The SLACS strong lens sample debiased. II. Lensing-only constraints on the stellar IMF and dark matter contraction in early-type galaxies

Alessandro Sonnenfeld · 2025

Read The SLACS strong lens sample debiased. II. Lensing-only constraints on the stellar IMF and dark matter contraction in early-type galaxies by Alessandro Sonnenfeld (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-02054.txt.

Introduction

Alessandro Sonnenfeld, writing solo in 2025, reworks a well studied set of galaxy lenses using lensing data alone. The sample comes from a Sloan survey program and is the best studied of its kind. Past work mixed lensing with data on star motion, but reading that motion data needs hard guesses about a galaxy's shape and its stars' orbits.

His lens-only route pairs each lens's ring size with weak lensing data from the parent sample, while correcting for how the sample was picked. The data fit two unlike mixes about as well: one pairs a slightly light star mass scale with no dark matter squeeze, the other a lighter scale with near full squeeze. More lensing data could break the tie.

Catalog record

CREATORAlessandro Sonnenfeld
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-02054

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The SLACS strong lens sample debiased. II. Lensing-only constraints on the stellar IMF and dark matter contraction in early-type galaxies Alessandro Sonnenfeld Abstract The Sloan Lens ACS (SLACS) is the best studied sample of strong lenses to date. Much of our knowledge of the SLACS lenses has been obtained by combining strong lensing with stellar kinematics constraints. However, interpreting stellar kinematics data is difficult: it requires reconstructing the three-dimensional structure of a galaxy and the orbits of its stars. For SLACS, the problem is exacerbated by its selection function, which caused lenses with a larger observed velocity dispersion to be overrepresented. In this work we pursued an alternative approach to the study of galaxy structure with SLACS, based purely on gravitational lensing data. The primary goal of this study is to constrain the stellar population synthesis mismatch parameter α sps \alpha_{\mathrm{sps}} , quantifying the ratio between the true stellar mass of a galaxy and that obtained with a reference stellar population synthesis model, and the efficiency of the dark matter response to the infall of baryons, ϵ \epsilon . We combined Einstein radius measurements from the SLACS lenses with weak lensing information from their parent sample, while accounting for selection effects. The data can be fit comparatively well by a model with log ⁡ α sps = 0.22 \log{\alpha_{\mathrm{sps}}}=0.22 and ϵ = 0 \epsilon=0 , corresponding to an IMF slightly lighter than Salpeter and no dark matter contraction, or log ⁡ α sps = 0 \log{\alpha_{\mathrm{sps}}}=0 and ϵ = 0.8 \epsilon=0.8 , equivalent to a Chabrier IMF and almost maximal contraction. Selection effects, if not modelled, produce a shift in the joint posterior probability that is larger than the uncertainty. The degeneracy between α sps \alpha_{\mathrm{sps}} and ϵ \epsilon could be broken with lensing-only measurements of the projected density slope, but existing data are completely inconsistent with our model. We suspect systematic errors in the measurements to be at the origin of this discrepancy. Number density constraints would also help break the degeneracy. Because of selection effects, SLACS lenses have a larger velocity dispersion than galaxies with the same projected mass distribution, and their velocity dispersion is overestimated. These two biases combined produce a 5 % 5\% upward shift in the observed velocity dispersion. 1 Introduction Strong gravitational lensing is one of the most reliable methods for studying the mass distribution of galaxies: it can provide a measurement of the projected mass of a lens galaxy with a precision and accuracy of a few percent, regardless of the dynamical state of the lens. The best studied sample of lenses so far is the Sloan Lens ACS (SLACS) survey ( Bolton et al., 2006 ) , consisting of about a hundred strong lenses, most of which are massive early-type galaxies. The standard strategy for studying the inner structure of the SLACS lenses has so far been to combine information from strong lensing and stellar kinematics. Joint lensing and stellar dynamics analyses have revealed that SLACS lenses have, on average, a total density profile slightly steeper than isothermal ( Koopmans et al., 2006 ; Auger et al., 2010a ; Barnabè et al., 2011 ) , and that the steepness of the density profile correlates positively with the stellar mass density ( Sonnenfeld et al., 2013 ) . Lensing and dynamics have also been used to determine the relative contribution of stars and dark matter to the total mass budget of massive galaxies ( Treu et al., 2010 ; Auger et al., 2010b ; Sonnenfeld et al., 2015 ; Posacki et al., 2015 ; Shajib et al., 2021 ; Sheu et al., 2024 ) . According to a large part of these investigations, the stars appear to have a relatively large mass-to-light ratio, similar to that predicted by a Salpeter stellar initial mass function (IMF), while the dark matter mass enclosed within the inner regions seems to be smaller than that predicted by numerical simulations ( Shajib et al., 2021 see e.g. Fig. 11 of) . Interpreting the stellar kinematics data of a galaxy is difficult. It requires modelling its three-dimensional mass structure and the orbits of its stars, which are two properties that are not directly observable. While some of the degeneracies affecting dynamical models can be broken with the help of integral field spectroscopic data, for most of the SLACS lenses the only stellar kinematics information currently available comes from Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) single-aperture spectra. This scarcity of spatially resolved spectroscopic data has forced past investigations to rely on simplifying assumptions: nearly all of the studies mentioned above have assumed spherical symmetry, and some of them have asserted orbital isotropy ( Auger et al., 2010a ; Sonnenfeld et al., 2015 ) . One notable exception is the work of Barnabè et al. (2011) , who fitted models with axial symmetry and orbits described by a two-integral distribution function to spatially resolved kinematics data of 16 lenses. Barnabè et al. (2011) modelled the radial density profile of the lenses as a power-law, \rho(r)\propto r^{-\gamma} and measured the density slope \gamma for each of the lenses. Their values of \gamma are systematically lower, by approximately 0.05 , than those obtained by Auger et al. (2010a) with an isotropic spherical Jeans model. Such a discrepancy is larger than the current uncertainty on the average \gamma of the SLACS lens sample, and should therefore warn against assuming spherical symmetry or isotropy when studying the SLACS lenses. The problem of analysing SLACS stellar kinematics data is made worse by selection effects. SLACS lenses were selected on the basis of the observed velocity dispersion ( Bolton et al., 2006 ) . This caused lenses with a larger observed velocity dispersion to be overrepresented, with respect to a purely mass-selected sample ( Sonnenfeld, 2024 ) . In order for a dynamical analysis to accurately capture the mass and orbital structure of a SLACS lens, these selection effects must be taken into account. So far, this has only been done by Sonnenfeld (2024 , hereafter Paper I) , albeit in the simplified context of spherical and isotropic models. Since the velocity dispersion correlates with the three-dimensional structure and orbital anisotropy of a galaxy, a more complex and realistic dynamical model of a SLACS lens would require a non-trivial prior on these quantities: for instance, models with a larger radial anisotropy and elongation along the line of sight would have to be upweighted. In this paper we re-analysed the SLACS sample with a more conservative approach: we focused exclusively on projected quantities, which are directly observable, and used only gravitational lensing data as constraints on the mass distribution. We combined strong lensing measurements of SLACS with weak lensing observations obtained for the parent galaxy sample from which the lenses were drawn, while explicitly accounting for selection effects. The primary goal of this work is to put constraints on the stellar mass-to-light ratio of massive galaxies and on their inner dark matter density profile. We want to determine to what extent can gravitational lensing data, on its own, support previous claims of a non-universal IMF in early-type galaxies, and whether it provides evidence for the contraction of dark matter, a phenomenon ubiquitously observed in hydrodynamical simulations at the mass

Read the complete text