The fine-scale structure of polar coronal holes
R. J. Morton, R. Cunningham · 2025
Read The fine-scale structure of polar coronal holes by R. J. Morton, R. Cunningham (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-03656.txt.
Introduction
Morton and Cunningham zoom into the fine structure inside the Sun's polar coronal holes, in a 2025 paper. Coronal holes are dark regions where the solar wind escapes, and textbooks draw them as broad columns called plumes. Watching the Sun's edge, away from the clutter of the surface below, the team found those columns are bundles of far finer threads. The threads span only a few arcseconds across.
The threads fill the view to the edge of the telescope's field. Their spacing follows a simple power pattern across the magnetic field direction. Some threads widen faster than simple radial spread as they rise, matching models of the polar field's expansion. The authors say this fine grain matters for how waves travel through coronal holes and feed the solar wind.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | R. J. Morton, R. Cunningham |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-03656
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The fine-scale structure of polar coronal holes R. J. Morton, R. Cunningham Abstract Coronal holes are thought to be composed of relatively broad columnar structures known as plumes. Here we demonstrate that the plumes (and inter-plumes) in polar coronal holes are composed of fine-scale filamentary structure, with average scales of 2-10 ′′ {}^{{}^{\prime\prime}} . The fine structure is the off-limb analogue of the previously found ’plumelets’ of Uritsky et al. 2021 . The off-limb observations enable an examination of the fine-structure without the influence of the underlying atmosphere along the line of sight. Hence, we show that the fine-scale structure is present at least until the edge of the field of view of the Solar Dynamics Observatory. The fine structure is found to have spatial distribution that follows a k − 1 k^{-1} power law perpendicular to the inferred magnetic field direction. For a small sample of the fine structure, the cross-sectional profiles are measured as a function of height. In some cases, the measurements indicate that the fine structure expands super-radially, consistent with existing models of polar field expansion and the expansion of the plumes. We discuss the implications of the presence of the fine structure with respect to understanding wave propagation in the coronal holes and their contribution to powering the solar wind. Keywords The Sun (1693), Solar corona (1483), Solar coronal holes (1484), Solar coronal plumes (2039) 1 Introduction Plumes, observed in both polar regions and lower latitude coronal holes, are a common coronal feature that are rooted in near-unipolar fields comprising the magnetic network ( Newkirk & Harvey 1968 ; Wang & Sheeley 1995 ; DeForest et al. 1997 ) . The plumes appear after the emergence of ephemeral regions and can live for several days ( Wang & Muglach 2008 ) . Plumes generally appear as diffuse, columnar features in EUV images, often termed ‘beam’ plumes. The presence of an additional plume structure, the ‘curtain’ plume, has also been suggested in the past to explain the (false) impression in EUV images that plumes are mainly rooted on the far side of the Sun ( Wilhelm et al. 2011 ) . The plumes are found to extend up to \sim 40 R ⊙ in the polar regions, expanding super-radially ( DeForest et al. 2001 ) , hence link many regions of the Sun’s outer atmosphere. Over the decades, they have received significant attention as they likely play an important role in supplying mass and energy into the solar wind. Plumes exhibit a variety of dynamic behaviour. Outflows have been observed throughout the coronal holes (in both plume and inter-plume regions), seemingly starting in the transition region ( Tian et al. 2010 ) and increasing through the low corona ( Habbal et al. 1995 ; Teriaca et al. 2003 ; Morton et al. 2015 ) . The plumes also display outwardly-moving, quasi-periodic disturbances visible as intensity fluctuations in imagers. It remains unclear whether these events are slow magnetoacoustic waves or mass flows ( DeForest & Gurman 1998 ; Banerjee et al. 2009 ; McIntosh et al. 2010 ; Tian et al. 2011 ; Prasad et al. 2011 ; Pucci et al. 2014 , e.g.,) . McIntosh et al. 2010 suggested the occurrence of the fluctuations is connected to jet activity in the upper chromosphere, and is responsible for mass loading heated plasma into the plumes. Samanta et al. 2015 provided evidence that some of these fluctuations are indeed initiated by spicules. A potentially related phenomenon are small-scale coronal jets discussed by Raouafi & Stenborg 2014 , although they seem to be on a larger scale than spicules. Raouafi & Stenborg 2014 suggest that the coronal jets provide mass and energy to initiate and sustain plumes. Plumes in polar coronal holes also demonstrate quasi-periodic transverse displacements in intensity images ( Thurgood et al. 2014 ) , which are associated with intensity features at smaller scales. These motions have been interpreted as the kink mode, which is essentially a surface Alfvén wave ( Goossens et al. 2012 , or Alfvénic waves, ) . The Doppler velocities of coronal emission lines from polar regions also demonstrate the corresponding signal of these waves ( Morton et al. 2015 ) . Given the omni-presence of Alfvénic waves throughout the corona ( McIntosh et al. 2011 ; Morton et al. 2019 ) it should be expected that the Alfvénic waves are also present in equatorial coronal hole plumes, however, there is currently no specific confirmation of this. The Alfvénic fluctuations are regular and present across the coronal holes, plumes and interplumes, indicating that the main driver is convective buffeting and/or the mode conversions of p -modes. Energy estimates suggest the observed fluctuations carry enough energy to provide a significant contribution to the heating or acceleration requirements of the solar wind ( McIntosh et al. 2011 ; Morton et al. 2015 ; Weberg et al. 2018 ) . Although not all Alfvénic modes, e.g., rotational motions, are directly observable in the corona (yet) and so the actual energy flux of Alfvénic waves in coronal holes is unknown. It has recently been recognised that plumes contain fine-structure. The fine-structure was first noted in DeForest et al. 1997 , who observed transient intensity enhancements at scales of 10 ′′ . It was proposed by Gabriel et al. 2009 that, in order to explain the appearance and behaviour of curtain plumes, they must be composed of fine-scale structures which they termed micro-plumes (or network plumes). Wilhelm et al. 2011 suggest that ‘beam’ plumes may also be composed of micro-plumes. Plumes generally appear as diffuse, columnar features in EUV images. However, image processing reveals that plumes in equatorial coronal holes are composed of filamentary substructure ( Uritsky et al. 2021 ) ( Raouafi & Stenborg 2014 , also partialy visible in the processed images of) . They were given the name ‘plumelets’ and found to vary on the time-scales of minutes. The network regions below plumes are known to consist of small-scale ‘network’ jets ( Tian et al. 2014 ; Qi et al. 2019 ) . Kumar et al. 2022 extended the investigation of the substructure, finding variations on the order of 5 minutes, in accordance with the previous studies that had examined the quasi-periodic disturbances integrated over the diffuse plumes. Kumar et al. 2022 connected the appearance of the substructure with the occurrence of coronal jets at the base of the plumes, and suggested that small-scale quasi-periodic reconnection is responsible for producing mass-flows that feed the substructure and ultimately contribute to mass loss via the solar wind. Recently, Raouafi et al. 2023 demonstrated the phenomenon is widespread in coronal holes and suggest the coronal jets (or jetlets as the authors call them) are the primary source of the heating and driving of the solar wind. In this work, we examine the spatial scales of the fine-scale structure within polar coronal holes. We demonstrate that both plume and inter-plume regions show the presence of fine-scale structure. This filamentary structure is superimposed upon a bright, diffuse background emission and is only revealed clearly after removing the diffuse component. The emission from the fine-scale plasma structure is weak, representing only \sim 1\% of the total emission locally (comparable to the