Quantum tunneling and its absence in deep wells and strong magnetic fields
Charles L. Fefferman, Jacob Shapiro, Michael I. Weinstein · 2024
Read Quantum tunneling and its absence in deep wells and strong magnetic fields by Charles L. Fefferman, Jacob Shapiro, Michael I. Weinstein (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-21100.txt.
Description
Abstract We present new results on quantum tunneling between deep potential wells, in the presence of a strong constant magnetic field. We construct a family of double well potentials containing examples for which the low-energy eigenvalue splitting vanishes, and hence quantum tunneling is eliminated.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Charles L. Fefferman, Jacob Shapiro, Michael I. Weinstein |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-21100
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantum tunneling and its absence in deep wells and strong magnetic fields Charles L. Fefferman, Jacob Shapiro, Michael I. Weinstein Abstract We present new results on quantum tunneling between deep potential wells, in the presence of a strong constant magnetic field. We construct a family of double well potentials containing examples for which the low-energy eigenvalue splitting vanishes, and hence quantum tunneling is eliminated. Further, by deforming within this family, the magnetic ground state can be made to transition from symmetric to anti-symmetric. However, for typical double wells in a certain regime, tunneling is not suppressed, and we provide a lower bound for the eigenvalue splitting. \dates This manuscript was compiled on August 24, 2026 DOI: www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.XXXXXXXXXX † † lead-author: Fefferman † † author-contributions: All authors contributed equally to the research and writing of this article. † † author-declaration: No conflicts of interest. † † corresponding-author: 2 To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: author.twoemail.com \dropcap Tunneling is a phenomenon of central importance in quantum systems. An important paradigm is a quantum particle, such as an electron, in a double well potential. The ground state tunneling rate (tunneling probability) between weakly coupled wells is related to the magnitude of the energy splitting of the two lowest eigenvalues of the double well Hamiltonian: in a purely classical description the lowest two states of the system are degenerate. Physicists and chemists have long known [ 1 ] , and mathematicians have proven [ 2 , 3 ] , that in the regime of deep potential wells (one way to realize the weakly-coupled regime), the energy splitting in non-magnetic quantum systems (a) is always non-zero and exponentially small in the depth of the wells, and (b) is asymptotically related to the hopping coefficient , an overlap integral of ground state atomic orbitals. In this paper we consider two dimensional double well quantum systems in a constant perpendicular magnetic field. In [ 4 ] we studied a Schrödinger double well model in which each single potential well is radially symmetric; see also [ 5 , 6 ] . The constant magnetic field strength of order \sim\lambda and the potential well depths \sim\lambda^{2} are taken to be large. We found (see Theorem 1) that (a) the eigenvalue splitting (and hence tunneling rate) is controlled by the hopping coefficient and (b) is always non-zero and exponentially small in \lambda . In this article we announce new results on the general case, where the single well is no longer constrained to be radially symmetric. We exhibit a family of double well potentials containing cases for which the low-energy eigenvalue splitting vanishes and quantum tunneling is eliminated. Further, by deforming within this family, the magnetic ground state can be made to transition from symmetric to anti-symmetric. For typical double wells in a certain regime, we prove that tunneling is not suppressed, and we provide a lower bound for the eigenvalue splitting. Mathematical setup We consider a quantum mechanical particle in two space dimensions, with a constant magnetic field perpendicular to the plane. We shall study two related Hamiltonians: the one well Hamiltonian h_{\lambda} and the two well Hamiltonian H_{\lambda} . The magnetic one well Hamiltonian, h_{\lambda} Let x=(x_{1},x_{2})^{\top} and x^{\perp}=(x_{2},-x_{1})^{\top} . In the symmetric gauge for the magnetic vector potential, the one well magnetic Hamiltonian is given by h_{\lambda}=\left(P+\frac{1}{2}\lambda bX^{\perp}\right)^{2}+\lambda^{2}v(X). Here, Xf(x)=xf(x) and P=-i\nabla denote the position operator and the momentum operator, respectively. We take the one well v:\mathbb{R}^{2}\to(-\infty,0] to be