Turbulent Pipe Flow of Thixotropic Fluids

Noman Yousuf 1, Daniel Lester 1, Murray Rudman 2, Marco Dentz 3, Nicky Eshtiaghi 1 · 2025

Read Turbulent Pipe Flow of Thixotropic Fluids by Noman Yousuf 1, Daniel Lester 1, Murray Rudman 2, Marco Dentz 3, Nicky Eshtiaghi 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-01597.txt.

Introduction

Noman Yousuf and co-authors simulate turbulent flow in a pipe for fluids whose thickness changes with their recent history. Such fluids, found in slurries and emulsions, thin or thicken based on how they were lately sheared. At large scale their springy response is too fast to matter, leaving only the memory effect.

Full computer runs covered cases where the memory is slow, fast, or matched to the swirl time of the flow. In the slow and fast limits the fluid acted like a simple one with a fixed rule. At matched rates, a record of each parcel's shear past set the thickness. A shortcut model using that record matched the full runs within a few percent.

Catalog record

CREATORNoman Yousuf 1, Daniel Lester 1, Murray Rudman 2, Marco Dentz 3, Nicky Eshtiaghi 1
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE86 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-01597

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Turbulent Pipe Flow of Thixotropic Fluids Noman Yousuf 1, Daniel Lester 1, Murray Rudman 2, Marco Dentz 3, Nicky Eshtiaghi 1 Abstract Complex materials with internal microstructure such as suspensions and emulsions exhibit time-dependent rheology characterized by viscoelasticity and thixotropy. In many large-scale applications such as turbulent pipe flow, the elastic response occurs on a much shorter timescale than the thixotropy, hence these flows are purely thixotropic. The fundamental dynamics of thixotropic turbulence is poorly understood, particularly the interplay between microstructural state, rheology, and turbulence structure. To address this gap, we conduct direct numerical simulations (DNS) of fully developed turbulent pipe flow of a model thixotropic (Moore) fluid over a range of thixoviscous numbers Λ \Lambda from slow ( Λ ≪ 1 \Lambda\ll 1 ) to fast ( Λ ≫ 1 \Lambda\gg 1 ) thixotropic kinetics relative to the eddy turnover time. Analysis of DNS results in the Lagrangian frame shows that, as expected, in the limits of slow and fast kinetics, these time-dependent flows behave as time-independent purely viscous (generalized Newtonian) analogues. For intermediate kinetics ( Λ ∼ 1 \Lambda\sim 1 ), the rheology is governed by a path integral of the thixotropic fading memory kernel over the distribution of Lagrangian shear history, the latter of which is modelled via a simple stochastic model for the radially non-stationary pipe flow. DNS computations based on this effective viscosity closure exhibit excellent agreement (within 2.4% error) with the fully thixotropic model for Λ = 1 \Lambda=1 , indicating that the purely viscous (generalized Newtonian) analogue persists for arbitrary values of Λ ∈ [ 0 , ∞ + ) \Lambda\in[0,\infty^{+}) and across nonlinear rheology models. These results uncover the feedback mechanisms between microstructure, rheology, and turbulence and offer fundamental insights into the structure of thixotropic turbulence. keywords Turbulence, Thixotropy, Non-Newtonian Flow † † affiliation: 1 Chemical and Environmental Engineering, RMIT University, VIC 3000, Australia 2 Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Monash University, VIC 3800, Australia 3 Spanish National Research Council (IDAEA-CSIC), 08034 Barcelona, Spain 1 Introduction Complex fluids such as colloidal suspensions, emulsions, biological assemblies, polymer solutions and melts ( Larson, 1999 ) are all characterized by the presence of an internal microstructure that imparts non-Newtonian flow behaviors such as yield-pseudo plasticity ( Barnes, 1999 ; Bonn et al., 2017 ) , nonlinear viscoelasticity ( Ewoldt et al., 2009 ; McKinley et al., 1996 ) , thixotropy ( Larson & Wei, 2019 ; Mewis & Wagner, 2009 ) and thixo-elasto-visco-plasticity ( Ewoldt & McKinley, 2017 ) . These fluids arise in large-scale process equipment such as pumps, heat exchangers, mixing tanks and pipelines across industrial applications spanning minerals processing, paints and coatings, energy resources, food processing and wastewater treatment. From a process perspective, turbulent flow of these complex fluids is desirable due to improved heat and mass transfer characteristics, mitigation of sedimentation and optimal pumping efficiency. Despite widespread application, there remain significant fundamental questions regarding the turbulent flow of complex fluids. The onset of rheological complexity in complex fluids arises from their internal microstructure, which