On the Nowicki conjecture for the two-generated free Lie algebra

Lucio Centrone, Şehmus Fındık and Manuela da Silva Souza · 2025

Read On the Nowicki conjecture for the two-generated free Lie algebra by Lucio Centrone, Şehmus Fındık and Manuela da Silva Souza (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-03636.txt.

Introduction

Lucio Centrone, Sehmus Findik, and Manuela da Silva Souza wrote a 2025 math paper on a free Lie algebra built from two letters. They study a map that sends one letter to the other and the second to zero. Their aim is to find which parts stay fixed under that map.

The work grows out of an old claim by Nowicki about fixed parts in rings of many letters. The authors bring in a new tool they call pseudodeterminants. They use it to describe the fixed Hall monomials in their algebra. They also list all the generators of low degree, giving readers a clear set of cases to build on.

Catalog record

CREATORLucio Centrone, Şehmus Fındık and Manuela da Silva Souza
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-03636

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the Nowicki conjecture for the two-generated free Lie algebra Lucio Centrone, Şehmus Fındık and Manuela da Silva Souza Abstract Let K ⁡ [ X n ] = K ⁡ [ x 1 , … , x n ] K[X_{n}]=K[x_{1},\ldots,x_{n}] be the polynomial algebra in n n variables over a field K K of characteristic zero. A locally nilpotent linear derivation δ \delta of K ⁡ [ X n ] K[X_{n}] is called Weitzenböck due to his well known result from 1932 stating that the algebra of constants of δ \delta defined by ker ​ ( δ ) = K ​ [ X n ] δ \text{\rm ker}(\delta)=K[X_{n}]^{\delta} is finitely generated. The explicit form of a generating set of K ​ [ X n , Y n ] δ K[X_{n},Y_{n}]^{\delta} was conjectured by Nowicki in 1994 in the case δ \delta was such that δ ⁡ ( y i ) = x i \delta(y_{i})=x_{i} , δ ⁡ ( x i ) = 0 \delta(x_{i})=0 , i = 1 , … , n i=1,\ldots,n . Nowicki’s conjecture turned out to be true and, recently, has been applied to several relatively free associative algebras. In this paper, we consider the free Lie algebra ℒ ⁡ ( x , y ) \mathcal{L}(x,y) of rank 2 2 generated by x x and y y over K K and we assume the Weitzenböck derivation δ \delta sending y y to x x , and x x to zero. We introduce the idea of pseudodeterminants and we present a characterization of Hall monomials that are constants showing they are not so far from being pseudodeterminants. We also give a complete list of generators of the constants of degree less than 7 which are, of course, pseudodeterminants. keywords algebras of constants, Weitzenböck derivations, Nowicki conjecture. MSC 17B01; 17B40, 16S15, 16W25, 13N15, 13A50. † † authorinfo: [ † † authorinfo: [ † † authorinfo: [ † † volume: 33 † † year: 2025 † † issue: 3 † † number: 9 † † doi: https://doi.org/10.46298/cm.15036 † † edit-info: January 8, 2025 May 14, 2025 David Towers and Ivan Kaygorodov L. Centrone]University of Bari Aldo Moro, Bari, [email protected] Ş. Fındık]Çukurova University, Adana, [email protected] M. da S. Souza]Federal University of Bahia, Salvador, [email protected] 1 Introduction Let K[X_{n}] be the polynomial algebra with generating set X_{n}=\{x_{1},\ldots,x_{n}\} , n\geq 2 over a field K of characteristic zero. It is the free algebra of rank n in the variety of unitary commutative algebras over K . Let H be a subgroup of the general linear group GL_{n}(K) . Then a polynomial p\in K[X_{n}] is H - invariant if it is preserved under the action of each element of H . The vector space K[X_{n}]^{H} of all H -invariants is called the algebra of H -invariants. The question whether the algebra K[X_{n}]^{H} of invariants is finitely generated for every subgroup H of GL_{n}(K) is a special case of the Hilbert’s fourteenth problem suggested by the German mathematician David Hilbert in 1900 at the International Congress of Mathematicians in Paris. Although the answer to Hilbert’s question turned out to be negative in general (see for instance the paper by Nagata [ 24 ] (1958)), some remarkable affirmative cases have been handled as