Eigenstructure Analysis of Bloch Wave and Multislice Formulations for Dynamical Scattering in Transmission Electron Microscopy

Arya Bangun, Oleh Melnyk, Benjamin März · 2024

Read Eigenstructure Analysis of Bloch Wave and Multislice Formulations for Dynamical Scattering in Transmission Electron Microscopy by Arya Bangun, Oleh Melnyk, Benjamin März (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-21119.txt.

Description

A 2024 arXiv research paper by Arya Bangun, Oleh Melnyk, Benjamin März. We investigate the eigenstructure of matrix formulations used for modeling scattering processes within materials in transmission electron microscopy. Dynamical scattering is crucial for describing the interaction between an electron wave and the material under investigation. Unlike the Bloch wave formulation, which defines the transmission function via the scattering matrix, the traditional multislice method is lacking a pure transmission function due to the entanglement of electron waves with the propagation function.

Catalog record

CREATORArya Bangun, Oleh Melnyk, Benjamin März
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-21119

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Eigenstructure Analysis of Bloch Wave and Multislice Formulations for Dynamical Scattering in Transmission Electron Microscopy Arya Bangun, Oleh Melnyk, Benjamin März Abstract We investigate the eigenstructure of matrix formulations used for modeling scattering processes within materials in transmission electron microscopy. Dynamical scattering is crucial for describing the interaction between an electron wave and the material under investigation. Unlike the Bloch wave formulation, which defines the transmission function via the scattering matrix, the traditional multislice method is lacking a pure transmission function due to the entanglement of electron waves with the propagation function. To address this, we reformulate the multislice method into a matrix framework, which we refer to as the transmission matrix. This allows a direct comparison to the scattering matrix derived from Bloch waves in terms of their eigenstructures. Through theory, we demonstrate their equivalence with eigenvectors related by a two-dimensional Fourier matrix, given that the eigenvalue angles differ by modulo 2 ​ π ​ n 2\pi n (integer n n ). We numerically verify our findings as well as demonstrate the application of the eigenstructure for the estimation of the mean inner potential. I Introduction Modeling the three-dimensional atomic structure of a material is essential for studying its physical characteristics, like atomic electrostatic potential [ 34 , 13 , 35 ] . Information about the structure can significantly aid in the process of structure retrieval from experimental data such as diffraction patterns, when analyzing the material in transmission electron microscopes [ 12 ] . Determining the crystalline structure of materials from diffraction experiments is inseparable from the theory of multiple scattering of electrons, developed by Bethe [ 4 ] . Since then, numerous formulations have been developed to model multiple scattering phenomena in crystals, including the multislice method [ 9 , 24 , 16 , 20 ] and the scattering matrix obtained from Bloch waves [ 45 , 18 ] . Both models are frequently used for model-based reconstruction in TEM ( TEM ) [ 1 , 44 , 33 , 6 , 14 , 17 , 8 , 3 , 41 ] . Formulating the scattering matrix from the Bloch wave method incorporates the superposition of many periodic waves within a crystal to solve the Schrödinger equation. Therefore, the relation between electrostatic potential and Bloch waves within the crystal can be represented by an eigenvalue problem. Consequently, the scattering matrix is described by its eigenvalue decomposition, with the eigenvalues encoding parameters such as the specimen’s thickness, and the eigenvectors providing the Fourier coefficients of Bloch waves. On the other hand, the multislice method approximates the total electrostatic potential of the crystal by subdividing it into many thin slices of projected potentials. Then, the incident electron wave interacts with all slices consecutively, with the exit wave of one slice being used as the input wave for the following. A visualization of the Bloch wave and multislice approaches is given in Fig. 1 . An important benefit of the multislice method is that the eigenvalue decomposition can be avoided, facilitating a more efficient computation of the propagation through the crystal. The relationship between Bloch waves and the multislice method is discussed, for