smooth, nonzero and compactly supported within B_{a}(0) , the disc of radius a>0 in \mathbb{R}^{2} . The parameter \lambda>0 , which sets the scale of both the depth of the potential and the magnetic field strength, is taken to be sufficiently large. The parameter b>0 is the relative (order 1 ) strength of the magnetic field. For fixed b , the effect of the magnetic field and that of a potential well with a non-degenerate minimum are of the same order of magnitude as \lambda\to\infty . Let e_{\lambda}\sim-\lambda^{2} be the ground state eigenvalue of h_{\lambda} . Throughout this paper, we assume that (i) e_{\lambda} is simple, and that (ii) e_{\lambda} remains bounded away from all other energies in the spectrum of h_{\lambda} as \lambda\to\infty . Assumption (ii) is valid if, for example, v has an isolated non-degenerate minimum or if v is very flat near its minimum, as for the square well. We denote the corresponding L^{2}(\mathbb{R}^{2}) –normalized eigenfunction by \varphi_{\lambda}(x) ; to simplify notation we will often write merely \varphi(x) . We emphasize that, in contrast to the non-magnetic case, it may not be possible to choose the ground state to be real-valued. The magnetic double well Hamiltonian, H_{\lambda} In some of the discussion below, we shall allow for v(x)=v(x;\lambda) , i.e., the one well potential depends on the large parameter \lambda . We replace the one well potential v(x;\lambda) by two copies of v , one displaced by d\in\mathbb{R}^{2} , the other by -d . The corresponding double well Hamiltonian is: \displaystyle H_{\lambda} \displaystyle=\left(P+\frac{1}{2}\lambda bX^{\perp}\right)^{2}+v^{L}(X;\lambda)+v^{R}(X;\lambda), (1a) In the most basic case, we take \displaystyle v^{L}(X;\lambda) \displaystyle=\lambda^{2}v(X+d)\quad v^{R}(X;\lambda)=\lambda^{2}v(X-d). (1b) Below, we shall also allow for more general \lambda- dependence of v^{L} and v^{R} . We center the two wells on the x_{1} –axis and impose that their supports do not overlap by taking: d=\begin{bmatrix}d_{1}\\ 0\end{bmatrix},\quad d_{1}>a. If \lambda\gg 1 , corresponding to the regime of deep wells and strong magnetic field, then under the constraints given above on v , H_{\lambda} has two eigenvalues in a small neighborhood of the single well ground state energy, e_{\lambda} : E_{0,\lambda}\leq E_{1,\lambda} . The two-dimensional eigenspace corresponding to this pair of eigenvalues is approximately spanned by the (nearly orthonormal) symmetric and antisymmetric linear combinations of the “atomic ground state orbitals”, \varphi^{L}(x) and \varphi^{R}(x) arising separately from v^{L}(x;\lambda) and v^{R}(x;\lambda) . The states \varphi^{L}(x) and \varphi^{R}(x) are obtained via magnetic translation of \varphi(x) [ 7 ] : \varphi^{L}(x)=e^{i\frac{\lambda}{2}bd_{1}x_{2}}\varphi(x+d)\quad{\rm and}\quad\varphi^{R}(x)=e^{-i\frac{\lambda}{2}bd_{1}x_{2}}\varphi(x-d). We introduce the magnetic eigenvalue splitting : \Delta_{\lambda}:=E_{1,\lambda}-E_{0,\lambda} (2) and the magnetic hopping coefficient , an overlap integral of the single well ground state, \varphi_{\lambda}(x) , magnetically translated to x=-d and x=+d ; [ 7 ] : \displaystyle\rho_{\lambda} \displaystyle\equiv\ \int\overline{\varphi^{L}(x;\lambda)}\ v^{R}(x;\lambda)\ \varphi^{R}(x;\lambda)\ dx. (3a) In the most basic case [ 1b ], we have \displaystyle\rho_{\lambda} \displaystyle=\int_{x\in\mathbb{R}^{2}}\overline{\varphi(x+d)}\ \lambda^{2}v(x-d)\ \varphi(x-d)\ e^{-i\lambda bd_{1}x_{2}}\ \mathrm{d}x\,, (3b) Note that \rho_{\lambda} is in general complex-valued. However, \rho_{\lambda} is real if v^{L}(x;\lambda)+v^{R}(x;\lambda) is inversion symmetric (even). For large \lambda , a formal analysis suggests that the emergent quantity, \rho_{\lambda} , controls the eigenvalue splitting \Delta_{\lambda} , and hence tunneling between two wells. In non-magnetic systems ( b=0 ) this has been proved. But as we shall see below, the magnetic case is far more subtle. The hopping coefficient also emerges in the strong binding regime for an infinite crystal Hamiltonian, H_{\rm crystal} , whose potential is a superposition of atomic wells, centered on a discrete set \mathbb{G}\subset\mathbb{R}^{2} , in the sense that \displaystyle\left[J\left(H_{\rm crystal}-e_{\lambda}\mathds{1}\right)J^{*}\right]_{nm} \displaystyle\approx\rho_{\lambda}\ e^{i\frac{b\lambda}{2}n\wedge m}\delta_{\|m-n\|,d_{0}},\quad n,m\in\mathbb{G}. (4) Here, d_{0} , the minimal distance within \mathbb{G} , is strictly positive and the minimal next-nearest-neighbor distance is uniformly bounded away from d_{0} . The operator J relates functions on the continuum with vectors whose amplitudes are indexed by \mathbb{G} ; see [ 8 ] . Previous work Upper