Update on non-unitary mixing in the recent NO ν \nu A and T2K data
Xin Yue Yu, Zishen Guan, Ushak Rahaman, Nikolina Ilic · 2025
Read Update on non-unitary mixing in the recent NO ν \nu A and T2K data by Xin Yue Yu, Zishen Guan, Ushak Rahaman, Nikolina Ilic (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-00146.txt.
Introduction
Four authors, Xin Yue Yu, Zishen Guan, Ushak Rahaman, and Nikolina Ilic, update a test of how neutrinos mix and change type. Their work uses the newest data from two large trials, NOvA and T2K. The head of the text dates the work to 2024, one year earlier than the catalog year shown for the entry.
The team asks whether the mixing rules allow a small break from the standard pattern. They fit both trials alone and together, and give best-fit values and firm limits for the new terms. The new limits are tighter than those from older data. The study also looks ahead to what NOvA, T2K, and a future trial called DUNE could show.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Xin Yue Yu, Zishen Guan, Ushak Rahaman, Nikolina Ilic |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-00146
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Update on non-unitary mixing in the recent NO ν \nu A and T2K data Xin Yue Yu, Zishen Guan, Ushak Rahaman, Nikolina Ilic Abstract In this paper, we have tested the non-unitary mixing hypothesis with the latest data from NO ν \nu A and T2K experiments. We have also analysed their combined data. We have provided the best-fit values of the standard and non standard parameters after the analysis. 90 % 90\% limits on the non-unitary mixing parameters have also been provided. The constraints on unitary violation is stronger, compared to the constraints obtained from previous data from NO ν \nu A and T2K. The tension between NO ν \nu A and T2K at the 1 σ 1\,\sigma for normal mass hierarchy can be reduced for non-unitary mixing due to α 10 \alpha_{10} , albeit for a value of | α 10 | |\alpha_{10}| larger than the present global 90 % 90\% limit. Additionally a study of the future sensitivity of NO ν \nu A, T2K and DUNE has been provided. Preprint: APS/123-QED I Introduction The neutrino oscillation phenomenon, driven by three mixing angles {\theta_{12}} , {\theta_{13}} and {\theta_{23}} ; two mass squared differences {\Delta_{21}}=m_{2}^{2}-m_{1}^{2} and {\Delta_{31}}=m_{3}^{2}-m_{1}^{2} , where m_{i} s are the absolute masses of three neutrino mass eigen states \nu_{i} s, with i=1,2,3 ; and a CP violating phase \delta_{\mathrm{CP}} , provides one of the windows to physics beyond the standard model (BSM). The currently unknown properties related to neutrino oscillation physics are the sign of {\Delta_{31}} , octant of {\theta_{23}} , and the value of \delta_{\mathrm{CP}} . Depending on the sign of {\Delta_{31}} , there can be two different mass hierarchies: normal hierarchy (NH) for {\Delta_{31}}>0 ; and inverted hierarchy (IH) for {\Delta_{31}}<0 . Similarly, if \sin^{2}2{\theta_{23}}<1 , there can be two different octants of {\theta_{23}} : lower octant (LO) for {\theta_{23}}<\pi/4 ; and a higher octant (HO) for {\theta_{23}}>\pi/4 . The present long-baseline accelerator neutrino experiments NO \nu A [ 1 ] and T2K [ 2 ] are expected to measure these unknowns. However, the 2020 and 2024 data from NO \nu A [ 3 , 4 ] is in mild tension [ 5 ] with the latest T2K data from 2020, [ 6 , 7 ] for the the \delta_{\mathrm{CP}} measurements and both experiments disfavour each other’s 1\,\sigma allowed regions on the \sin^{2}{\theta_{23}}-\delta_{\mathrm{CP}} plane. These tensions opened up the possibility of the existence of BSM physics in the NO \nu A and T2K data [ 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] . The recent joint analysis of NO \nu A and T2K collaborations also observed this tension [ 14 ] . We have presented our analysis of the latest NO \nu A and T2K data in Appendix B . In this paper, we explore the non-unitary mixing in the NO \nu A and T2K experiment. This is an update from ref. [ 9 ] . Here, we consider one non-unitary parameter at a time, unlike the referenced analysis where all of the parameters simultaneously analyzed. This has allowed us to pinpoint the exact effects of non-unitary parameters on oscillation probabilities and event numbers. Best-fit values of standard oscillation