Chiral induced Spin Polarized Electron Current: Origin of the Chiral Induced Spin Selectivity Effect
Jonas Fransson · 2025
Read Chiral induced Spin Polarized Electron Current: Origin of the Chiral Induced Spin Selectivity Effect by Jonas Fransson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-00781.txt.
Introduction
Jonas Fransson explains what must hold for chiral molecules to sort electrons by spin. The paper appeared in two thousand twenty-five. The effect, called chiral induced spin selectivity, is well observed. Its origin has stayed an open question. Chiral molecules lack mirror symmetry, like a screw or a hand. Electrons passing through them come out spin-polarized.
Fransson shows two needs must be met together. First, chirality itself breaks the tie between spin states in light molecules. Heavy elements are not required for that split. Second, the molecule must lose energy to its surroundings. Without dissipation, no lasting polarization can form. Examples in the paper show each need at work. The theory gives chemists a clearer target when designing spin-selective materials.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jonas Fransson |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 28 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-00781
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Chiral induced Spin Polarized Electron Current: Origin of the Chiral Induced Spin Selectivity Effect Jonas Fransson Abstract The discovery of the chiral induced spin selectivity effect has provided a novel tool to study how active physical and chemical mechanism may differ in chiral enantiomers, however, the origin of the effect itself is yet an open question. In this article, it is theoretically shown that two aspects have to be fulfilled for the chiral induced spin selectivity effect to arise. First, chirality is a necessary condition for breaking spin-degeneracy in molecular structures that do not comprise heavy elements. Second, dissipation is indispensable for the molecule to develop a non-vanishing spin-polarization. These theoretical conclusions are illustrated in terms of a few examples, showing the necessity of the two aspects to be coordinated for the emergence of the chiral induced spin selectivity effect. Chirality induced spin selectivity is now a well-established phenomenon in physics, chemistry, and in biology Bloom et al. 2024 . Whenever electrons flow through a chiral material, they will likely be spin-polarised in the direction they propagate Ray et al. 1999 . Aside from its intrinsic interest, this phenomenon has implications both for devices and for our understanding of biological electrochemistry. In aerobes large electron currents, typically tens of amperes in the resting human, flow from metabolism to oxygen Rees 1983 . What makes spin important in this process of respiration is that the ultimate electron acceptor, dioxygen, is a ground state triplet. One of the reactions involved in the reduction of oxygen to water involves a two-electron transfer. It has been shown that this reaction is facilitated by spin-polarisation Sang et al. 2022 . At a ferromagnetic electrode, oxygen reduction proceeds faster in a magnetic field. Remarkably, general anesthetics, known to affect cellular respiration, markedly reduce spin-polarisation at a ferromagnetic electrode Gupta et al. 2023 . This said, the extent and importance of spin-polarisation in living systems remains unknown. Direct two-terminal measurements of electron current in biology are usually impossible. Hitherto, almost all measurements related to the chiral induced spin selectivity effect have thus far been made by injecting a spin-polarized current into the chiral material, e.g., see Refs Xie et al. 2011 ; Das et al. 2022 ; Kondou et al. 2022 . In the case of photoemission, measurements using linearly polarized light were conducted Göhler et al. 2011 , demonstrating the spin-polarization of the electrons emitted from a surface of chiral molecules. By contrast, there has been little attempt to discern the magnetic properties of chiral structures in the absence of external magnetic boundary conditions. If that were possible, it may amount to a noninvasive method to assess for example whether the electron currents flowing in a living organism are spin-polarized. Recently, however, it was predicted that chiral molecules should acquire an inhomogeneous spin-distribution under a charge current flux Fransson and Turin 2024 Theoretically, the chiral induced spin selectivity effect has been approached using the independent particle description Gutierrez et al. 2012 ; Guo and Sun 2012 ; Guo and Sun 2014 ; Matityahu et al. 2016 ; Michaeli and Naaman 2019 ; Yang and Ren 2024 , which does not capture the chiral induced spin anisotropy that underlies the phenomenon. Density functional theoretical approaches have also been employed Zöllner et al. 2020 ; Naskar et al. 2023 , however, without successfully accounting for these basic features of the effect. These approaches fail because the intrinsic absence of particle correlations that account for dissipation or losses in the system. It has subsequently been demonstrated that electron correlations are necessary to be included in order obtain a somewhat more physically correct description of the processes Dalum and Hedegård 2019 ; Fransson 2019 ; Fransson 2020 ; Alwan and Dubi 2021 ; Huisman and Thijssen 2021 ; Huisman et al. 2023a ; Huisman et al. 2023b ; Vittmann et al. 2023 ; Chiesa et al. 2024 . The prediction made in this article is that any charge current flowing through a chiral molecule must become spin-polarized. Behind the generation of the spin-polarized current is the breaking of time-reversal symmetry by dissipative processes and the breaking of spin-degeneracy by chirality coupled to spin-orbit coupling. In this sense one may describe chiral molecules as being spin-polarizers. The mechanism presented in this article plays an important role for the theoretical development of chiral induced spin selectivity effect. Spin-polarization will emerge if two symmetries are broken, namely (i) time-reversal symmetry and (ii) spin-degeneracy. It is not necessary for a single mechanism to break the two symmetries simultaneously. There might be different sources for the two symmetry breaking agents. One should keep in mind that breaking time-reversal symmetry allows but does not imply breaking spin-degeneracy. Another important aspect is that the discussion of breaking time-reversal symmetry does not necessarily apply to the system as a whole, but only to parts that locally may correspond to lowering of the entropy as a local order is established. This loss of entropy is, however, compensated by an excess of entropy in another part of the system. Consequently, the description of local properties may display a broken symmetry state although the global symmetry is preserved. An example is the screening that occurs around a localized magnetic moment in a metallic environment at low temperatures, due to the Kondo effect. While the local moment tends to stabilize at low temperatures, the surrounding environment of itinerant electrons align anti-ferromagnetically with the local moment such that the overall magnetic moment vanishes. In this sense, the local order which is established by the formation of the localized moment is prevented from violating the time-reversal invariance by the Kondo screening cloud. The general structure of the electronic spin-orbit coupling can be effectively written as {\bf v}\cdot{\boldsymbol{\sigma}} , where the vector {\bf v} is defined by the electric field {\bf E} and the momentum operator {\bf p} , and {\boldsymbol{\sigma}} is the vector of Pauli matrices. For a centrally symmetric (wave-) functions, the electric field {\bf E} and, hence, the spin-orbit coupling vanishes. The wavefunction is required to be distorted from a centrally symmetric form to generate a spin-orbit coupling. Consider a molecular structure defined by a distribution of coplanar nuclei. The effective spin-orbit coupling for such a structure provides a hybridization between the spins of the planar form {\bf v}\cdot{\boldsymbol{\sigma}}=v_{-}\sigma_{+}+v_{+}\sigma_{-} , where v_{\pm}=v_{x}\pm iv_{y} and \sigma_{\pm}=\sigma_{x}\pm i\sigma_{y} . For a Kramers doublet, the planar spin-orbit coupling breaks the degeneracy of the state, however, into bonding and anti-bonding linear combinations of the spin-states such that the resulting gapped electron spectrum remains non spin-polarized. In principle this symmetry breaking mechanism does not have an influence on the spin-degeneracy, which remains intact. By contrast, for a non-coplanar distribution of nuclei, the effective vector field may include a longitudinal component v_{z} . This leads to the introduction of a mass term v_{z}\sigma_{z} in the matrix defining the spectrum. The significance of this mass term is to open up an energy gap between the spin-states, hence breaking the spin-degeneracy. It is important to point out that although this spin-degeneracy breaking mechanism exists in a molecule, it is an immanent property of the molecule. As such, it requires additional conditions to be fulfilled before an actual spin-polarization develops. Nevertheless,