Synthetic accessibility and sodium ion conductivity of the Na 8-x A x P 2 O 9 (NAP) high-temperature sodium superionic conductor framework

Lauren N. Walters, Yuxing Fei, Bernardus Rendy, Xiaochen Yang, Mouhamad Diallo, KyuJung Jun, Grace Wei, Matthew J. McDermott, Andrea Giunto, Tara Mishra, Fengyu Shen, David Milsted, May Sabai Oo, Haegyeom Kim, Michael C. Tucker, Gerbrand Ceder · 2025

Read Synthetic accessibility and sodium ion conductivity of the Na 8-x A x P 2 O 9 (NAP) high-temperature sodium superionic conductor framework by Lauren N. Walters, Yuxing Fei, Bernardus Rendy, Xiaochen Yang, Mouhamad Diallo, KyuJung Jun, Grace Wei, Matthew J. McDermott, Andrea Giunto, Tara Mishra, Fengyu Shen, David Milsted, May Sabai Oo, Haegyeom Kim, Michael C. Tucker, Gerbrand Ceder (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-03165.txt.

Introduction

Lauren Walters and a large team of co-authors survey a sodium superionic conductor family for solid-state batteries. Their paper from twenty twenty-five studies the NAP framework, a phosphate structure with room for swapped cations. New frameworks can beat edits of old ones, with fresh diffusion paths and traits. The parent phase first gets a close look: loose phonons warp its shape and flip its conduction at heat.

Computation screens swapped candidates for stability, ease of making, and fast ion flow. Machine-learned potentials widen the sweep. Several candidates pass all three bars. Bench trials on one tin-based member then expose how hard these phosphates are to cook by solid-state routes. Method tuning follows. The authors call NAP a tunable frame that heat effects had hidden from view.

Catalog record

CREATORLauren N. Walters, Yuxing Fei, Bernardus Rendy, Xiaochen Yang, Mouhamad Diallo, KyuJung Jun, Grace Wei, Matthew J. McDermott, Andrea Giunto, Tara Mishra, Fengyu Shen, David Milsted, May Sabai Oo, Haegyeom Kim, Michael C. Tucker, Gerbrand Ceder
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE99 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-03165

