Fundamentals of Antenna Bandwidth and Quality Factor
Arthur D. Yaghjian · 2025
Read Fundamentals of Antenna Bandwidth and Quality Factor by Arthur D. Yaghjian (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-03146.txt.
Introduction
Arthur Yaghjian lays out the basics of antenna bandwidth and quality factor, the measure of how sharply an antenna resonates. He derives solid expressions for a version based on input impedance that pins down an antenna's bandwidth for isolated resonances.
For antennas with several closely spaced resonances, he gives a formula for the fractional bandwidth that Bode-Fano tuning can win. Methods follow for computing quality factors from circuit models of the antenna. New field-based quality factors, computed from the antenna's fields, prove strikingly robust. They agree with the impedance version whenever impedance is known, and they ignore arbitrary choices like the coordinate origin or extra transmission line. With them he derives lower bounds on quality factor for spherical-mode antennas, beating the Chu and Collin-Rothschild limits, and maps maximum gain against minimum quality factor. A criterion for supergain antennas also emerges.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Arthur D. Yaghjian |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 109 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-03146
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Fundamentals of Antenna Bandwidth and Quality Factor Arthur D. Yaghjian Abstract After a brief history of the development of quality factor, useful expressions are derived for the robust 𝑸 𝒁 ( 𝝎 ) Q_{Z}({\omega}) quality factor that accurately determines the VSWR input-impedance fractional bandwidth of antennas for isolated resonances and a small enough bandwidth power drop. For closely spaced multiple resonances/antiresonances, a definitive formula is given for the increase in fractional bandwidth enabled by Bode-Fano tuning. Methods are given for determining the conventional and complex-energy quality factors of antennas from RLC circuit models. New field-based quality factors 𝑸 ( 𝝎 ) Q({\omega}) are derived for antennas with known fields produced by an input current. These 𝑸 ( 𝝎 ) Q({\omega}) are remarkably robust because they equal 𝑸 𝒁 ( 𝝎 ) Q_{Z}({\omega}) when the input impedance is available. Like 𝑸 𝒁 ( 𝝎 ) Q_{Z}({\omega}) , the field-based 𝑸 ( 𝝎 ) Q({\omega}) is independent of the choice of origin of the antenna fields and is impervious to extra lengths of transmission lines and surplus reactances. These robust field-based quality factors are used to derive new lower bounds on the quality factors (upper bounds on the bandwidths) of spherical-mode antennas that improve upon the previous Chu/CR (Collin-Rothschild) lower bounds for spherical modes. A criterion for antenna supergain is found by combining the Harrington maximum gain formula with the recently derived formula for the reactive power boundaries of antennas. Maximum gain versus minimum quality factor for spherical antennas are determined using the improved lower bounds on quality factor for different values of electrical size 𝒌 𝒂 ka . Lastly, reduced antenna quality factors allowed by dispersive tuning overcome the traditional Chu/CR lower bounds for lower radiation efficiencies and small enough bandwidth power drops. I Historical Introduction The concept of quality factor in electrical engineering appears to have originated circa 1914 with the “inductive purity” K={\omega}L/R defined at the angular frequency {\omega} by K.S. Johnson for lossy coils with inductance L and resistance R [ 1 , 2 ] . In 1918, the Circular 74 of the United States Bureau of Standards used the expression {\omega}L/R to define the ‘‘sharpness of resonance’’ 1 1 1 When an initially open series RLC circuit with a charged capacitor is closed, the voltages and currents “ring” or “resonate” with damped oscillations (for R not too large) at a “natural” frequency close to the tuned frequency {\omega}\!=\!