Effect of negative triangularity on SOL plasma turbulence in double-null L-mode plasmas

K. Lim 1,2 , P. Ricci 2 , L. Lebrun 2 · 2024

Read Effect of negative triangularity on SOL plasma turbulence in double-null L-mode plasmas by K. Lim 1,2 , P. Ricci 2 , L. Lebrun 2 (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-20780.txt.

Description

Abstract The effects of negative triangularity (NT) on boundary plasma turbulence in double-null (DN) configurations are investigated using global, nonlinear, three-dimensional, flux-driven two-fluid simulations. NT plasmas exhibit suppressed interchange-driven instabilities, resulting in enhanced confinement and lower fluctuation levels compared to positive triangularity (PT) plasmas.

Catalog record

CREATORK. Lim 1,2 , P. Ricci 2 , L. Lebrun 2
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-20780

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Effect of negative triangularity on SOL plasma turbulence in double-null L-mode plasmas K. Lim 1,2 , P. Ricci 2 , L. Lebrun 2 Abstract The effects of negative triangularity (NT) on boundary plasma turbulence in double-null (DN) configurations are investigated using global, nonlinear, three-dimensional, flux-driven two-fluid simulations. NT plasmas exhibit suppressed interchange-driven instabilities, resulting in enhanced confinement and lower fluctuation levels compared to positive triangularity (PT) plasmas. This reduction in interchange instability is associated with the weakening of curvature effects in the unfavorable region, caused by the stretching of magnetic field lines at the outer midplane. The magnetic disconnection between the turbulent low-field side (LFS) and the quiescent high-field side (HFS) results in most of the heat flux reaching the DN outer targets. In NT plasmas, the power load on the outer target is reduced, while it increases on the inner target, indicating a reduced in-out power asymmetry compared PT plasmas. Furthermore, the analysis of power load asymmetry between the upper and lower targets shows that the up-down power asymmetry is mitigated in NT plasmas, mainly due to the reduced total power crossing the separatrix. The reduction of interchange instabilities in NT plasmas also affects the blob dynamics. A three-dimensional blob analysis reveals that NT plasmas feature smaller blob sizes and slower propagation velocities. Finally, an analytical scaling law for blob size and velocity that includes plasma shaping effects is derived based on the two-region model and is found to qualitatively capture the trends observed in nonlinear simulations. I Introduction In recent years, extensive research has been carried out to explore alternative divertor configurations (ADCs) to the single-null (SN) configuration considered for ITER, where high core plasma performance can be maintained while ensuring that heat flux levels at the targets remain within material constraints [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . Among various ADCs, the double-null (DN) configuration is particularly interesting [ 4 , 5 ] . For instance, the presence of two X-points enables power control through two radiation fronts. Furthermore, DN configurations facilitate easier access to H-mode [ 6 ] and allow for the safe installation of external heating systems on the quiescent high-field side (HFS) region, due to its magnetic disconnection from the turbulent low-field side (LFS) [ 7 , 8 ] . DN configurations can be combined with operation in negative triangularity (NT) scenarios [ 9 ] , which have recently emerged