Nuclear quantum effects slow down the energy transfer in biological light-harvesting complexes
Johan E. Runeson, David E. Manolopoulos · 2025
Read Nuclear quantum effects slow down the energy transfer in biological light-harvesting complexes by Johan E. Runeson, David E. Manolopoulos (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-02212.txt.
Introduction
Johan Runeson and David Manolopoulos wrote a paper from 2025 on how plants and bacteria catch light and move its energy. Inside them, color molecules pass energy along in steps, while their atoms jiggle. The pair asked whether the quantum side of that jiggling speeds the energy flow or slows it.
They built a mixed model, then added the quantum side of fast jiggling and checked it against full quantum sums. In three real light-harvesting systems, the quantum jiggling slowed the flow in two of them. In the third, the speed was much the same. The final spread of energy came out the same either way. The pair says the slowdown grows when energy gaps and jiggle links are large.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Johan E. Runeson, David E. Manolopoulos |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-02212
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Nuclear quantum effects slow down the energy transfer in biological light-harvesting complexes Johan E. Runeson, David E. Manolopoulos Abstract We assess how quantum-mechanical effects associated with high-frequency chromophore vibrations influence excitation energy transfer in biological light-harvesting complexes. We begin with a mixed quantum-classical theory that combines a quantum description of the electronic motion with a classical description of the nuclear motion in a way that is consistent with the quantum-classical equilibrium distribution. We then include nuclear quantum effects in this theory with a variational polaron transformation of the high frequency vibrational modes. This approach is validated by comparison with fully quantum mechanical benchmark calculations and then applied to three prototypical biological light-harvesting complexes. We find that high-frequency vibrations delay the energy transfer in the quantum treatment, but accelerate it in the classical treatment. For the inter-ring transfer in the light-harvesting complex 2 of purple bacteria, the transfer rate is a factor of 1.5 times slower in the quantum treatment than the classical. The transfer timescale in the Fenna–Matthews–Olson complex is essentially the same in both cases, whereas the transfer in light-harvesting complex II of spinach is 1.7 times slower in the quantum treatment. In all cases, the quantum mechanical long-time equilibrium populations of the chromophores are well reproduced by the classical treatment, suggesting that nuclear quantum effects are generally unimportant for the directionality of energy transfer. Nuclear quantum effects do however reduce the transfer rate in systems with large excitonic energy gaps and strong vibronic coupling to high-frequency vibrational modes. Introduction Photosynthesis is a process of fundamental importance to life on earth and a source of inspiration for the development of solar fuels. However, there are still some aspects of its mechanism that are open to debate, including the long-standing question of whether biological light harvesting exhibits any quantum effects. [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] For almost two decades, this debate focused on the interpretation of oscillatory signals observed in nonlinear electronic spectroscopy experiments. [ 4 ] These signals were originally attributed to inter-exciton coherences, but a concensus has now emerged that they have a more straightforward vibrational or vibronic origin. [ 5 , 6 ] In recent years, the debate has therefore shifted to consider the quantum effects associated with the vibrations themselves, [ 7 ] which we shall refer to here as “nuclear quantum effects”. Our goal in this article is to contribute to the debate by comparing classical and quantum treatments of the vibrational modes in explicit simulations of the energy transfer in biological light-harvesting complexes. On the one hand, a series of recent articles have argued that nuclear quantum effects are essential for the function of photosynthetic antenna complexes. For a vibronic model of the light harvesting complex 2 (LH2) in purple bacteria, Kundu and Makri [ 7 ] found that a classical treatment of vibrations provided a poor description of exciton equilibration compared to a fully quantum treatment, which led them to conclude that quantum nuclear motion is necessary for the correct flow of energy. Similar statements have been made by other authors, [ 8 , 9 , 10 ] and two recent reviews [ 5 , 6 ] have identified nuclear quantum effects as responsible