channels in [ 18 ] . A sample of recent work studying related aspects of covariant quantum channels includes [ 17 , 10 , 6 ] . To extend on previous work, in this article we consider covariances Lie group such that their Lie algebras ( \mathcal{A} ) form a symmetric pair with the special unitary algebra \mathfrak{su}(n)=\mathcal{A}\oplus\left(\mathfrak{su}(n)/\mathcal{A}\right) . The quotient space \mathcal{B}=\mathfrak{su}(n)/\mathcal{A} is known as a symmetric or homogeneous space. By showing that all Sp( \frac{n}{2} ) covariant channels and SO(4) covariant channels satisfy the PPT 2 -conjecture, it follows that all Cartan-covariant channels satisfy the PPT 2 conjecture from the results of [ 25 , 24 ] . These results, most importantly, on the symplectic covariant channels, are different from existing work for several reason. Chiefly, symplectic covariant channels are never diagonal unitary covariant. The Cartan subalgebra of the unitary group, that generates the diagonal unitary group, is too large be contained within Sp( \frac{n}{2} ). For example assume n=2m , then there are 2m-1 generators in the diagonal unitary group but only m generators in the Cartan subalgebra of the compact symplectic group. Therefore the results of [ 24 ] do not apply. However these results are applicable to the S-covariant channels, as S-type unitary covariance implies diagonal unitary covariance. Another useful difference to other work is that we are working with reducible representations of the symmetry groups. For example, useful entanglement breaking conditions were found for channels covariant with respect to an irreducible representation of a symmetry group [ 20 ] . 1.1 Quantum channels and the Choi-Jamiołkowski state We begin with a brief review of quantum channels. A quantum channel ( \mathcal{E} ) is a map \mathscr{E}:\mathbb{M}_{n_{1}}(\mathbb{C})\rightarrow\mathbb{M}_{n_{2}}(\mathbb{C}) (3) that is trace-preserving and completely-positive, where \mathbb{M}_{n}(\mathbb{C}) is the space of n\times n complex matrices. For our purposes, we assume that the input and output spaces are isomorphic n_{1}=n_{2}=n . One method of showing a map is completely positive is to construct a Kraus decomposition, \mathscr{E}\left[\rho\right]=\sum_{i}K_{i}\rho K_{i}^{{\dagger}}\,. (4) The completely positive map is then trace-preserving if, \sum_{i}K^{{\dagger}}_{i}K_{i}=\mathbbm{1}\,. (5) The Kraus decomposition is not unique as typically many choices of Kraus operators ( K_{i} ) exist. For example, any unitary transformation performed on the set \{K_{i}\} generates a new set of Kraus operators. However, there is a minimal number of Kraus operators necessary to generate a given channel, called the Kraus rank. The lack of a unique set of the Kraus operators makes the Kraus decomposition unfavorable for parameterizing quantum channels. A better alternative is the use of Choi’s theorem and the Choi-Jamiołkowski isomorphism to parameterize a set of quantum channels (for example, [ 21 ] ). Choi’s theorem states that a map \mathscr{E} is completely positive iff the Choi state [ 3 ] \varrho_{\mathscr{E}}=(\mathbbm{1}\otimes\mathscr{E})\!\left[\omega\right] (6) is positive, where \omega=|\Psi\rangle\!\langle\Psi| is the maximally entangled pure state, \displaystyle|\Psi\rangle=\sum_{\ell=1}^{n}|\ell\ell\rangle\,. (7) The rank of the Choi state is equal to the Kraus rank of the channel, and its eigenvectors with non-zero eigenvalues form a Kraus basis for the corresponding channel. 1.2 Completely co-positive maps and entanglement breaking An additional class of maps, useful in the study of channels, are the completely co-positive maps and the closely related completely co-positive channels. Denoting the transpose operator (in the computational basis) as T \left(|\ell\rangle\!\langle m|\right)\!=\!|m\rangle\!\langle\ell| , a map \mathscr{E} is called completely co-positive map if T \circ\mathscr{E} is completely positive. A channel that is completely co-positive is known as a positive partial transpose (PPT) channel, since the Choi state of such a channel has a positive partial transpose, i.e. the partial transpose \displaystyle\widetilde{\varrho}_{\mathscr{E}}=(\mathbbm{1}\otimes{\rm T})\varrho_{\mathscr{E}} (8) is also a density matrix. The (partial) transpose is important in quantum information, as all separable mixed states have a positive partial transpose. However, the converse is famously known to hold only generically for 2 \times 2 and 2 \times 3 mixed states [ 12 ] . There are of course subclasses of mixed states in

Read the complete text