parameters as well as non-unitary parameters have been presented. A 90\% limit on the non-unitary parameters have also been obtained from the present NO \nu A and T2K data. We also provide a theoretical explanation of our results, based on the effects of different parameters on the oscillation probabilities. Finally, we consider the role of a future combined result of NO \nu A and T2K, and the upcoming long-baseline experiment, DUNE [ 15 ] , under the assumption that non-unitary mixing exists. In section II , we have introduced non-unitary mixing and discussed how it can arise in neutrino oscillation experiments. We have presented the results of our data analysis in section III . The results from future sensitivity studies have been presented in section IV , and the final conclusions have been drawn in section V . II Non-unitary mixing If more than three neutrino generations exist as iso-singlet heavy neutral leptons (HNL), they would not take part in neutrino oscillations in the minimal extension of the standard model. However, their ad-mixture in charged current weak interactions will affect neutrino oscillation and the neutrino oscillation will be described by an effective 3\times 3 non-unitary mixing matrix. In case of non-unitary mixing, the effective 3\times 3 mixing matrix can be written as [ 16 , 17 ] : N=N_{NP}U_{3\times 3}=\left[{\begin{array}[]{ccc}\alpha_{00}&0&0\\ \alpha_{10}&\alpha_{11}&0\\ \alpha_{20}&\alpha_{21}&\alpha_{22}\end{array}}\right]U_{\rm PMNS}\, (1) where U_{\rm PMNS} is the standard 3\times 3 PMNS mixing matrix. The diagonal elements \alpha_{ii} of N_{NP} are real, and the off-diagonal elements \alpha_{ij}=|\alpha_{ij}|e^{i\phi_{ij}} are complex, with i,j=1,2,3 and i>j . The details of the calculation of the oscillation probability with non-unitary mixing have been discussed in ref. [ 9 ] . The present 3\,\sigma boundary values for non-unitary parameters are given in ref. [ 18 , 19 ] . From ref. [ 19 ] , it is clear that there is a stringent constraint on non-unitary neutrino mixing from the charged lepton flavour violation (CLFV) experiments. However, it is possible to obtain percent level non-unitary mixing in neutrino oscillation without violating the strong constraints of CLFV experiments in certain neutrino mass models involving low scale typw-I seesaw mechanisms, namely inverse and linear seesaw [ 20 ] . Besides it is important to independently test unitary violation of the three light neutrino mixing in the neutrino oscillation experiments. Several other works [ 21 , 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 ] have studied unitary violation in the future simulated neutrino oscillation experiments as well as the present neutrino oscillation experiment data. If there is a mismatch between the CLFV results, and the neutrino oscillation results, that should be something to ponder about. The low scale see-saw mechanism can allow percentage level deviation from unitary mixing at the CLFV experiments only for channels involving tau decay because of weaker constraints on lepton flavour violating tau decays. However, it is possible to evade all the constraints on non-unitery mixing from CLFV data and invoke large non-unitary mixing in neutrino oscillation experiments in another way. If the sterile neutrino is light enough to be produced in all relevant processes including \beta -decay, then unitarity is preserved in CLFV experiments because all the mass eigenstates are kinemetically accessible. However, the sterile neutrinos will mix and propagate with 3 standard neutrinos and hence participate in the oscillation phenomenon. Thus, their effects will be observed in neutrino oscillation experiments. If the additional mass eigen states are light enough, they can be directly probed in neutrino oscillation experiments [ 28 ] . However, if the new mass eigenstate lead to large \Delta m^{2}L/E , the oscillation will average out at the detector. In this averaged out region, the phenomenology of sterile neutrino is equivalent to that of non-unitary mixing [ 29 , 30 ] , except a sub-leading constant term. Moreover, the zero-distance effect [ 29 ] for non-unitary mixing will not be observed because the sterile oscillation would not develop yet at the near detector. In this particular case, it is possible to observe non-unitary mixing effect