\!1/\sqrt{LC} of the RLC circuit; thus the term “resonant frequency” for {\omega}\! [ 3 ] . of a series RLC circuit but without referring to it as quality factor or Q [ 3 ] . By 1920, Johnson had changed the “overworked” symbol K to Q , which was not initially an abbreviation for “quality” or “quality factor”, a term first used for Johnson’s symbol Q by his colleague V.E. Legg at Bell Telephone Laboratories that became popular after about 1925. In his 1932 book, F.E. Terman, the “father of Silicon Valley”, was apparently the first to note that the quality factor for a series RLC resonance could be expressed as Q_{\scriptscriptstyle\rm RLC}={\omega}W_{\scriptscriptstyle\rm LC}/P_{\scriptscriptstyle\rm R} , where W_{\scriptscriptstyle\rm LC} is the total average energy stored in the fields of the inductor plus capacitor and P_{\scriptscriptstyle\rm R} is the average power dissipated in the resistor. Moreover, Terman proved that the -3 dB conductance fractional bandwidth of a series RLC circuit about its resonant frequency is equal to the inverse of the quality factor, namely 1/Q_{\scriptscriptstyle\rm RLC} [half the voltage-standing-wave-ratio (VSWR) fractional bandwidth] [ 4 , 5 ] . Although not as universally applicable to antennas as VSWR fractional bandwidth, the conductance fractional bandwidth for series RLC circuits, or resistance bandwidth for parallel RLC circuits, has the advantage of not requiring the introduction of a single-mode feed waveguide with a terminal surface (port) and a characteristic impedance [ 5 , 6 ] . The present paper concentrates on the fundamentals of antenna bandwidth and quality factor with emphasis on the derivation and applicability of the VSWR impedance-bandwidth quality factor Q_{Z}({\omega}) , as well as on the generalized complex “Q-energy” from which a new improved field-based quality factor Q({\omega}) is derived that has the same robust accuracy and applicability as Q_{Z}({\omega}) . The recently discovered technique, based on the complex Q-energy, for the dispersive tuning of antennas is highlighted as a practical means to overcome the traditional Chu lower bounds on quality factors. There have been relatively few significant advancements in the fundamentals of antenna bandwidth and quality factor since the seminal papers of Wheeler [ 7 ] , Chu [ 8 ] , Collin-Rothschild [ 9 ] , and Fante [ 10 ] , as opposed to the many papers that have been published on applying, evaluating, and optimizing the fundamental expressions for the bandwidths and quality factors of different classes and designs of antennas. There have been a number of noteworthy review papers within this derivative area of antenna research, including review articles on the physical bounds and stored energies of antennas and other radiating systems [ 11 ] , [ 12 ] . Nevertheless, the present paper confines itself to the more fundamental developments of antenna bandwidth and quality factor. I-A RLC Circuit Approximation for the Impedance and Quality Factor of Antennas The quality factors for linear, passive, time invariant, transmitting 2 2 2 The bandwidth of a receiving antenna is limited only by the signal to noise ratio of the output amplifiers and the noise in the input signal to the antenna. Several papers have been written on the receiving bandwidth of antennas, for example, [ 13 , 14 , 15 ] , and thus receiving antennas are not treated in the present paper. Also, nonFoster matching and time-varying antennas, both of which require active networks, are not considered herein. antennas, fed by a voltage V and current I across a terminal-pair (or port of a single-mode waveguide) and tuned to an isolated resonance or antiresonance, can be found by simply approximating the input impedance (resistance R and reactance X ) of the antenna near the resonance ( dX/d{\omega}>0 ) or antiresonance ( dX/d{\omega}<0 ) with a series or parallel RLC circuit, respectively, provided the input impedance Z=V/I=R+jX of the antenna is known as a function of frequency. (Time-harmonic e^{j{\omega}t} ( {\omega}>0 ) dependence is used throughout.) That is, the quality factor of the tuned antenna can be approximated by Q_{\scriptscriptstyle\rm RLC}={\omega}L/R=1/({\omega}CR) for a resonance and Q_{\scriptscriptstyle\rm RLC}=R/({\omega}L)={\omega}CR for an antiresonance, respectively, where L and C can be found from the value of dX({\omega})/d{\omega} for the tuned antenna along with the relationship {\omega}^{2}LC=1 ( {\omega}>0 ), and R is the resistance at the resonant or antiresonant frequency. Then the -3 dB conductance (or resistance) fractional bandwidth, which does not require a feed waveguide with a characteristic impedance for its definition (just a terminal-pair), is given approximately as 1/Q_{\scriptscriptstyle\rm RLC} for a resonance (or antiresonance). 3 3 3 For |dR({\omega})/d{\omega}|\!\!\ll\!\!|dX({\omega})/d{\omega}| , the \alpha power-drop fractional conductance bandwidth, FCBW_{\alpha}({\omega})=2\Delta{\omega}/{\omega} , for a fixed input voltage applied to the antenna is determined approximately at the tuned resonant frequency {\omega} [ X({\omega})=0,dX({\omega})/d{\omega}>0 ] from the solutions to the equation [ 5 ] {\rm Re}[1/Z({\omega}\pm\Delta{\omega})]=\frac{R({\omega})}{R^{2}({\omega})+X^{2}({\omega}\pm\Delta{\omega})}=\frac{1-\alpha}{R({\omega})}\\ (1) to