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Synthetic accessibility and sodium ion conductivity of the Na 8-x A x P 2 O 9 (NAP) high-temperature sodium superionic conductor framework Lauren N. Walters, Yuxing Fei, Bernardus Rendy, Xiaochen Yang, Mouhamad Diallo, KyuJung Jun, Grace Wei, Matthew J. McDermott, Andrea Giunto, Tara Mishra, Fengyu Shen, David Milsted, May Sabai Oo, Haegyeom Kim, Michael C. Tucker, Gerbrand Ceder Abstract Advancement of solid state electrolytes (SSEs) for all solid state batteries typically focuses on modification of a parent structural framework for improved conductivity, e.g. cation substitution for an immobile ion or varying the concentration of the mobile ion. Therefore, novel frameworks can be disruptive by enabling fast ion conduction aided by different structure and diffusion mechanisms, and unlocking optimal conductors with different properties ( e.g. mechanical properties, sintering needs, electrochemical stability) than previously published. Herein, we perform a high throughput survey of an understudied structural framework for sodium ion conduction, Na 8-x A x P 2 O 9 (NAP), to understand the family’s thermodynamic stability, synthesizability, and ionic conduction. We first show that the parent phase Na 4 TiP 2 O 9 (NTP) undergoes a structural distortion (with accompanying conductivity transition) due to unstable phonons from a pseduo-Jahn Teller mode in the 1D titanium chains. Then, screening of cation-substituted structural candidates with ab initio and machine-learned potential calculations reveal a number of candidates that are thermodynamically stable, likely synthesizable, and have high predicted ionic conductivities. High throughput experimental trials and subsequent methodology optimization of one Na 4 SnP 2 O 9 (NSP) highlight collective challenges to the synthesis pathways for sodium phosphate materials via solid state synthesis. Our results demonstrate that NAP is a highly tunable conduction framework whose high temperature conductivity transition has heretofore eliminated it from significant research interest. By expanding the structural toolkit for SSE design, we increase the number of useful sodium ion electrolytes for integration into safe and accessible solid state batteries. I Introduction First principles design of new solid state electrolytes (SSEs) often incorporates structural framework that are engineered to allow for fast ion conductivity. When new frameworks are reported, they are dissected, categorized, and integrated into high-throughput studies to understand the conductivity pathway and diffusion mechanisms, and how these might be optimized. For lithium SSEs, the significant number of frameworks have allowed studies to distill key features and design principles utilizing high-throughput materials screening and machine learning-based approaches Wang et al. 2024a ; Ma and Li 2024 ; Famprikis et al. 2019 ; Zhang et al. 2018 ; Jun et al. 2022 ; Xiao et al. 2021 ; He et al. 2019 ; Jun et al. 2024 ; Kang et al. 2023 ; Zhang et al. 2019 . However, rational development of sodium and other non-lithium ionic conductors is impeded by the relatively smaller pool of reported examples to draw from, and the only handful of studies that have attempted to featurize the frameworks Wang et al. 2023a ; Park et al. 2024 . Therefore, uncovering a single new framework provides a key additional data point for the computational modeling and machine learning studies necessary for data driven sodium SSE development. The NTP superionic conductor class was first introduced by T. Takahashi, et al. at the International Conference on Solid State Electrolytes in 1981 T. Takahashi 1981 (visualized in Figure 1 ). Subsequent studies were released in the 1980s and 1990s to clarify the structure of the low and high-temperature polymorphs, and verify a one-order-of-magnitude change in conductivity upon phase transition near 250 ∘ C Maximov et al. 1994 ; Matsajuki et al. 1983 ; Maximov et al. 1999 ; Klokova et al. 1993 ; Bolotina et al. 1993 ; Bolotina et al. 1995 . The framework presented in NTP falls into a general formula Na 8-x A x P 2 O 9 (NAP) and is composed of large, highly-coordinated sodium cages pinned by 1D cation chains. Despite the initial success and ease of synthesis of the original NTP structure, there are only handful of other reported cation substituted NAP phases A.K. Ivanov-Shits 1990 ; Duan and Li 2019 ; Maximov et al. 1999 . However, no studies known to the authors describe detailed the mechanism behind the structural or conductivity transitions, underscoring the limited knowledge and research activity on NTP, despite its high ionic mobility. Moreover, within the original Google set, only a handful of materials were found that had low activation energies for sodium ion diffusion, and NTP had one of the lowest. The lack of reported structural and conductivity investigations, particularly with modern first principles calculations, in conjunction a narrow understanding of the chemical flexibility of the structure, demands an immediate and broad survey of the NAP framework. Historically, investigation of new materials represents a bottleneck towards accelerating new phase discovery; trial-and-error-based experimental synthesis development is limited by time, resources, and expertise, with no guarantee of success. Meanwhile, as new materials are predicted, critical a priori questions for emerging materials families include synthesizability and properties of prospective phases. However, output from first principles calculations and machine learning models can fail to reflect the structures and properties of real-world samples. This gap in knowledge between computationally predicted and experimentally realized results limits the scope that ambitious computational research can reasonably tackle. To address this challenge, the integrated use of computational and experimental tools such as open-access material databases, machine-learned potentials, synthesis science models, and self-driving labs is essential. Feedback between these different strategies fosters more efficient sampling of materials spaces. Moreover, the culmination of positive and negative results can paint a more complete picture of the materials discovery process, introducing new insights towards the synthesis development and phase characterization processes. We here conduct a survey of the NAP framework to report key components necessary for development, including thermodynamic stability, synthesizability, conductivity predictions and measurements, and the sodium diffusion pathway. Experimental synthesis attempts of 3+, 4+, and 5+ cation substitutions yields successful synthesis of one new material, Na 4 SnP 2 O 9 (NSP). A closer look into the physics behind previously reported NTP gives crucial insight into why NAPs have a sudden drop in ionic conductivity upon distortion to lower temperature phase, and what modifications might be necessary to suppress this transition. II Methods II.1 Experimental Methods II.1.1 Solid state synthesis Reactions were completed with traditional, powdered solid state (ceramic) synthesis. Reagents were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich (Millipore Sigma) and BeanTown Chemical at generally 98% or greater purity. Due to the significant number of reagents used, the full list of precursors used, CAS numbers, manufacturer, and purity are included in the Supplemental Materials. As sodium pyrophosphate is purchased as hydrated \text{Na}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\smash[t]{\text{4}}}\text{P}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\smash[t]{\text{2}}}\text{O}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\smash[t]{\text{7}}} \cdot 10 \text{H}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\smash[t]{\text{2}}}\text{O} , it is heated for at least 24 hours at 70 ∘ C under vacuum to remove crystal water before use. For all syntheses, stoichiometric amounts of reagent are weighed within a 0.1% threshold and then mixed in air. Mixing is done via either wet (ball) milling, pestle and mortar grinding, or dry ball milling. Wet (ball) milling is carried out as described by Z. Lun, et al. Lun et al. 2020 First, a slurry is made by spin mixing ethanol and precursors together in plastic vial with 10 zirconia balls for 10 minutes within a Hauschild Speedmixer machine

Read the complete text