Thermodynamics of charmed hadrons across chiral crossover from lattice QCD

Sipaz Sharma, Frithjof Karsch, Peter Petreczky · 2025

Read Thermodynamics of charmed hadrons across chiral crossover from lattice QCD by Sipaz Sharma, Frithjof Karsch, Peter Petreczky (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-01300.txt.

Introduction

Sipaz Sharma and co-authors used lattice QCD to study charmed hadrons near the chiral crossover, in a 2025 paper. As hot matter crosses over, quarks begin to move freely. Charm fluctuations and their links to charge, strangeness, and baryon number carry clues. The team computed those signals up to fourth order.

They split the charm pressure into baryon and meson parts. Below the crossover, unseen charmed states predicted by the quark model add real weight. At the crossover, the simple hadron gas picture breaks down. Some low-lying states seem to survive above it, hinting at stepwise melting. The work maps how charm matter changes with heat.

Catalog record

CREATORSipaz Sharma, Frithjof Karsch, Peter Petreczky
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE19 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-01300

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Thermodynamics of charmed hadrons across chiral crossover from lattice QCD Sipaz Sharma, Frithjof Karsch, Peter Petreczky Abstract We use up to fourth-order charm fluctuations and their correlations with net baryon number, electric charge, and strangeness fluctuations, calculated within the framework of lattice QCD, to study the continuum partial pressure contributions of charmed baryons and mesons. We show that, at and below the chiral crossover temperature, these partial pressures receive enhanced contributions from experimentally unobserved charmed hadrons predicted by the Quark Model. Additionally, we demonstrate that at the chiral crossover, the Hadron Resonance Gas description breaks down, signaling the modification of open charm hadrons and thereby implying the onset of charm deconfinement. We present evidence for the survival of low-lying non-radial 1 ​ S 1S and 1 ​ P 1P hadron-like excitations above the chiral crossover, which hints at the sequential melting of charmed hadrons. Finally, we investigate the continuum partial pressure contribution of charm quark-like excitation that emerges at the chiral crossover and calculate its temperature-dependent in-medium mass. [orcid=0000-0001-6916-2233] 1 Introduction Lattice studies in the recent years have predicted the existence of experimentally unobserved charmed resonances by calculating charm fluctuations and their correlations with other conserved quantum numbers a.k.a. generalized charm susceptibilities Bazavov et al. 2014 ; Sharma 2023 ; Bazavov et al. 2024 . Recently, analysis of experimental open charm hadron yields using the extended Statistical Hadronization Model for charm (SHMc) Andronic et al. 2019 , showed enhanced yields in the charmed baryon sector Braun-Munzinger et al. 2024 . This enhancement is relative to the experimentally known charmed hadronic states tabulated in the Particle Data Group (PDG) records, and therefore corroborates the existence of missing resonances in the open charm sector. Until now, lattice QCD predictions of missing resonances have been based solely on the ratios of generalized charm susceptibilities. This approach, however, could not provide a quantitative measure of enhancement in individual quantum number channels. The reason lattice QCD studies had to resort to ratios of generalized susceptibilities rather then the susceptibilities themselves is because controlling the cutoff effects in the latter is challenging due to the relatively large charm quark mass. In this study, for the first time, we use our continuum extrapolated lattice QCD results to explicitly determine enhancement factors at the chiral crossover temperature, {T_{pc}=(156.5\pm 1.5)} MeV Bazavov et al. 2019 ; Borsanyi et al. , for both the charmed baryonic and mesonic sectors. The chiral crossover also exhibits deconfining feature in the charm quark sector, i.e. charm quarks as new degrees of freedom start appearing at or close to the pseudo-critical temperature of chiral symmetry restoration (Bazavov et al. (2024)). Clearly the appearance of charm quark degrees of freedom at T_{pc} , arising due to the disappearance of some hadronic states, will also liberate light quark degrees of freedom, although in the chiral limit this may not directly be related to the universal aspects of the chiral phase transition. The partial charm hadronic pressures start to deviate from the HRG model prediction, but not all charmed hadrons dissociate at T_{pc} . Furthermore, recent lattice QCD studies provide compelling evidence for the survival of charmed hadrons above the chiral crossover temperature Bazavov et al. 2024 ; Sharma 2024a ; Sharma 2024b . In this paper, we investigate the gradual deconfinement of charmed hadrons by analyzing continuum extrapolated proxies for partial pressures of charmed baryons and mesons across the chiral crossover. 