Quantum uncertainty in the area of a black hole

Maulik Parikh, Jude Pereira · 2024

Read Quantum uncertainty in the area of a black hole by Maulik Parikh, Jude Pereira (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-21160.txt.

Description

Abstract Quantum fluctuations of the spacetime metric induce an uncertainty in the horizon area of a black hole. Working in linearized quantum gravity, we derive the variance in the area of a four-dimensional Schwarzschild black hole from the renormalized graviton propagator.

Catalog record

CREATORMaulik Parikh, Jude Pereira
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE69 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-21160

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantum uncertainty in the area of a black hole Maulik Parikh, Jude Pereira Abstract Quantum fluctuations of the spacetime metric induce an uncertainty in the horizon area of a black hole. Working in linearized quantum gravity, we derive the variance in the area of a four-dimensional Schwarzschild black hole from the renormalized graviton propagator. We find that the standard deviation of the horizon area scales as the product of the Schwarzschild radius and the Planck length. For macroscopic black holes, the quantum uncertainty is therefore enormous in Planck units. 1 Introduction The event horizon of a classical black hole is a mathematically precise null hypersurface in spacetime. Correspondingly, the horizon of a Schwarzschild black hole has a definite area. Quantum mechanics of course alters this picture. If any quantum fields are in the Unruh state, a black hole will decay through the probabilistic emission of Hawking radiation – a process driven by the ability of the horizon to reduce its entropy and thus its area [ 1 , 2 ] . In this scenario, the expectation value of the area decreases in time. If, however, all quantum fields are in the Hartle-Hawking state, the black hole will remain at equilibrium and the expectation value of the area will stay constant. But even in the Hartle-Hawking state, quantum-gravitational fluctuations of the metric will induce a variance in the area. The goal of this paper, then, is to calculate the quantum-gravitational variance of the area of a four-dimensional Schwarzschild black hole. We will do that in the context of linearized quantum gravity, for which the fluctuations can be described by a massless helicity-two field living on a Schwarzschild background, and to which the techniques of quantum field theory in curved spacetime are applicable. What might we expect to find? A natural guess for the uncertainty (i.e. the standard deviation) might be \Delta A\sim l_{P}^{2} . Loosely, the rationale would be that the background geometry is a classical solution to Einstein’s equations and thus one might expect it to be defined in quantum gravity by a coherent state – and coherent states are states of minimum uncertainty. This possibility is also indicated by thermality: for a thermal system with \Delta E\sim T , a black hole at Hawking temperature T_{H} would have \Delta A\sim l_{P}^{2}\Delta S=l_{P}^{2}\Delta E/T_{H}=l_{P}^{2} . As we will see, however, these naive estimates are not at all what we will obtain by explicit computation. Rather, we will find that \Delta A\sim r_{H}l_{P} , where r_{H} is the Schwarzschild radius. For any macroscopic black hole, this uncertainty is both vastly larger than Planckian scales and disappointingly small on astrophysical scales. Let us briefly outline the derivation. Our first task is to define what we mean by the horizon when the spacetime geometry is fluctuating. In addition, we will need an operator whose expectation value corresponds to the classical area. In Section 2 , we argue that linearized quantum gravity offers natural candidates. Since g_{\theta\theta}=r^{2} , we note that the classical horizon area is proportional to the value of g_{\theta\theta} at the horizon. Thus we will take the variance of the horizon area to be proportional to the variance of the local operator \hat{g}_{\theta\theta} evaluated at the coordinate location r_{H} . To find the variance of a quantum field requires taking the expectation value of the product of operators at a point in spacetime, which is in general divergent. We regulate this via point-splitting, so that \langle\hat{g}_{\theta\theta}(x)^{2}\rangle is replaced by \lim_{x\to x^{\prime}}\langle\hat{g}_{\theta\theta}(x)\hat{g}_{\theta\theta}(x^{\prime})\rangle . This quantity turns out to be proportional to a component of the Feynman propagator for the graviton. Thus to find the regulated variance, we need the position-space graviton propagator on a Schwarzschild background, evaluated near the horizon. This is an arduous calculation but, fortunately, the bulk of the derivation has already been performed by Gaddam and Groenenboem [ 3 , 4 ] . They decomposed the metric perturbations into spherical harmonics, imposed Regge-Wheeler gauge, and found the momentum-space propagator of the (l,m) th mode in the near-horizon limit. Thus to complete the derivation of the position-space graviton propagator only requires taking the Fourier transform and summing over all modes. In order to obtain the variance, we need to bring the two points in the propagator together. We can renormalize the resultant divergence by subtracting the graviton propagator in flat space. Somewhat surprisingly, the graviton propagator in flat space has not, to our knowledge, been calculated before in Regge-Wheeler gauge so we follow Gaddam and Groenenboem’s methods to obtain the necessary component of the graviton propagator in Minkowski space. (This is not simply a matter of setting the mass to zero in the expression for the black hole graviton propagator because that propagator assumed a near-horizon limit.) We illustrate the method for finding the renormalized position-space propagator for a scalar field, relegating its lengthy graviton counterpart to appendices. Finally, we take the coincidence limit to obtain the variance of horizon area. We find that uncertainty scales as r_{H}l_{P} , which is parametrically much larger than what might perhaps have been naively anticipated. We end with some numerical estimates and a discussion of the physical implications for an object free-falling into the black hole. Our derivation relies on perturbative quantum gravity; fluctuations in the spacetime geometry of black hole horizons have also been studied from a holographic perspective [ 16 , 17 ] . 2 Defining the quantum area of the horizon Consider the line element of a Schwarzschild black hole in the usual coordinates: ds^{2}=g^{(0)}_{\mu\nu}dx^{\mu}dx^{\nu}=-\Big(1-\frac{r_{H}}{r}\Big)dt^{2}+\Big(1-\frac{r_{H}}{r}\Big)^{-1}dr^{2}+r^{2}d\theta^{2}+r^{2}\sin^{2}\theta d\phi^{2}\;. (1) Here r_{H}=2GM and the area of the event horizon is A=\int_{r=r_{H}}d\theta d\phi\sqrt{g_{\Omega}}=4\pi r_{H}^{2}\;, (2) where g_{\Omega} is the determinant of the metric on the two-sphere. The expression ( 2 ) is only a classical statement; we are interested in calculating its quantum-gravitational fluctuations. More precisely, we wish to calculate the variance of some operator whose expectation value in some appropriate quantum state is given by ( 2 ). In a full background-independent theory of quantum gravity, this would be a highly non-trivial problem. But in the context of linearized quantum gravity, the presence of the classical background helps us in two ways. First, by quantizing metric perturbations about the background metric, we are able to work in the context of quantum field theory in curved spacetime. And second, the presence of the background allows us to define what we mean by the horizon in a fluctuating geometry, as follows. We pick some coordinates to cover the Schwarzschild geometry, or at least its near-horizon region. By stationarity and spherical symmetry, we can prefentially slice the event horizon into codimension-two sections, and we identify the corresponding surface on the coordinate chart (say r=r_{H} at some constant t ). See Figure 1 . Keeping the coordinates fixed, we then allow the metric to fluctuate via gauge-invariant perturbations, leading to a variance in the area on that surface. Note that r_{H} is just a coordinate, labeling the surface of interest on the manifold. When we put the black hole metric on the manifold, the surface has a special significance as the event horizon, but for the Minkowski metric it is just some arbitrary sphere which happens to have the radius r_{H} . Figure 1: In linearized gravity,

Read the complete text