well. Among them is the approach of Weitzenböck [ 33 ] , where he considered the locally nilpotent linear derivations \delta of the algebra K[X_{n}] . Then the kernel \text{\rm ker}(\delta)=K[X_{n}]^{\delta} of the derivation \delta is an algebra so called the algebra of constants. He showed that the algebra K[X_{n}]^{\delta} is finitely generated as an algebra, which is equal to the algebra K[X_{n}]^{UT_{2}(K)} of invariants of the unitriangular group given by {UT_{2}(K)}=\{\text{exp}(c\delta)\mid c\in K\} . Thus the study of the algebra of constants inherits methods from the classical invariant theory. The books by Nowicki [ 25 ] , Derksen and Kemper [ 12 ] , and Sturmfels [ 31 ] are suggested for the readers interested in numerical aspects of algebras of constants and general invariant theory. The next question after the approach of Weitzenböck has become the explicit forms of those generators. Nowicki conjectured in his book [ 25 ] that the algebra K[X_{n},Y_{n}]^{\delta} is generated by x_{1},\ldots,x_{n} , and x_{i}y_{j}-y_{i}x_{j} , 1\leq i<j\leq n , assuming that \delta(y_{i})=x_{i} , \delta(x_{i})=0 , i=1,\ldots,n . The Nowicki’s conjecture was proved by Khoury [ 20 , 21 ] , Drensky and Makar-Limanov [ 17 ] , Kuroda [ 22 ] , Bedratyuk [ 2 ] using different techniques. See also the paper [ 14 ] by Drensky for a generalized version of Nowicki’s conjecture in which the author proves, as a consequence of the paper by Kuroda of 2009, that the algebra of constants of K[X_{n},Y_{n}]^{\delta} is generated by X_{n} and the “determinants” u_{i,j}:=f_{i}y_{j}-f_{j}y_{i} ’s, when the derivation \delta is such that \delta(x_{i})=0 and \delta(y_{i})=f_{i} , i=1,\ldots,n , where the f_{i} ’s are nonconstant polynomials of K[X_{n}] . A natural generalization of the problem is to study the generators of the algebra of constants of (relatively) free associative or Lie algebras. In [ 16 ] Drensky and Gupta studied Weitzenböck derivations acting on the relatively free algebra in a variety \mathfrak{V} . They proved that if \mathfrak{V} contains UT_{2}(K) , then the algebra of constants is not finitely generated. It is also known by a result of Drensky in [ 13 ] that if UT_{2}(K) does not belong to \mathfrak{V} , then the algebra of constants is finitely generated. One may list the recent works as follows. Let \delta be a Weitzenböck derivation of the free metabelian Lie algebra F_{n} and of the free metabelian associative algebra A_{n} of rank m . Dangovski et al. [ 10 , 11 ] showed that the algebras of constants F_{n}^{\delta} and A_{n}^{\delta} are not finitely generated as an algebra except for some trivial cases. Also Drensky and one of the authors [ 15 ] considered the Nowicki conjecture for free metabelian Lie algebras, and they gave explicit forms of the generators. As a continuation of this approach, two among the authors [ 8 ] solved the problem for several relatively free algebras. See also the paper [ 7 ] for a survey toward this argument. The goal of this paper goes in this direction but in a free Lie algebra setting. We recall, by the well known dichotomy, a variety of Lie algebras either satisfies the Engel condition (hence it is nilpotent by [ 35 ] ) or contains the metabelian variety \mathfrak{A}^{2} consisting of all solvable Lie algebras of class 2 which is defined by the identity [[x_{1},x_{2}],[x_{3},x_{4}]]=0 . Since the finitely generated nilpotent Lie algebras are finite dimensional, the problem for the finite generation of the algebras of constants of relatively free nilpotent Lie algebras is solved trivially. In this paper we present the algebra of constants of the free Lie algebra \mathcal{L}(x,y) in two generators. We make use of the definition of pseudodeterminants. The name pseudodeterminants is due to some own algebraic properties and their similarities with the determinant-like generators used by Makar-Limanov and Drensky in their proof of Nowicki’s conjecture for the free commutative algebra. We give a characterization of the monomials which are constants. It turns out they can be monomials in

Read the complete text