as a promising alternative to the H-mode operation in positive triangularity (PT) [ 9 ] . Experimental observations from various tokamaks have shown that NT L-mode plasmas can achieve H-mode-like confinement due to the reduced turbulence [ 10 , 11 ] with intrinsically ELM-free scenarios [ 10 , 12 , 11 , 13 ] . Moreover, recent numerical studies, including gyrokinetic [ 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 ] and fluid modeling [ 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 ] , provide evidence of reduced plasma turbulence when NT is considered. These findings underscore the viability of NT plasmas as an effective solution for power handling in fusion devices compared to the PT H-mode plasmas. In this work, we investigate the effects of triangularity on SOL plasma turbulence in DN L-mode plasmas. We first observe that SOL plasma turbulence is reduced in NT plasmas, due to the decreased interchange drive and the reduced area of the magnetic surface in the bad curvature region. Second, we compare the characteristic pressure length scale L_{p} between NT and PT plasmas, disentangling the impact of triangularity on L_{p} . Third, a comparison of the up-down power sharing asymmetry between the predictive scaling law derived in Ref. [ 22 ] and numerical measurements demonstrate that NT-DN plasmas exhibit less up-down asymmetry. Finally, we perform a three-dimensional analysis of the blob dynamics using a blob detection and tracking technique, comparing the behavior of blobs in NT and PT plasmas. In particular, we derive a theoretical scaling law for blob size and velocity that includes the effects of plasma shaping, which is found to be qualitatively consistent with numerical observations. Ultimately, our analysis enables us to assess the potential advantages of NT plasmas in DN configuration for power handling. In the present study, we leverage previous turbulent simulations in DN scenarios [ 22 ] performed using the GBS code. These simulations identified the physical mechanisms determining the power-sharing asymmetry between upper and lower outer targets in both balanced and unbalanced DN configurations. We expand this analysis by examining the effects of triangularity on SOL plasma turbulence in DN L-mode plasmas, varying plasma resistivity, heating power, and triangularity. The structure of the present paper is as follows. Section II introduces the GBS model, while Section III describes the numerical setup parameters and the magnetic equilibria used for NT and PT plasmas simulations in DN configurations. Section IV presents the numerical results, highlighting the reduction of SOL plasma turbulence and comparing analytical estimates for the pressure gradient length with nonlinear GBS simulations. Section V discusses the inner-outer and upper-lower power asymmetry at the DN targets between NT and PT plasmas. Section VI focuses on the blob analysis, illustrating the differences between NT and PT plasmas, and derives an analytical scaling law for blob size and velocity that accounts for plasma shaping effects. Finally, Section VII summarizes the conclusions. II Numerical model The investigations presented in this work are based on the three-dimensional drift-reduced Braginskii equations [ 23 ] implemented in the GBS code [ 24 , 25 ] . GBS uses a coordinate system independent of the magnetic field, allowing for the study of various magnetic configurations, such as the snowflake [ 26 ] , negative triangularity [ 18 , 20 ] , double-null [ 27 , 22 ] , and non-axisymmetric [ 28 ] configurations. It