exhibits time-dependent properties characterized by nonlinear viscoelasticity and thixotropy. Viscoelasticity involves the partial recovery of prior elastic deformation of the microstructure over small timescales ( Pipkin, 1972 ) , whereas thixotropy manifests as a reversible, time-dependent change in viscosity under flow conditions, driven by the shear degradation (breakdown) and the thermal recovery (rebuild) of the microstructure ( Larson & Wei, 2019 ) . In this sense, viscoelasticity involves the impact of strain history on the current stress state, whereas thixotropy involves the impact of strain rate history on the current stress state. Many complex fluids can be broadly classified as thixotropic elasto-visco-plastic (TEVP) materials ( Ewoldt & McKinley, 2017 ) , where the interplay of thixotropic and elastic effects, along with a plastic yield criterion gives rise to complex rheological responses that can be difficult to deconvolve ( Ewoldt & Saengow, 2022 ) . However, for many large-scale applications that involve continuous flow over longer timescales, some TEVP materials can be validly approximated as thixotropic fluids with shear-dependent viscosity as the elastic relaxation timescale of the fluid is several orders of magnitude shorter than both the flow and thixotropic timescales ( Dullaert & Mewis, 2005 ; Mewis & Wagner, 2012 ) . One such practical example is turbulent pipe flow, where TEVP materials exhibit drag reduction primarily due to thixotropic breakdown of the microstructure near pipe walls ( Escudier & Presti, 1996 ; Pereira & Pinho, 1999 ; Pereira & Pinho, 2002 ) . Although there certainly exist industrial applications where elastic effects are important, many large-scale flows of complex fluids can be treated as purely thixotropic fluids Larson & Wei (2019) . Despite extensive applications in the process industries ( Cayeux & Leulseged, 2020 ; Escudier et al., 1999 ; Pereira & Pinho, 1999 ; Pereira & Pinho, 2002 ) , thixotropic turbulence remains poorly understood. Turbulent thixotropic flows are complex in that they involve an interplay ( Thompson, 2020 ) between microstructural evolution due to thixotropy, macroscopic fluid rheology that arises from the microstructural state, and the turbulence structure that informs fluid shear and transport which drive thixotropy. The evolution of microstructure due to thixotropy is typically characterized by the structural parameter \lambda ( Goodeve, 1939 ; Cheng & Evans, 1965 ; Barnes, 1997 ) that represents the state of the microstructure, ranging from fully structured ( \lambda=1 ) to an unstructured ( \lambda=0 ) material. Typically, the viscosity of the fluid decreases with decreasing \lambda , and in a spatially homogeneous system the structural parameter decreases with shear exposure due to shear-induced structure breakdown, while simultaneously rebuilding due to Brownian motion ( Nguyen & Boger, 1985 ) . In turbulent flows, the ubiquity of coherent structures ( Lee et al., 1990 ) can generate large spatial variations in shear rate, which can generate heterogeneous spatial distributions of the structural parameter \lambda . Hence, in these flows the structural parameter evolves through a balance between shear-induced microstructure breakdown, thermal rebuild and advective transport. Diffusion is typically negligible as this is governed by the very slow self-diffusion of the microstructure ( Eckstein et al., 1977 ) . This feedback loop remains poorly understood, particularly when the timescale of the thixotropic kinetics are similar to that of the eddy turnover time, leading to highly nonlinear flow behavior. In this study, we explore the following questions regarding the fundamentals of thixotropic turbulence: (i) What mechanisms govern the interplay between rheology, microstructural state, and turbulence structure? Understanding this relationship is essential for capturing the non-equilibrium dynamics of thixotropic turbulent pipe flows. (ii) How do these interactions evolve as the thixo-viscous timescale changes? Variations in timescales can lead to qualitatively different behaviour, influencing both microstructural evolution and turbulence dynamics. (iii) Can a simplified rheological model be developed to accurately describe these interactions in fully developed turbulent flow? Development of such a model would significantly improve our ability to predict and control flow of thixotropic fluids in engineering applications. We address these questions in this study by simulating and analyzing fully developed turbulent pipe flow of a model thixotropic fluid at a moderate Reynolds number. We employ a high-resolution spectral element code ( Blackburn et al., 2019 ) to conduct

Read the complete text