Asymmetric Variability: The Impact of Uneven Stochasticity on Competitive Dynamics
Ori Turkia and Nadav M. Shnerb · 2025
Read Asymmetric Variability: The Impact of Uneven Stochasticity on Competitive Dynamics by Ori Turkia and Nadav M. Shnerb (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-03682.txt.
Introduction
Ori Turkia and Nadav M Shnerb model how uneven randomness shapes competition between two species or types, in a 2025 paper. Birth and death are chance events, and outside conditions swing as well. Species with different life histories feel that randomness at different strengths, which can tilt who wins.
The authors build a simple two-species model and derive formulas for key outcomes. These include the chance that one type takes over, how long takeover takes, and how outcomes spread. The formulas hold across wide settings, with migration, selection, and shifting conditions all covered. Results speak to species survival, extinction risk, and how even a community stays. The work gives theory a cleaner grip on chance in rivalry.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ori Turkia and Nadav M. Shnerb |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-03682
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Asymmetric Variability: The Impact of Uneven Stochasticity on Competitive Dynamics Ori Turkia and Nadav M. Shnerb Abstract Competition between species and genotypes is a dominant factor in a variety of ecological and evolutionary processes. Biological dynamics are typically highly stochastic, and therefore, analyzing a competitive system requires accounting for the random nature of birth and death processes (demographic stochasticity) as well as the variability of external conditions (environmental stochasticity). Recent studies have highlighted the importance of species life history, showing that differences in life history lead competing species to experience different levels of demographic stochasticity. Here, we propose a simple model of two-species competition with different life histories and derive analytical expressions for various properties (fixation probability, fixation time, absorption time, probability density) under a wide range of conditions, including migration, selection, and environmental stochasticity. These properties provide insights into the long-term outcomes of competition, such as species persistence, extinction risks, and the influence of environmental variability on the evenness of the community. I introduction Understanding species interactions and species turnover is essential for addressing pressing ecological challenges. A clearer grasp of these dynamics can provide valuable insights into mitigating the alarming loss of biodiversity observed in numerous ecosystems [ 1 , 2 ] - a problem with profound global consequences. Moreover, analyzing species interactions plays a pivotal role in efforts to modify or optimize microbial communities, such as the human microbiome [ 3 ] or soil microbiome [ 4 ] - areas that have become focal points of extensive research. Additionally, our theoretical understanding of evolutionary dynamics hinges on accurately describing ecological interactions, as competitive pressure is the central driving forces of evolution. A central challenge in ecology is identifying the conditions under which competing species can coexist. Despite significant progress, this question remains a fundamental puzzle, as the competitive exclusion principle [ 5 , 6 ] predicts that one species—typically the stronger competitor—will eventually outcompete and exclude the other. Within this context, stochasticity plays a crucial role in shaping species coexistence [ 7 ] . Biological and ecological systems are inherently stochastic, with random fluctuations capable of driving diverse outcomes. Under certain conditions, such fluctuations can even facilitate coexistence [ 8 , 9 ] . Understanding these stochastic dynamics is therefore essential for building robust ecological theories and addressing the related challenges. Stochasticity in ecological systems is typically categorized into two main types: demographic stochasticity and environmental stochasticity [ 10 ] . Demographic stochasticity arises from random variation in the reproductive success of individuals. For instance, each individual might have an equal probability of producing either zero or two offspring. In contrast, environmental stochasticity affects entire populations in a correlated manner. For example, during favorable years, each individual may, on average, produces two offspring, whereas in unfavorable years, this average might drop to just one-half. Neutral models, where stochasticity is the sole driver of abundance variations, have garnered significant interest over the years. In their simplest form [ 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 ] , these models assume that competing species are competitively identical, i.e., that any differences between them are irrelevant to the reproductive process. Both species compete for the same resources, and the stochasticity affecting them is purely demographic. Competitive forces manifest themselves through a constraint on the total population size. In this framework, the model is considered neutral if individuals from both species share the same offspring distribution or, at the very least, distributions with identical means and variances. Neutral models of this kind, whether describing competition between two biological types or communities composed of many species, are well established in the fields of population genetics and ecological community dynamics [ 15 , 16 ] . These models have been successful in explaining observed patterns, such as species abundance distributions. However, they often fall short in capturing temporal fluctuations in species abundances and related metrics [ 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 ] . To address this limitation, time-averaged neutral models have been proposed over the past decade [ 21 , 22 , 23 , 24 ] . In these models, environmental conditions can temporarily favor one species over others, granting it a competitive advantage at a given moment. However, when averaged over time, the long-term fitness of all species remains equal, preserving the core assumption of neutrality. In a recent study, Jops and O’Dwyer [25] proposed a novel type of neutral model. These models exclude environmental stochasticity, and the average number of offspring per individual is identical for both species. However, the species differ in their life history traits, differences that can be empirically quantified using a population matrix model. These traits result in varying magnitudes of demographic stochasticity between species. For example, an individual of one species might produce four, five, or six offspring with equal probability (yielding an average of five), while an individual of the competing species could produce anywhere between two and eight offspring with equal probability. Although the averages are identical, the intensity of demographic stochasticity differs, leading to distinct patterns of population fluctuations. In this work, we present a simple model of competition between two species with different life histories. Using this model, we analyze key aspects of interspecific competition when the competing species experience differing levels of stochasticity: 1. In the simplest case, where stochasticity is purely demographic and dynamics occur on an isolated island, we employ the diffusion approximation to derive expressions for the probability of ultimate fixation, the time to absorption, and the time to fixation (Section IV ). 2. When the system is subject to constant immigration of individuals, rendering the extinction state non-absorbing, we derive formulas for the equilibrium distribution (Section V ). 3. We examine the interplay between stochasticity and selection, with a particular focus on the scenario where the species that is stochastically superior - experiencing lower stochasticity - is also selectively inferior , i.e., having a lower mean number of offspring per individual (Section VI ). 4. We also explore the relationship between demographic and environmental stochasticity. Once again, the most intriguing scenario arises when the species advantaged by demographic stochasticity is disadvantaged by environmental stochasticity (Section VII ). In the penultimate section, we aim to provide a broader perspective, clarifying how, why, and when stochasticity undermines a species’ effective fitness in competition. Finally, we present a general discussion of the conclusions emerging from our analysis. II The model We model the competition between two species with non-overlapping generations, each characterized by a distinct life history. In its simplest form, the dynamics proceed through four sequential steps: 1. Seed Production : Adult individuals of each species produce seeds, with the quantity determined by their reproductive strategies and environmental conditions. 2. Adult Mortality : At the end of each generation, all adult individuals die, ensuring complete generational turnover and the absence of overlap between successive generations. 3. Juvenile Recruitment : Seeds germinate and recruit into a juvenile pool, resulting in a total of J juveniles. 4. Maturation and Seed Production : Each juvenile has a species-specific probability of maturing into an adult capable of producing seeds, thus forming the next generation. We will analyze the transition from one juvenile stage to the next. At a given stage, if