is therefore an ideal tool for investigating the effects of plasma shaping on plasma turbulence. In the present study, we focus on an axisymmetric magnetic field in the electrostatic limit without including the interaction between plasma and neutrals, although these are implemented in GBS [ 25 ] . As a result, the GBS model equations can be reformulated as follows: \displaystyle\frac{\partial n}{\partial t}=-\frac{\rho_{*}^{-1}}{B}[\phi,n]+\frac{2}{B}\bigg[C(p_{e})-nC(\phi)\bigg]-\nabla_{\parallel}(nv_{\parallel e})+D_{n}\nabla^{2}_{\perp}n+s_{n}, (1) \displaystyle\frac{\partial\Omega}{\partial t}=-\frac{\rho_{*}^{-1}}{B}\nabla\cdot[\phi,\omega]-\nabla\cdot\big(v_{\parallel i}\nabla_{\parallel}\omega\big)+B^{2}\nabla_{\parallel}j_{\parallel}+2BC(p_{e}+\tau p_{i})+\frac{B}{3}C(G_{i})+D_{\Omega}\nabla_{\perp}^{2}\Omega, (2) \displaystyle\frac{\partial v_{\parallel i}}{\partial t}=-\frac{\rho_{*}^{-1}}{B}[\phi,v_{\parallel i}]-v_{\parallel i}\nabla_{\parallel}v_{\parallel i}-\frac{1}{n}\nabla_{\parallel}(p_{e}+\tau p_{i})-\frac{2}{3n}\nabla_{\parallel}G_{i}+D_{v_{\parallel i}}\nabla_{\perp}^{2}v_{\parallel i}, (3) \displaystyle\frac{\partial v_{\parallel e}}{\partial t} \displaystyle=-\frac{\rho_{*}^{-1}}{B}[\phi,v_{\parallel,e}]-v_{\parallel e}\nabla_{\parallel}v_{\parallel e}+\frac{m_{i}}{m_{e}}\Bigg(\nu j_{\parallel}+\nabla_{\parallel}\phi-\frac{1}{n}\nabla_{\parallel}p_{e}-0.71\nabla_{\parallel}T_{e}-\frac{2}{3n}\nabla_{\parallel}G_{e}\Bigg) \displaystyle+D_{v_{\parallel e}}\nabla_{\perp}^{2}v_{\parallel e}, (4) \displaystyle\frac{\partial T_{i}}{\partial t} \displaystyle=-\frac{\rho_{*}^{-1}}{B}[\phi,T_{i}]-v_{\parallel i}\nabla_{\parallel}T_{i}+\frac{4}{3}\frac{T_{i}}{B}\Bigg[C(T_{e})+\frac{T_{e}}{n}C(n)-C(\phi)\Bigg]-\frac{10}{3}\tau\frac{T_{i}}{B}C(T_{i}) \displaystyle+\frac{2}{3}T_{i}\Bigg[(v_{\parallel i}-v_{\parallel e})\frac{\nabla_{\parallel}n}{n}-T_{i}\nabla_{\parallel}v_{\parallel e}\Bigg]+2.61\nu n(T_{e}-\tau T_{i})+\nabla_{\parallel}(\chi_{\parallel i}\nabla_{\parallel}T_{i}) \displaystyle+D_{T_{i}}\nabla_{\perp}^{2}T_{i}+s_{T_{i}}, (5) \displaystyle\frac{\partial T_{e}}{\partial t} \displaystyle=-\frac{\rho_{*}^{-1}}{B}[\phi,T_{e}]-v_{\parallel e}\nabla_{\parallel}T_{e}+\frac{2}{3}T_{e}\Bigg[0.71\frac{\nabla_{\parallel}j_{\parallel}}{n}-\nabla_{\parallel}v_{\parallel e}\Bigg]-2.61\nu n(T_{e}-\tau T_{i}) \displaystyle+\frac{4}{3}\frac{T_{e}}{B}\Bigg[\frac{7}{2}C(T_{e})+\frac{T_{e}}{n}C(n)-C(\phi)\Bigg]+\nabla_{\parallel}(\chi_{\parallel e}\nabla_{\parallel}T_{e})+D_{T_{e}}\nabla_{\perp}^{2}T_{e}+s_{T_{e}}. (6) The above equations are coupled with the Poisson equation, which avoids the Boussinesq approximation. \displaystyle\nabla\cdot\bigg(n\nabla_{\perp}\phi\bigg)=\Omega-\tau\nabla_{\perp}^{2}p_{i}, (7) where \Omega=\nabla\cdot\omega=\nabla\cdot(n\nabla_{\perp}\phi+\tau\nabla_{\perp}p_{i}) is the scalar vorticity. In Eqs. ( 1 – 7 ), the plasma variables are normalized with respect to the reference values. Specifically, the plasma density, n , the ion and electron temperatures, T_{i} and T_{e} , the ion and electron parallel velocities, v_{\parallel i} and v_{\parallel e} , and the electric potential, \phi , are normalized to n_{0} , T_{i0} , T_{e0} , c_{s0}=\sqrt{T_{e0}/m_{i}} , and T_{e0}/e , respectively. Perpendicular lengths are normalized to the ion sound Larmor radius \rho_{s0}=c_{s0}/\Omega_{ci} , where \Omega_{ci}=eB/m_{i} is the ion cyclotron frequency. Parallel lengths are normalized to the tokamak major radius, R_{0} . Time is normalized to R_{0}/c_{s0} . The

Read the complete text