Dynamical de Sitter conjecture and quintessence

Muneto Nitta a,b,c, Kunihito Uzawa d,b · 2025

Read Dynamical de Sitter conjecture and quintessence by Muneto Nitta a,b,c, Kunihito Uzawa d,b (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-02258.txt.

Introduction

Muneto Nitta and Kunihito Uzawa wrote in 2025 about a proposed rule that limits what kinds of universes a theory of quantum gravity can allow. The rule, tied to de Sitter space, puts a harsh bound on allowed settings. They asked what happens when the motion of the driving field is taken into account, not just its resting values.

They extended the rule to cover that motion and applied it to a model of cosmic inflation driven by a slow field. The allowed range of settings came out wider than under the older rule. The authors note the wider bounds could matter for building models that pack extra dimensions into small spaces.

Catalog record

CREATORMuneto Nitta a,b,c, Kunihito Uzawa d,b
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-02258

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Dynamical de Sitter conjecture and quintessence Muneto Nitta a,b,c, Kunihito Uzawa d,b Abstract The de Sitter conjecture yields a severe bound on possible vacua for a consistent quantum gravity. We extend the de Sitter conjecture by taking into account dynamics of the scalar field. We then apply such an extended de Sitter conjecture to a quintessence model of inflation for which dynamics of the scalar field is essential, and obtain an allowed region of parameters of the scalar potential wider than previously considered cases with the conventional de Sitter conjecture. The new bounds in the swampland conjecture could have implications in several situations to construct compactification models. pacs 04.50.-h, 11.25.Mj, 98.80.Cq, 95.36.+x I Introduction String theory is one of the candidates for quantum field theories consistent with theory of gravity. Since it is defined in higher-dimensional spacetimes, a compactification process becomes necessary to ensure compatibility with our four-dimensional universe. Each compactification represents a different low-energy effective field theory in four dimensions, which generates what is called the “landscape” of string theory Susskind:2003kw ; Banks:2003es ; Denef:2004ze ; Kallosh:2004yh ; Vafa:2005ui ; Denef:2008wq ; Brennan:2017rbf ; vanBeest:2021lhn ; Grana:2021zvf ; Agmon:2022thq . Although the four-dimensional quantum field theory describing the standard model of particle physics has succeeded in explaining various interactions, it is also true that numerous problems remain in field theories beyond the standard model, such as the need for parameter fine-tuning to determine coupling constants and particle masses. In recent developments of string theory, it has been suggested that not all quantum field theories are necessarily consistent with gravitational theories, and there exist conditions for four-dimensional field theories to be gravitationally consistent. Field theories that do not satisfy these conditions are referred to as residing in the “swampland” Vafa:2005ui ; Ooguri:2006in ; Ooguri:2016pdq ; Brennan:2017rbf ; Obied:2018sgi ; Agrawal:2018own ; Ooguri:2018wrx ; Andriot:2018wzk ; Palti:2019pca ; Bedroya:2019snp ; Agmon:2022thq . Some solutions to higher-dimensional string theories become theories within the landscape through compactification, while others become theories residing outside the landscape, i.e., in the swampland. The latter are no longer consistent with gravitational theories. The classification of quantum field theories consistent with quantum gravity potentially provides powerful theoretical tools, offering strategies to resolve fine-tuning problems Heckman:2019bzm and enabling predictions about cosmological observations by clarifying the swampland region, such as the dynamics of early universe inflation and the nature of dark energy Agrawal:2019dlm ; Bedroya:2019snp ; Vafa:2019evj ; McNamara:2020uza ; vanBeest:2021lhn ; Agmon:2022thq . Although string theory might provide the field theory of the standard model of particle physics, no one knows the full extent of the landscape. If the landscape were to encompass all quantum field theories, string theory would find it challenging to provide insights into field theories beyond the standard model. However, we cannot obtain the low-energy limits of all string-theory compactifications, and it is becoming increasingly clear that numerous field theories exist outside the landscape Vafa:2005ui ; Palti:2019pca . Consequently, the most critical issue in current string theory is determining the boundary between the landscape and the swampland. However, given the countless possible compactifications of