Extensions of a theorem of P. Hall on indexes of maximal subgroups
Antonio Beltrán Departamento de Matemáticas Universitat Jaume I 12071 Castellón Spain Changguo Shao College of Science Nanjing University of Posts and Telecommunications Nanjing 210023 Yadong China · 2025
Read Extensions of a theorem of P. Hall on indexes of maximal subgroups by Antonio Beltrán Departamento de Matemáticas Universitat Jaume I 12071 Castellón Spain Changguo Shao College of Science Nanjing University of Posts and Telecommunications Nanjing 210023 Yadong China (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-02249.txt.
Introduction
Antonio Beltrán and Changguo Shao extend a classic theorem of P. Hall about finite groups, in this two thousand twenty-five paper. Hall showed that if every maximal subgroup sits inside the whole group with an index that is a prime or a prime squared, then the group is solvable.
The authors loosen the condition in two directions and still reach solvability. First, maximal subgroups may instead simply be nilpotent, a strongly orderly kind of subgroup. Second, the same conclusion holds when every smaller non-maximal subgroup lies inside some subgroup of prime or prime-squared index. Results like these map exactly which structural clues force a finite group to be solvable, a basic question in group theory.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Antonio Beltrán Departamento de Matemáticas Universitat Jaume I 12071 Castellón Spain Changguo Shao College of Science Nanjing University of Posts and Telecommunications Nanjing 210023 Yadong China |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 22 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-02249
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Extensions of a theorem of P. Hall on indexes of maximal subgroups Thanks: Antonio Beltrán: [email protected] ORCID ID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6570-201X Changguo Shao: [email protected] ORCID ID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3865-0573 Antonio Beltrán Departamento de Matemáticas Universitat Jaume I 12071 Castellón Spain Changguo Shao College of Science Nanjing University of Posts and Telecommunications Nanjing 210023 Yadong China Abstract . We extend a classical theorem of P. Hall that claims that if the index of every maximal subgroup of a finite group G G is a prime or the square of a prime, then G G is solvable. Precisely, we prove that if one allows, in addition, the possibility that every maximal subgroup of G G is nilpotent instead of having prime or squared-prime index, then G G continues to be solvable. Likewise, we obtain the solvability of G G when we assume that every proper non-maximal subgroup of G G lies in some subgroup of index prime or squared prime. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification 20E28, 20D15, 20D06 1. Introduction A well-known theorem of P. Hall [ 13 , 9.4.1] establishes that if the index of every maximal subgroup of a finite group G is a prime number or the square of a prime number, then G is solvable. First, we extend this result by allowing maximal subgroups of G the possibility of being nilpotent too, so we obtain the following solvability criterion. Theorem A . If every maximal subgroup of a finite group G either is nilpotent or has index a prime or the square of a prime, then G is solvable. We note that Theorem A also extends other recent results [ 10 , 14 ] that demonstrate, among other properties, the solvability of those groups whose non-nilpotent maximal subgroups have prime index. Our proof of Theorem A is quite elementary; it basically utilizes the p -nilpotency criterion of Glauberman and Thompson for an odd prime p [ 6 , Satz IV.6.2] . It is worth mentioning that another extension of Hall’s theorem was given in [ 11 ] . It was proved that when every proper non-maximal subgroup of a group G lies in a subgroup of prime index, then G is solvable. Indeed, it turns out that G/{\bf F}(G) is supersolvable, where {\bf F}(G) denotes the Fitting subgroup of G . We go a step further, by obtaining the following solvability criterion that also generalizes Hall’s Theorem. Theorem B . Let G be a finite group. If every proper non-maximal subgroup of G is contained in some subgroup whose index is a prime or the square of a prime, then G is