2 Calculating generalized susceptibilities on the lattice To project out the relevant degrees of freedom in the charm sector, one calculates the generalized susceptibilities, {\chi^{BQSC}_{klmn}} , of the conserved charges: baryon number, B , electric charge, Q , strangeness, S , and charm, C . This involves taking appropriate derivatives of the total pressure, P=\frac{T}{V}\ln Z(T,V,\hat{\mu}_{B},\hat{\mu}_{Q},\hat{\mu}_{S},\hat{\mu}_{C})\;, (1) which contains contributions from the total charm pressure, P_{C} . These derivatives are taken with respect to the chemical potentials, {\hat{\mu}_{X}=\mu_{X}/T} , {\forall X\in\{B,Q,S,C\}} , of the quantum number combinations one is interested in, {\chi^{BQSC}_{klmn}=\dfrac{\partial^{(k+l+m+n)}\;\;[P\;(\hat{\mu}_{B},\hat{\mu}_{Q},\hat{\mu}_{S},\hat{\mu}_{C})\;/T^{4}]}{\partial\hat{\mu}^{k}_{B}\;\;\partial\hat{\mu}^{l}_{Q}\;\;\partial\hat{\mu}^{m}_{S}\;\;\partial\hat{\mu}^{n}_{C}}}\bigg|_{\overrightarrow{\mu}=0}\text{,} (2) where \vec{\mu}=(\mu_{B},\mu_{Q},\mu_{S},\mu_{C}) . Note that {\chi^{BQSC}_{klmn}} will be non-zero only for {(k+l+m+n)\in\text{even}} . In the following, if the subscript corresponding to a conserved charge is zero in the left hand side of Eq. ( 2 ), then both the corresponding superscript as well the zero subscript will be suppressed. Generalized susceptibilities up to fourth order have been calculated on the (2+1)-flavor HISQ (Highly Improved Staggered Quark) gauge configurations generated by the HotQCD collaboration Bollweg et al. 2021 for the physical strange to light quark mass ratio, {m_{s}/m_{l}}=27 . The temperature scale was set using the f_{K} scale Bollweg et al. 2021 . The charm-quark sector has been treated in the quenched approximation. We use HISQ action with epsilon term for charm quark to remove \mathcal{O}((am_{c})^{4}) tree-level lattice artifacts Follana et al. 2007 . This setup is known to have small discretization effects for charm quark related observables Follana et al. 2007 ; Bazavov et al. 2010 . The calculation of \chi^{BQSC}_{klmn} involves derivatives of the pressure and on the lattice this is achieved by the unbiased stochastic estimation of various traces – consisting of inversions and derivatives of the fermion matrices ( D ) – using the random noise method Mitra et al. 2022 . Lattice cutoff effects cancel to a large extent in the ratios of various generalized susceptibilities Bazavov et al. 2024 . These ratios, even though calculated on lattices with a finite lattice spacing, a , are close to the continuum limit results. Therefore, in this work we use generalized susceptibilities normalized by \chi^{C}_{4} calculated on lattices with a fixed temporal extent, N_{\tau}=8 , where N_{\tau}=(aT)^{-1} . In order to understand the cut-off effects due to heavier charm quark, we used two different Lines of Constant Physics (LCPs) to tune the bare charm quark mass am_{c} . The first LCP (LCP [a] ) corresponds to keeping the spin-averaged charmonium mass, {(3m_{J/\psi}+m_{\eta_{c\bar{c}}})/4} , fixed to its physical value Sharma 2023 . The second LCP (LCP [b] ) is defined by the physical (PDG) charm to strange quark mass ratio, m_{c}/m_{s}=11.76 Workman et al. 2022 . Further details of the charm-quark mass tuning and parametrization can be found in Sharma 2024a . Here we use ratios of generalized susceptibilities calculated on lattices with temporal extent N_{\tau}=8 on LCP [b] because of their relatively smaller errors. To convert generalized susceptibilities normalized by \chi^{C}_{4} into absolute numbers we use continuum extrapolated results for \chi^{C}_{4} . Details of the continuum extrapolation will be given in a forthcoming publication. 3 Boltzmann Approximation Figure 1: Comparison of QM-HRG and PDG-HRG predictions for charmed baryons [ Left ] and charmed mesons [ Right ]. \Delta=100|1-\text{QM-HRG}/\text{PDG-HRG}|_{T_{pc}} . The yellow bands represent T_{pc} with its uncertainty. 3.1 Charmed Hadrons Hadron resonance gas model (HRG) has been successful in describing the particle abundance ratios measured in the heavy-ion experiments. It describes a non-interacting gas of hadron resonances, and therefore can be used to calculate the hadronic pressure below {T_{pc}} Andronic et al. 2019 . In the Boltzmann approximation, the dimensionless partial pressures from the charmed meson, {P^{C}_{M}}, and the charmed baryon, {P^{C}_{B}} , sectors take the following forms Allton et al. 2005 : \displaystyle\begin{aligned} {P^{C}_{M}(T,\overrightarrow{\mu})}&{=\dfrac{1}{2\pi^{2}}\sum_{i\in\text{C-mesons}}g_{i}\bigg(\dfrac{m_{i}}{T}\bigg)^{2}K_{2}(m_{i}/T)}\\ &{\text{cosh}(Q_{i}\hat{\mu}_{Q}+S_{i}\hat{\mu}_{S}+C_{i}\hat{\mu}_{C})}\text{ ,}\\ {P^{C}_{B}(T,\overrightarrow{\mu})}&={\dfrac{1}{2\pi^{2}}\sum_{i\in\text{C-baryons}}g_{i}\bigg(\dfrac{m_{i}}{T}\bigg)^{2}K_{2}(m_{i}/T)}\\ &{\text{cosh}(B_{i}\hat{\mu}_{B}+Q_{i}\hat{\mu}_{Q}+S_{i}\hat{\mu}_{S}+C_{i}\hat{\mu}_{C})}\text{ .}\end{aligned} (3) In above equations, at a given temperature, the summation

Read the complete text