instance, in [ 11 ] . In several publications [ 51 , 43 , 29 , 15 ] , both models are numerically compared. Apart from the computation time, these analyses are mainly focused on the error in the intensity of the specimen exit wave functions for both methods, as this is the quantity that is finally obtained on a TEM detector. While such comparisons are valid to capture the performance, accuracy and consistency of outputs produced by both approaches, the underlying model is treated rather as a black box system and similarity is measured only implicitly. More importantly, measuring similarity solely based on intensity captures the projection information, which does not provide insight into the spatial structure of the electrostatic potentials, neither by the Bloch wave nor the multislice approach. In our study, we therefore go a step further and, rather than relying on the projected intensity alone, directly evaluate the 3D electrostatic potential. Figure 1: Comparison of the Bloch wave and the multislice approach. a , visualization of a SrTiO 3 crystal. b , projected potential representation of the SrTiO 3 crystal in a used in the multislice method. c , the construction of the respective scattering matrix \mathbf{S} and, d , transmission matrix \mathbf{\hat{S}} . e , f , diffraction patterns generated from matrices \mathbf{S} and \mathbf{\hat{S}} using plane wave illumination are similar, yet do not explicitly characterize the differences in eigenstructure of matrices in c and d . To compare the models, we study how both methods transform the incidence wave. Using Bloch waves, we have a direct expression in terms of the Fourier coefficients; such an expression can not be directly achieved for the multislice method. In the original formulation of the multislice method, the possibility of defining a pure transmission function, akin to the scattering matrix in the Bloch wave approach, is precluded due to the inherent entanglement between the exit wave across slices and Fresnel propagation. As a consequence, a direct comparison of the eigenstructure of the scattering matrix with the multislice method is made impossible. To circumvent this limitation, we reformulate the multislice model using matrix products and achieve a crucial separation between the input wave and the matrix that represents the transmission function of the crystal structure, which we call transmission matrix . This reformulation enables us to model the transmission function in a manner directly comparable to the scattering matrix by using eigenstructure analysis. Rather than the conventional approach of comparing resulting intensities, we present a direct mathematical comparison of the transmission matrix with the scattering matrix. Furthermore, we investigate whether the similarity between both matrices implies that also the underlying atomic structure is the same by evaluating diffraction patterns simulated by both methods. In addition to that, we leverage the determinant (the product of eigenvalues) of the transmission matrix to estimate the MIP ( MIP ), an important physical property of the inner structure of a crystal often analyzed in TEM and particularly electron holography experiments [ 48 , 32 ] . At first, we briefly introduce the scattering and transmission matrices: I.1 Transmission Matrix. Our formulation of the transmission matrix is derived from the multislice method. Instead of calculating an analytical solution, such as in the Bloch wave approach, the transmission function is built step-by-step using infinitely thin ‘sub-specimens’ (slices) represented by N\times N matrices. The (real-space) transmission matrix of a crystal with M slices is given by \mathbf{A}=\prod_{m=1}^{M}\mathbf{G}_{m}\mathbf{O}_{m}, (1) where \mathbf{O}_{m}\in\mathbb{C}^{N^{2}\times N^{2}} is the diagonal matrix representing the potential of each slice, and \mathbf{G}_{m} is the Fresnel propagator in free space. The elements of both potential and Fresnel propagator matrices depend on interaction constants, spatial frequencies, and tilt angles of the incoming wave. As scattering is typically considered in terms of the Fourier coefficients, so-called reciprocal space, we transform equation ( 1 ) as \mathbf{\hat{S}}=\mathbf{F}_{2D}\mathbf{A}\mathbf{F}_{2D}^{-1}, (2) where \mathbf{F}_{2D} and \mathbf{F}_{2D}^{-1} denote the two-dimensional Fourier and inverse Fourier transforms, respectively. The outlined transformation models the diffraction pattern in the back focal plane of a TEM. I.2 Scattering Matrix. The scattering matrix \mathbf{S} describes the interaction

Read the complete text