Universality in quantum critical flow of charge and heat in ultra-clean graphene
Aniket Majumdar, Nisarg Chadha, Pritam Pal, Akash Gugnani, Bhaskar Ghawri, Kenji Watanabe, Takashi Taniguchi, Subroto Mukerjee, Arindam Ghosh · 2025
Read Universality in quantum critical flow of charge and heat in ultra-clean graphene by Aniket Majumdar, Nisarg Chadha, Pritam Pal, Akash Gugnani, Bhaskar Ghawri, Kenji Watanabe, Takashi Taniguchi, Subroto Mukerjee, Arindam Ghosh (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-03193.txt.
Introduction
Aniket Majumdar and eight co-authors probe how charge and heat flow in very clean graphene near a special point. Graphene is a single layer of carbon atoms, and near its Dirac point the electrons act like a fluid. Theory says one value, the flow of charge at that point, should settle at a fixed number set by deep rules.
The team measured both electric and heat flow in high-quality samples. The two flows moved in opposite ways, as fluid theory predicts, and the charge value landed close to the expected mark in several samples. Heat and charge also broke a classic rule linking them, by a wide margin. The heat flow neared a known lower bound tied to quantum physics.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aniket Majumdar, Nisarg Chadha, Pritam Pal, Akash Gugnani, Bhaskar Ghawri, Kenji Watanabe, Takashi Taniguchi, Subroto Mukerjee, Arindam Ghosh |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-03193
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Universality in quantum critical flow of charge and heat in ultra-clean graphene Aniket Majumdar, Nisarg Chadha, Pritam Pal, Akash Gugnani, Bhaskar Ghawri, Kenji Watanabe, Takashi Taniguchi, Subroto Mukerjee, Arindam Ghosh Abstract Close to the Dirac point, graphene is expected to exist in quantum critical Dirac fluid state, where the flow of both charge and heat can be described with a dc electrical conductivity \sigma_{\mathrm{Q}} , and thermodynamic variables such as the entropy and enthalpy densities Son [2007] , Hartnoll et al. [2007] . Although the fluid-like viscous flow of charge is frequently reported in state-of-the-art graphene devices Crossno et al. [2016] , Bandurin et al. [2016] , Ku et al. [2020] , Bandurin et al. [2018] , Krishna Kumar et al. [2017] , Xin et al. [2023] , Block et al. [2021] , Ghahari et al. [2016] , Gallagher et al. [2019] , Kumar et al. [2022] , Sulpizio et al. [2019] , Huang et al. [2023] , Tan et al. [2022] , the value of \sigma_{\mathrm{Q}} , predicted to be quantized and determined only by the universality class of the critical point, has not been established experimentally so far Hartnoll et al. [2007] , Damle and Sachdev [1997] . Here we have discerned the quantum critical universality in graphene transport by combining the electrical ( \sigma ) and thermal ( \kappa_{\mathrm{e}} ) conductivities in very high-quality devices close to the Dirac point. We find that \sigma and \kappa_{\mathrm{e}} are inversely related, as expected from relativistic hydrodynamics, and \sigma_{\mathrm{Q}} converges to \approx(4\pm 1)\times e^{2}/h for multiple devices, where e and h are the electronic charge and the Planck’s constant, respectively. We also observe, (1) a giant violation of the Wiedemann-Franz law where the effective Lorentz number exceeds the semiclassical value by more than 200 times close to the Dirac point at low temperatures, and (2) the effective dynamic viscosity ( \eta_{\mathrm{th}} ) in the thermal regime approaches the holographic limit \eta_{\mathrm{th}}/s_{\mathrm{th}}\rightarrow\hbar/4\pi k_{\mathrm{B}} within a factor of four in the cleanest devices close to the room temperature, where s_{\mathrm{th}} and k_{\mathrm{B}} are the thermal entropy density and the Boltzmann constant, respectively. Our experiment addresses the missing piece in the potential of high-quality graphene as a testing bed for some of the unifying concepts in physics. Transport in real graphene devices is determined by two competing length scales: The electron-electron scattering length l_{\mathrm{ee}} and the momentum relaxation length l_{\mathrm{mr}} , both of which depend on the carrier density n (or the Fermi Temperature T_{\mathrm{F}} =\hbar v_{F}\sqrt{\pi n} , v_{F} being the Fermi velocity) and the temperature T (see schematic in Fig. 1 a). In the diffusive and inhomogeneous regimes, scattering from, for example, the Coulomb impurities or phonons, do not conserve the momentum, resulting in l_{\mathrm{mr}}\ll l_{\mathrm{ee}} . As the disorder decreases, the channel can be ballistic when the device dimension is \ll l_{\mathrm{ee}} , l_{\mathrm{mr}} or viscous, when l_{\mathrm{ee}} becomes the shortest length scale. The viscous flow is described well by the electronic analogue of the Navier-Stokes equation Levitov and Falkovich [2016] when T_{\mathrm{F}}/T\gg 1 , and manifests in parabolic propagation profile Sulpizio et al. [2019] , Ku et al. [2020] , negative non-local resistance Bandurin et al. [2016] or super-ballistic electrical conduction Krishna Kumar et al. [2017] , among others. In the opposite (thermal) limit of T_{\mathrm{F}}/T\ll 1 , nearly unscreened Coulomb interaction and linear dispersion tune to a Lorentz-invariant quantum critical point Hartnoll et al. [2007] , Fritz et al. [2008] , where the current relaxes by collisions among the thermally excited electrons and holes, while the energy propagates unimpeded due to conservation of momentum during such collisions. This naturally violates the Wiedemann-Franz (WF) law. For relativistic hydrodynamics, quantum critical \sigma and \kappa_{\mathrm{e}} are predicted to be Lucas et al. [2016] , Xie and Foster [2016] , Lucas and Fong [2018] , \sigma(n)=\sigma_{\mathrm{Q}}+\frac{e^{2}v_{\mathrm{F}}n^{2}l_{\mathrm{mr}}}{\mathcal{H}} (1) and \kappa_{\mathrm{e}}(n)=\frac{v_{\mathrm{F}}l_{\mathrm{mr}}{\cal H}\sigma_{\mathrm{Q}}}{T\sigma(n)} (2) where, {\cal H} and v_{\mathrm{F}} are the enthalpy density and Fermi velocity, respectively. So far, several experimental reports on the breakdown of the WF law Crossno et al. [2016] , enhanced thermoelectric power Ghahari et al. [2016] , giant quasi-linear magnetoresistance Xin et al. [2023] , near-Planckian scattering rates and efficient thermal diffusion inferred from the terahertz Gallagher et al. [2019] and pump-probe Block et al. [2021] spectroscopic techniques, provided valuable insight to the formation of a Dirac fluid, but unambiguous experimental evaluation of \sigma_{\mathrm{Q}} has not been possible. This is because the measured \sigma for n\rightarrow 0 yields non-universal results, limited by device-dependent spatial inhomogeneity, or puddles, of charge close to the Dirac point Adam et al. [2007] (see Supplementary Section S1). In the absence of this, the quantum critical behaviour itself remains unsettled, especially in the presence of alternative models that propose violation of the WF law in marginally gapped graphene within the Fermi liquid framework Tu and Sarma [2023] . Figure 1: Viscous electron flow in ultra-clean graphene devices: (a) Different regimes of electron transport in graphene, based on the interplay between momentum-conserving and momentum-relaxing collisions. (b) (Top) Optical micrograph of the device along with the circuit diagram used for conducting the electrical transport measurements. (Bottom) Schematic of the heterostructure. (c) Electrical conductance of device D4S4 as a function of the carrier density n for 90 K \leq T\leq 260 K. The dashed line labelled G_{\mathrm{ball}} indicates the ballistic conductance for the measured channel. (d) Charge inhomogeneity ( n_{\mathrm{min}} ) as a function of T for five different devices. The colour gradient in the background indicates the transition from a disorder-driven regime to a thermally-driven transport regime. (e) Electrical conductance (normalised by the ballistic conductance, G_{\mathrm{ball}} ) of D4S4 as a function of l_{\mathrm{ee}}/W for different carrier densities, varying from n=1\times 10^{11} cm -2 to 5\times 10^{11} cm -2 . (f) Normalised conductance as a function of the Knudsen number for five different devices. (g) Electrical conductivity as a function of width W at n=8\times 10^{10} cm -2 and T=160 K. For the chosen values of n and T , we have observed that l_{\mathrm{ee}}/W\leq 0.5 . The solid line scales as W^{2} and serves as a guide to the eye. Inset shows the same dataset in double logarithmic scale where the straight line represents quadratic dependence. (h) Kinematic viscosity \nu as a function of n for four different devices, measured at T=180 K. In this work, we have combined dc charge and heat transport to explore the quantum critical conductivity in graphene. We measured both \sigma and \kappa_{\mathrm{e}} in multiple graphene devices with low charge inhomogeneity \simeq 5-10\times 10^{9} cm -2 , where the momentum relaxation, particularly at low temperatures, occurs at the boundary in most of the devices Xin et al. [2023] . Combining \sigma and \kappa_{\mathrm{e}} as in Eqn. 2 , and assigning l_{\mathrm{mr}}=\mathrm{min}(W,l_{\mathrm{mfp}}) , where W and l_{\mathrm{mfp}}=h\sigma/2e^{2}k_{\mathrm{F}} are the geometric channel width and the mean free path of carriers in the channel, respectively, we obtain a device-insensitive estimate of \sigma_{\mathrm{Q}}\simeq(4\pm 1)\times e^{2}/h , where the error represents variation across multiple devices. Fundamentally, this all-experimental strategy to determine \sigma_{\mathrm{Q}} depends on the high quality of our devices which makes the thermal limit ( T_{\mathrm{F}}/T<1 ) accessible over a broad range of T for n\gtrsim n_{\mathrm{min}}(0) , i.e. , when n is well-defined. I Electron