solvable. The proof of Theorem B, however, relies on several results depending on the Classification of Finite Simple Groups, among others, Guralnick’s classification of simple groups having a prime power index subgroup. We also need to do a detailed analysis on certain simple groups that requires the knowledge of the structure of maximal subgroups of several nonabelian simple groups, for which we will appeal to different sources [ 2 , 4 , 6 , 9 ] . We also remark that there are no more ways to extend Theorem B in the sense that no more possible prime-powers can be included in the assumptions of Theorem B so as to get a new solvability criterion. It suffices to take into account that every maximal subgroup of the simple group {\rm PSL}_{2}(7) has index 7 or 8 , so every proper non-maximal subgroup lies in a subgroup whose index is prime or the cube of a prime. On the other hand, for proving Theorem B we first need to establish a classification of nonabelian simple groups having a squared prime index subgroup. This result has interest on its own and we are not aware that has already been published. Theorem C . Let S be a finite nonabelian simple group that has a subgroup of index q^{2} with q prime. Then one of the following holds (a) S\cong{\rm Alt}(q^{2}) with subgroups of index q^{2} (q\geq 3) , or (b) S\cong{\rm PSL}_{2}(8) with subgroups of index 3^{2} , or (c) S\cong{\rm PSL}_{5}(3) with subgroups of index 11^{2} . Throughout this paper, all groups are supposed to be finite, and we follow standard notation (e.g. [ 13 ] ). 2. Preliminaries We start with an application of Glauberman-Thompson’s p -nilpotency criterion for an odd prime p mentioned in the Introduction, which is useful for our purposes. We stress, however, that the following lemma is not true for p=2 : the Mathieu group M_{10}\cong{\rm Alt}(6).2 , with a minimal normal subgroup isomorphic to {\rm Alt}(6) , which is maximal too, is an example of it because every maximal subgroup of M_{10} distinct from {\rm Alt}(6) is 2 -nilpotent. Lemma 2.1 . Let G be a finite group and N minimal normal subgroup of G that is not solvable. Let p be any odd prime dividing |N| and P a Sylow p -subgroup of N . Then there exists a maximal subgroup in G such that contains {\bf N}_{G}(P) , does not contain N , and is not p -nilpotent. Proof. Notice that N must be a direct product of isomorphic nonabelian simple groups. Let p an odd prime divisor of |N| and let P\neq 1 be a Sylow p -subgroup of N . Let J(P)\neq 1 be the Thompson subgroup of P (see [ 6 , IV.6.1.] for a definition). Clearly {\bf Z}(J(P)) is not normal in G since cannot be normal in N , and accordingly, {\bf N}_{G}({\bf Z}(J(P))) is a proper subgroup of G lying in some maximal subgroup, say M , of G . Now, if M is p -nilpotent, so is {\bf N}_{N}({\bf Z}(J(P))) . By Glauberman-Thompson’s criterion, N is p -nilpotent too (with p dividing |N| ), which contradicts the non-solvability of N . Hence, M is not p -nilpotent. On the other hand, the Frattini argument gives {\bf N}_{G}(P)N=G , and moreover, since {\bf Z}(J(P)) is characteristic in P , we have {\bf N}_{G}(P)\leq{\bf N}_{G}({\bf Z}(J(P)))\leq M, so we conclude that M does not contain N either. Thus, the lemma is proved. ∎ We need the following property concerning the structure of certain subgroups of direct products of nonabelian simple groups. Lemma 2.2 . [ 12 , Lemma 2.4] Let G be a finite group and N a minimal normal subgroup of G such that N=S_{1}\times\cdots\times S_{t}, with t\geq 1 and S_{i} are isomorphic nonabelian simple groups. Assume that H is a maximal subgroup of G such that G=HN . Set K=H\cap N . Then one of the following holds: (1) K=K_{1}\times\cdots\times K_{t} , where K_{i}<S_{i} for all i , and H acts transitively on the set \{K_{1},\cdots,K_{t}\} . (2) K=A_{1}\times\cdots\times A_{k} is minimal normal in H , where A_{1}\cong\cdots\cong A_{k}\cong S_{1} , k\mid t and k<t , and every nonidentity element of A_{i} has length t/k under the decomposition. Our proofs are based on the classic Guralnick’s classification mentioned in the Introduction, which we state here for the reader’s convenience. Lemma 2.3 . [ 5 , Theorem 1] Let G be a nonabelian simple group with H<G and |G:H|=p^{a} , p prime. One of the following holds. (a) G={\rm Alt}(n) , and H\cong{\rm Alt}(n-1) , with n=p^{a} .