for the existence of an energy funnel and therefore for the directionality of energy transfer. On the other hand, numerous simulations with classical nuclei have been shown to be consistent with the exact quantum dynamics of models of the Fenna–Matthews–Olson (FMO) complex of green sulfur bacteria, [ 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 ] suggesting that nuclear quantum effects do not play any role in its energy transfer. Hence the literature is still divided on the issue. To explain why this is, we first need to clarify what we mean by a nuclear quantum effect in the present context. Light-harvesting complexes enable efficient excitation energy transfer through an interplay of dipolar coupling between chromophores and vibronic coupling to nuclear motion. In a fully quantum description, the nuclear degrees of freedom are quantized in the same way as the excitonic degrees of freedom. However, fully quantum dynamics is computationally demanding and only possible for simple model systems, which has motivated the development of approaches that treat the nuclear degrees of freedom classically. An important issue here is that the classical treatment is not unique. Some classical formulations are better justified than others, and different approaches can be more or less accurate in comparison to the quantum description. So only when the best available classical treatment is unable to reproduce the quantum result does it make sense to identify a quantum effect. Such an identification indicates the level of theory that is required – or sufficient – to accurately describe the phenomenon. If one can reproduce the quantum result with a classical simulation then there is no quantum effect. The standard quantum description of exciton energy transfer is based on the model Hamiltonian H=H_{\mathrm{s}}+H_{\mathrm{b}}+H_{\mathrm{sb}} , where H_{\mathrm{s}} is the Hamiltonian of the excitonic system, H_{\mathrm{b}} that of a vibrational bath, and H_{\mathrm{sb}} that of the system-bath interaction. In a basis of locally excited chromophores (or ‘sites’), the first term is written as H_{\mathrm{s}}=\sum_{n}\varepsilon_{n}|n\rangle\langle n|+\sum_{n\neq m}J_{nm}|n\rangle\langle m|, (1) where \varepsilon_{n} are the site energies and J_{nm} the inter-site couplings. The other terms, H_{\mathrm{b}}=\sum_{nk}\hbar\omega_{k}\left(b_{nk}^{\dagger}b_{nk}+\tfrac{1}{2}\right) (2) H_{\mathrm{sb}}=\sum_{nk}\hbar\omega_{k}g_{k}(b_{nk}^{\dagger}+b_{nk})|n\rangle\langle n|, (3) model how the site energies fluctuate due to interaction with vibrational degrees of freedom with frequencies \omega_{k} and coupling strengths g_{k} . As is customary, we assume that the sites are coupled to identical and independent baths. Typically, one can attribute the high-frequency bath modes to intramolecular vibrations and the low-frequency modes to phonons of the solvent and protein scaffolding. To identify the role of nuclear quantum effects in this model, one first needs to define an appropriate classical limit for the nuclear motion. Based on past literature, it appears that there are many mixed quantum-classical approaches to choose from: surface hopping, [ 17 ] Ehrenfest dynamics, phase-space mappings, [ 18 , 19 ] quantum-classical path integrals, [ 20 ] etc. Each of these methods has its own definition of the force acting on the classical nuclei. The excitonic state-dependent part of this force is the so-called ‘back-action’ of the quantum system on the classical degrees of freedom. As has been discussed elsewhere [ 15 ] , part of the debate about nuclear quantum effects is semantic in the sense that some authors use the term ‘classical’ to mean ‘classical with no back-action’, or ‘classical with disregard for Newton’s third law’. It is well known that no back-action leads to equal long-time populations of all quantum states, an unphysical situation that corresponds to elevating the excitonic system to infinite temperature. Neglecting the back-action is therefore inconsistent with the quantum-classical equilibrium distribution at the temperature of interest. [ 15 ] The quantum mechanical Boltzmann population of site n is \langle|n\rangle\langle n|\rangle=\frac{\mathrm{Tr}_{\mathrm{nuc}}[\mathrm{Tr}_{\mathrm{ex}}[e^{-\beta H}|n\rangle\langle n|]]}{\mathrm{Tr}_{\mathrm{nuc}}[\mathrm{Tr}_{\mathrm{ex}}[e^{-\beta H}]]}, (4) where the labels ‘nuc’ and ‘ex’ refer to the nuclear and excitonic degrees of freedom, respectively. The classical analog of the nuclear trace is obtained by replacing b_{nk}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2\hbar\omega_{k}}}(\omega_{k}q_{nk}+ip_{nk}) and treating (p,q)=(\{p_{nk}\},\{q_{nk}\}) as classical variables. The classical limit of the population then emerges from an average of the excitonic Boltzmann distribution over the nuclear phase