Indistinguishability in general probabilistic theories

John H. Selby, Victoria J. Wright​, Máté Farkas, Marcin Karczewski, Ana Belén Sainz · 2024

Read Indistinguishability in general probabilistic theories by John H. Selby, Victoria J. Wright​, Máté Farkas, Marcin Karczewski, Ana Belén Sainz (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-20963.txt.

Description

Abstract The existence of indistinguishable quantum particles provides an explanation for various physical phenomena we observe in nature. We lay out a path for the study of indistinguishable particles in general probabilistic theories (GPTs) via two frameworks: the traditional GPT framework and the diagrammatic framework of process theories.

Catalog record

CREATORJohn H. Selby, Victoria J. Wright​, Máté Farkas, Marcin Karczewski, Ana Belén Sainz
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE582 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-20963

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Indistinguishability in general probabilistic theories John H. Selby, Victoria J. Wright​, Máté Farkas, Marcin Karczewski, Ana Belén Sainz Abstract The existence of indistinguishable quantum particles provides an explanation for various physical phenomena we observe in nature. We lay out a path for the study of indistinguishable particles in general probabilistic theories (GPTs) via two frameworks: the traditional GPT framework and the diagrammatic framework of process theories. In the first approach we define different types of indistinguishable particle by the orbits of symmetric states under transformations. In the diagrammatic approach, we find a decomposition of the symmetrised state space using two key constructions from category theory: the biproduct completion and the Karoubi envelope. In both cases for pairs of indistinguishable particles in quantum theory we recover bosons and fermions. 1 Introduction Consider any pair of elementary particles of the same species, e.g., a pair of electrons or a pair of photons. Each of the two particles will have identical intrinsic properties such as mass, charge, and spin. If one wishes to distinguish two such identical particles, it follows that one must turn to their extrinsic properties, such as position, momentum, or relative spin direction. Quantum theory tells us, however, that pairs of identical particles reside in states with exchange symmetry , whereby exchanging the labels of the particles results in a state that is indistinguishable from the original state. Explicitly, let \mathcal{H} be the Hilbert space, with orthonormal basis \left\{\psi_{j}\right\} , describing the state of each particle. Then, the pair can be in a state \Psi=\sum_{j,k}c_{j,k}\psi_{j}\otimes\psi_{k}\in\mathcal{H}\otimes\mathcal{H} such that P\Psi=\sum_{j,k}c_{k,j}\psi_{j}\otimes\psi_{k}=e^{i\theta}\sum_{j,k}c_{j,k}\psi_{j}\otimes\psi_{k}=e^{i\theta}\Psi (1) where P is the swap operator defined by P\psi\otimes\phi=\phi\otimes\psi for all \psi,\phi\in\mathcal{H} . Since \Psi and P\Psi only differ by a global phase, the statistics given by measuring any hypothetical observable from quantum theory on either state \Psi or P\Psi would be identical, and thus, the two states cannot be distinguished. This invariance of the state 1 1 1 We say invariance here in the sense that the state is less redundantly described by a ray of projective Hilbert space, meaning the vectors \Psi and e^{i\theta}\Psi are two representatives of the same state. under exchange of the labels will form the notion of indistinguishability we will study. Namely, a collection of identical particles are indistinguishable if there is no observable difference between any relabelling of the particles. Note that under this notion of indistinguishability, models of physics considered to be classical also allow for pairs of systems to be indistinguishable. For example, consider a pair of identical point particles A and B with positions x and y and momenta p and q in \mathbb{R}^{3} , respectively. If we describe the state of the pair by the (unordered) set \{(x,p),(y,q)\} then relabelling the particles results in the same state. There is, however, a further notion of indistinguishability not satisfied by this classical example. In this notion, the two point particles can be distinguished by tracking their trajectories after some time at which the particles are first labelled. Theoretically, one can always measure their position with sufficient frequency to distinguish the particles, since they cannot occupy the same point in space and assuming they cannot travel faster than light. In quantum theory, however, there are no such trajectories. Indeed, the extrinsic properties which can be tracked in the classical case do not take fixed values that can be simultaneously observed without disturbing the state of the system at each point in time (see, e.g. Ref. [ 1 ] for an introduction to this notion of indistinguishability). Within quantum theory one can demonstrate the trajectory indistinguishability follows from indistinguishability based on exchange symmetry [ 2 ] . However, the point particle example demonstrates that this implication does not hold more broadly. In this work, the notion of indistinguishability based on exchange symmetry will remain our focus. Indistinguishable particles were described early in the development of quantum theory. For example, they provided Pauli’s solution [ 3 ] to Bohr’s question [ 4 ] of why all the electrons of an atom do not occupy the lowest energy level, which became the Pauli exclusion principle [ 5 ] , which was in turn generalised in the symmetrisation postulate [ 6 ] . Although any phase in Eq. ( 5 ) results in theoretically indistinguishable particles, empirically we have found that particles from the standard model exist only in symmetric or antisymmetric states, i.e., this phase only takes the values \pm 1 . Particles that are restricted to residing in symmetric states, such as photons and gluons, are known as bosons, while their antisymmetric counterparts, such as electrons and protons, are known as fermions. As put by Schrödinger [ 7 ] , the discovery of indistinguishable particles prompted physicists to dismiss the idea that a particle is an individual entity which retains its ‘sameness’ forever. Quite the contrary, we are now obliged to assert that the ultimate constituents of matter have no ‘sameness’ at all. There is now a great literature on the interpretation of the indistinguishability presented by quantum theory, discussing topics such as, whether indistinguishable particles can be considered as individuals and the relation to Leibniz’s principle of identity of indiscernibles (see, e.g., Refs. [ 1 , 8 , 9 ] and references therein). The information-theoretic potential of the indistinguishability of quantum particles is also now being established [ 10 , 11 ] . This work will ask what we can learn about indistinguishability in our universe by considering how indistinguishable particles would present themselves in other hypothetical theories of physics, and whether there is anything special about quantum indistinguishability viewed in this broader landscape. We will study this question in the framework of general probabilistic theories (GPTs) [ 12 , 13 ] , a class of theories derived from minimal assumptions about what procedures one can perform in a laboratory. GPTs have proven to be a versatile tool for studying both the fundamental physical and the information-theoretic characteristics of quantum and classical theories. The framework has been used, for example, to provide alternative and less abstract postulates for quantum theory [ 14 , 15 ] , to connect state space structure to degree of Bell non-locality [ 16 ] , to show equivalence between generalised noncontextuality and other notions of classicality [ 17 ] , and to demonstrate connections between non-classical features of quantum theory in a theory-independent way, including purification, reversible transformation, teleportation, and no-cloning [ 18 ] . We now extend this line of study to include indistinguishable particles. This work aims to lay the ground work for studying the possibility of indistinguishable particles in GPTs. We propose approaches define how different types of indistinguishable particles emerge from a GPT, then examine these types in various GPTs. The goal of this analysis is establishing their similarities to and differences from the quantum case, to examine in what ways quantum indistinguishability is special. We will define indistinguishable particles using two different formalisms for the GPT framework. The first, more traditional approach describes GPTs by assigning to each system a state and effect space that are subsets of a real vector space (see, e.g. [ 12 ] ), while the second presents these concepts via a diagrammatic formulation of category theory, resulting in more

Read the complete text