string theory, definitively establishing this boundary is not straightforward Brennan:2017rbf . Therefore, there are systematic investigations of reliable compactifications that provide realistic four-dimensional universe models and standard model consistent with observations and experiments, empirically confirming the characteristics of four-dimensional field theories they share. From these data, studies are developing to hypothesize criteria for determining which field theories belong to the landscape or swampland and to define the boundary between them Brennan:2017rbf ; Palti:2019pca ; Bedroya:2019snp . As an example of determining such a boundary, the so-called de Sitter conjecture has been proposed.This conjecture addresses the possibility that the de Sitter vacuum becomes part of the swampland in the quantum field theory under consideration, and it is derived from the field equations and energy conditions of string theory Obied:2018sgi . The de Sitter conjecture is further supported by discussions of distance conjectures related to the de Sitter spacetime entropy and the dynamics of extra dimensions Ooguri:2018wrx . For instance, as extra dimensions increase in size, light particles emerge on the four-dimensional spacetime Ooguri:2006in , and their contributions impact the dynamics of early universe inflation. These new particles are colloquially referred to as the “tower of light states” Ooguri:2006in and play a role in constraining inflationary models Agrawal:2018own ; Garg:2018reu . The de Sitter conjecture provides constraints on the low-energy effective theories of consistent quantum gravitational theories, and these constraints (that is, the criteria for determining whether a theory belongs to the landscape or swampland) stem from the current accelerating expansion of the universe. In other words, the low-energy effective theories derived from consistent quantum gravity theories are evaluated on the basis of whether they can reproduce the observed accelerating universe and the inflation of the early universe without contradiction. The criteria determine whether a quantum field theory resides in the landscape or in the swampland. Naturally, if a low-energy effective theory realizes a meta-stable de Sitter vacuum Kachru:2003aw ; Kachru:2003sx and accelerated expansion at the present universe, it would be considered part of the landscape. Conversely, if it fails to do so, the four-dimensional quantum field theory would be deemed to reside in the swampland Obied:2018sgi ; Andriot:2018wzk ; Garg:2018reu ; Palti:2019pca . The de Sitter conjecture gives a lower bound on the gradient of potentials in positive regions Obied:2018sgi . The scalar potential of a theory coupled to gravity have to satisfy a bound on its derivatives with respect to scalar fields |\nabla V|>c\,V\,, (1) where c>0 is of order 1 in Planck units. The number c generally depends on the number of dimensions of background space-time and internal space. This bound on \left|\nabla V\right|/V for compactifications of string theory is in fact a consequence of strong energy condition (SEC) in higher dimensions and field equations. The criteria can be derived by a simple generalization of Maldacena & Nuñez Maldacena:2000mw and Steinhardt-Wesley Steinhardt:2008nk no-go theorems that one can place a bound on the gradient of the potential. As mentioned above, the de Sitter conjecture is fundamentally constructed based on the field equations of the original higher-dimensional theory, the low-energy effective theory obtained after compactification, and the SEC Obied:2018sgi . In this process, the time derivative of the scalar field is set to zero. The scalar field represents the moduli in the higher-dimensional theory, corresponding to the scale of the internal space, is fixed Obied:2018sgi . If the scalar field coming from moduli triggers an inflaton, the condition of dropping off the time derivative would be consistent with the slow-roll condition of inflation. The early universe inflationary expansion are achieved by the dynamics of scalar fields, particularly through scalar fields which possess minimum or local minimum in their potential Kachru:2003aw ; Kachru:2003sx . The potential energy at these minima or local minima of scalar fields is equivalent to a positive cosmological constant in four-dimensional effective theories, thus leading to stable or meta-stable de Sitter spacetimes. In string theory, there are numerous efforts to make stable or meta-stable de Sitter vacua Kachru:2003aw ; Kachru:2003sx , but an overwhelming number of problems still have emerged. Within the issues of reproducing stable or meta-stable de Sitter vacua in string theory, recent proposals have focused on

Read the complete text